HOME > Chowhound > Latin America & Caribbean >

St. Bart's restaurant recommendations

kellysan Apr 13, 2007 08:02 AM

This is our first time to St Bart's and we're looking forward to dining there. So far I've selected the following restaurants for dinner: Wall House, Eddy's, HIdeaway, K'fe Massai and Le Repaire. I know it's expensive in St. Bart's and we're not looking to break the bank there but we do enjoy food being from NYC. In any case, we would appreciate any suggestions for places to have dinner or lunch in St Bart's. Any recommendations for creole food as well? Thanks! kellysan

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
  1. ddavis RE: kellysan Apr 13, 2007 07:29 PM

    St. Barth is our absolute favorite place in the world. We go twice a year. Last went in February and have our villa and airline reservations made for June. I could talk about St. Barth's restaurants for hours, but you don't want that. I'll just give you a few suggestions. If you want much, much more or want to ask anything else about it, drop me an email at ddavis@hdbtyler.com and I'll be more than happy to talk and talk about it!

    I like all your current selections except for K'fe Massai, and we haven't been there so I just don't know. On a St. Barth board I spend some time on, it gets mixed reviews. Of course, most all of them get some bad reviews just because people are different and like different things.

    For lunch I would suggest:

    Do Brazil -- beautiful setting on Shell Beach -- expensive
    Cocolobo -- feet in the sand kind of place on Grand Cul de Sac -- inexpensive
    Le Tamarin -- near Saline Beach in a beautiful oriental garden setting -- expen-
    Le Piment -- in St. Jean village near Hideaway -- inexpensive, great paninis
    Sandbar -- on St. Jean beach at Eden Rock Hotel -- very expensive but worth
    it -- many say the best dinner on St. Barth is lunch at Sandbar
    Chez Rolande-Wishing Well -- true creole food near Flamands Beach -- inex-

    Suggestions for dinner:
    Pipiri Palace -- downtown Gustavia -- excellent seafood dishes, including
    grilled lobster -- good creole dishes -- expensive
    New Born -- a many-generation St. Barth's family's place -- fresh caught
    fish and lobster -- in Anse de Cayes -- moderate
    Le Sapotillier -- in Gustavia right across the street from Eddy's -- real French
    done absolutely beautifully -- very expensive
    Esprit de Saline -- near Saline Beach -- excellent seafood, especially raw
    dishes like tartares and carpaccios -- expensive

    These are just some of them. Inexpensive, moderate, expensive and very expensive are all relative to St. Barth's prices, which are high. Let me know if you want to know more.

    3 Replies
    1. re: ddavis
      kellysan RE: ddavis Apr 16, 2007 09:32 AM

      Thank-you for taking the time to recommend restaurants for lunch/dinner in St. Bart's. You've given us some good choices that we'll include with the other restaurants we've already selected.

      1. re: ddavis
        Margawil RE: ddavis Feb 2, 2013 01:07 PM

        Enjoyed reading your restaurant suggestions. My husband and I will be visiting St. Barths for a week this coming May. Any updates on your rest. choices? Thanks.


        1. re: Margawil
          Bkeats RE: Margawil Feb 19, 2013 10:41 AM

          Is this your first trip to SBH? If it is, welcome to one of the most fabulous places around. Plenty of great food on the island starting at the aeroport. Some of the places ddavis mentioned are gone. If you want the latest on what's happening on SBH, go to sbhonline.com. Check the forums. You will get much better advice there.

      2. Angelina RE: kellysan Apr 23, 2007 01:52 PM

        go to www.stbartstalk.com and introduce yourself there. We all LOVE this island. No matter where you eat here, it will be truely wonderful. Even JoJo Burger is good!

        Mayas to go is great as well......right across from the airport.

        I am jealous now!!! ha ha ..have fun!

        1 Reply
        1. re: Angelina
          kellysan RE: Angelina Apr 24, 2007 05:12 AM

          Thanks Angelina for the website!

        2. g
          gooseterp RE: kellysan Apr 23, 2007 01:58 PM

          I have family down there and the food can definitely be hit or miss. ddavis hit the nail on the head with his/her suggestions. Eddy's is a favorite and Eddy has been living there for a long while. The name escapes me but down the street from Flammande there is a hotel that does a great dinner with great wine. And for a great lunch spot I love Cocolobo.

          5 Replies
          1. re: gooseterp
            ddavis RE: gooseterp Apr 23, 2007 06:59 PM

            ". . . down the street from Flammande . . . " ??? Do you mean Flammands beach? If so, you must be referring to Hotel Isle de France. The restaurant there is La Case de l`Isle. And just as an item of interest, the owner of Hotel Isle de France is Fr. Charlie Nicoll, the priest at the Anglican Church!

            1. re: gooseterp
              kellysan RE: gooseterp Apr 24, 2007 05:13 AM

              We will definitely try Eddy's and Cocolobo for lunch! Thanks for the suggestions!

              1. re: kellysan
                Angelina RE: kellysan Apr 24, 2007 01:26 PM

                For a funky, chic lunch...go to the Tom Beach Hotel...La Plague.

                It is SOOOOO much fun!! They have a DJ, a fashion show...all on the beach!!

                1. re: Angelina
                  ciclista RE: Angelina Jun 16, 2009 12:08 PM

                  Ok, I know this is a 2 year old thread, but please tell me the restaurant is called "La Plage" (the beach") and not "La Plague" (the plague)?? I look forward to returning to St Barts, but I do miss Lafayette Beach Club and La Gloriette!

                  1. re: ciclista
                    ddavis RE: ciclista Jun 16, 2009 06:37 PM

                    The restaurant at the Tom Beach Hotel is La Plage.

                    How long has it been since you were on the island? Lots of changes have occurred during the past few years.

            2. k
              katetate RE: kellysan Jan 8, 2009 01:30 PM

              Wall House, K'fe Massai, Piri Palace, and Maya to go (for take-out) are all excellent. Avoid Pa Cri as it is incredibly mediocre and horribly over-priced.

              17 Replies
              1. re: katetate
                ddavis RE: katetate Jan 12, 2009 05:42 PM

                Just got back from down there. Changes since this thread started include the closing of Cocoloba and New Born. Word is the chef/owner of Pa Cri has already left the island and the restaurant will close at the end of this season. Also gone are La Gamelle, La Saladerie, Jao, Francois Plantation, Kazz 'n Blues, Au Port, O'Corner and La Gloriette.

                1. re: ddavis
                  Angelina RE: ddavis Jan 16, 2009 11:39 AM

                  I LOVED Pa Cri. The homemade pasta just melted in my mouth. Plus, the owner was gorgeous!! haa haa..

                  ddavis, say it is not true about La Saladerie!!! I loved that place for lunch.

                  1. re: Angelina
                    ddavis RE: Angelina Jan 16, 2009 05:31 PM

                    Sorry, but it is true. New places this season include Central Park, where La Gamelle used to be, and L'Isola, in the space where O'Corner was the past couple of years and where Barbecue was before that.

                    1. re: ddavis
                      Angelina RE: ddavis Jan 16, 2009 05:46 PM

                      I wish someone would take over Le Wok. I just can't stand driving past that place to Saline.....sorry..I am a snob.......ha ha ha!!

                      1. re: Angelina
                        ddavis RE: Angelina Jan 16, 2009 05:48 PM

                        I know where it is but have never been to Le Wok. My wife isn't big on any kind of oriental, so that's not one we have been to.

                        1. re: ddavis
                          Angelina RE: ddavis Jan 17, 2009 08:09 AM

                          I have never eaten there either. It just does nothing for me that food, and especially when you have so many great places to pick, I would never wind up going there. Right now I wish I could run out to Maya's to go and pickup some food! :)

                      2. re: ddavis
                        Treva RE: ddavis May 13, 2009 12:43 PM

                        Love L'Isola! Was in St. Barth last week. My starter was a beatific Burrata, Island tomato, basil and olive oil. Next a porcini risotto, then a refreshing supple pana cotta for dessert - drizzled with fine dark chocolate. Top Notch. Good service. Surrounded by beautiful couples, we were yachties in semi-boat clothes. L'Isola was so good I wondered how I had missed media coverage. Oh yeah - it's new. I was looking for ethnic dining on St. Barth and was warned away from La Vietnam, a thai place and an African (really French place). In St. Barth L'Isola - Cucina Italiana - IS ethnic dining.

                        Barthsgade, Aarhus, Midtjylland 8200, DK

                        1. re: Treva
                          Alica RE: Treva Jun 26, 2009 04:23 AM

                          Is Le Cave still there? That was a great wine store. There also used to be some pretty good sushi places there.

                          1. re: Alica
                            Beso RE: Alica Jun 27, 2009 08:02 AM

                            Yes, Alicia, La Cave is still there, although every time I go by it's closed! Baz Bar on the harbor in Gustavia is a great place for sushi, and so is La Mandala.

                            I love Le Vietnam. We usually eat there for lunch (one of the few restaurnats that is actually enclosed and air conditioned, nice in the heat of the day). They have terrific pad thai. highly recommended. I crave a little heat after all of the French food.

                            I believe the "african" place reffered to in the thread is K fe Massai, and it is not African, but the decore is. Well, sort of. It is a fabulous restaurant. The prix fixe menus are outstanding, as are the board specials. They make a killer mojito there, too.

                            1. re: Beso
                              Treva RE: Beso Jul 14, 2009 08:47 AM

                              I am glad to hear that you love Le Vietnam. I really wanted to go there, but my companions were swayed by a local know-it-all. Do they have good pho? We enjoyed Baz Bar so much we were there three nights in a row for the live music, libation and sushi. Very tolerant bartenders.

                              1. re: Treva
                                ddavis RE: Treva Jul 14, 2009 07:50 PM

                                I have read about a couple of new places in St. Barth -- both in Gustavia. Entre Doux is in the old La Gamelle space, right behind Totem. Tapas-type stuff. Harbour Saladerie in the old Jao (I think) location. Same folks as had Saladerie before it closed last year. Have not been yet, but reports are good.

                                1. re: ddavis
                                  cpenn RE: ddavis Feb 2, 2010 10:19 AM

                                  I am headed to St. Barth's next week for the 2nd time. Fell in love with the island last year! Considering Eddy's, La Mandala and "B4" (formerly Le Sapotillier) for dinner. Also, did PaCri actually close as discussed earlier?

                                  1. re: cpenn
                                    mb luvs SBH RE: cpenn Feb 2, 2010 02:15 PM

                                    La Mandala is closed....now called Bonito and its getting good reviews. Nice decor but expensive. Pretty sure PaCri is gone but I'sola is very popular if you want Italian. I also recommend the new Harbour Saladerie (yes, in the Jao location.)

                                    1. re: mb luvs SBH
                                      mb luvs SBH RE: mb luvs SBH Feb 3, 2010 03:19 AM

                                      Correction: PaCri is still open

                                2. re: Treva
                                  Beso RE: Treva Jul 15, 2009 12:45 PM

                                  I have not had the pho, but did have a simple broth/noodle soup. Had some seroius...hmmm...upset...and hubby did a soup run for medicinal purposes! Love Baz, fun! I think all of the bartenders on St. Barth's are very tolerant!

                      3. re: ddavis
                        Bkeats RE: ddavis Mar 26, 2010 07:49 AM

                        Have not been back to St Barths in 3 years and we're heading back in a couple of weeks. Is it true that Au Port is gone? I was looking forward to dinner there. Loved the place and the staff.

                        1. re: Bkeats
                          Bkeats RE: Bkeats Jul 6, 2010 07:55 PM

                          Just wanted to report that Au Port looks like a wreck. La Gloriette in Grand Cul de Sac has opened for lunch and its a wonderful spot to sit and enjoy the breeze and a planteurs.

                    Show Hidden Posts