HOME > Chowhound > Italy >
Do you create unique foods?
TELL US

florence

e
erly Apr 9, 2007 10:41 AM

Will be in Florence for 5 days in May.
Would like one great restaurant experience, and other suggestions in the moderate range.
Our friends who will accompany us for the first 4 days, simply cannot afford star rated restaurants.
So last night splurge, and the rest just good Italian food in a comfortable restaurant.
So, help!
Thanks
Bev

  1. itsolivia Apr 9, 2007 08:49 PM

    ive never been, but this was just posted today:

    http://www.chow.com/stories/10516

    have fun!

    3 Replies
    1. re: itsolivia
      b
      Barolo2007 Apr 10, 2007 03:42 AM

      I would heartily recommend a restaurant called "Ciro & Sons" in via del Giglio 28. It's not far from the Duomo; closed on Sundays. It gets very busy so booking is recommended, unless you don't mind waiting in one of the nearby bars! It's a family run restaurant - one of the sons married an American girl about 2 years ago and she works at the desk.

      If you want to book, their telephone number is (0039) 055 28.96.94.

      For your more moderate eating excursions, go to places where the locals eat - always good food at very resonable prices.

      Buone vacanze e buon appetito!

      1. re: itsolivia
        i
        Indy 67 Apr 10, 2007 04:10 AM

        If our experience eating across five trips to Florence is any guide, this list includes some a appealing possibilities. You don't mention your Italian proficiency -- especially your Italian menu proficiency -- but each of the following restaurants includes at least one person with very good English to help you through your meal.

        Trattoria 4 Leone (on the Oltrarno) is a must. We've eaten there three times in our last two trips to Florence and only once did we eat there primarily because we were in the neighborhood visiting the Pitti Palace. In warm weather, dining in the lovely outdoor courtyard is particularly pleasant.

        Ristorante La Giostra is a nice possibility, especially for a Sunday dinner when many of Florence's restaurants are closed. No outdoor dining. It is very odd to see the review identify the ravioli with Pecorino and pears as one of La Giostra's signature dishes since that's a preparation that has long been associated with 4 Leone. (Incidentally, it's delicious!) The one criticism I have of La Giostra is that the chef has a tendency to overdo; some of the preparations don't let the ingredients speak for themselves even though their quality is impeccable. One time, my husband ordered a steak preparation that included a slice of foie gras and a sauce. He was totally happy with the dish. I tasted it and thought the chef had masked spectacularly lovely Chianina beef. I ordered a much simpler preparation of veal and thought my meal was fabulous.

        Osteria de Benci: We love this place! It's the most reasonably priced of the restaurants I've mentioned so I'd definitely put this on the list when you'll be with your friend. My husband and I are still talking about a pasta we ate there with cherry tomatoes, black pepper, and grated cheese. Indoor and outdoor seating. The best way to end a meal at this trattoria is to head around the corner to Via dei Neri for wonderful gelato at Gelateria dei Neri. Delish!

        Our favorite place to eat bistecca Fiorentina is Ristorante Leo in Santa Croce. We've had this in places all across Tuscany and none equal the version at Leo. Impeccable quality ingredients. I remember an dish that consisted of nothing more than zucchini sliced thin, grilled and served with a drizzle of olive oil and shavings of Parmesean cheese. When the food is that simple, the ingredients have to be extra-ordinary. And they were. You won't go wrong putting yourself in the hands of the effusive owner/maitre d' although you'll want to make him aware of your friend's budget issues so bistecca is probably out. Again, eat your dessert around the corner only this time it will be at Vivoli.

        Vivoli used to be the best gelateria in Florence, but I think it is now equaled by others including Neri and Vestri. Still, I'll never say "no" to a chance to eat Vivoli's gelato.

        1. re: Indy 67
          e
          emiller444 Sep 29, 2007 01:08 PM

          Can anyone give me an idea of what dinner for 2 would cost at Trattoria 4 Leone, La Giostra, and Osteria de Benci? We will be traveling in northern Italy for a month and with the current state of the dollar, we will have to do some restaurant budgeting. Thanks so much for the help.

          emiller444@aol.com

      2. w
        whiner Apr 11, 2007 04:36 AM

        I love La Giostra but haven't been in years. If things are still the same, it would probably fall somewhere in between your price category desires. It was on the more expensive end for Florence, but certainly not a typical Michelin starred restaurant price. At the exchenge rate at the time, I think main courses were about 20USD

        1. d
          DavidT Apr 11, 2007 09:10 AM

          Be sure to do a search for Florence on this board. There have been many good posts about Florence here over the past fe wyears.

          1. g
            grubsessiondotcom Apr 11, 2007 06:16 PM

            I had incredible pizza at a little bakery type shop in the middle of Florence. There were no tables or anything but the pizza was served on this thick, light bread and it was incredible. I forget the exact price (1-2 Euro I think) but it was also the cheapest thing I ate in all of europe. We couldn't help ourselves and went back everyday we were there.

            I forget the name but there was a wooden sign hanging down at the entrance. Im 6'4 and only remember this bc I hit my head more than once on it.

            Good luck in finding this gold mine.

            1. m
              mirandabrooklyn Apr 14, 2007 05:05 PM

              Treat:Osteria Cinghialle Bianco - Oltrarno

              Across Ponte Vecchio -- make a right and walk about five minutes. Awesome Trattoria.
              Very local - not super cheap - but delicious.

              Cheap eats - were also at Oltrarno - Sabbatini - bright lights - cheap food - basic good Italian - just outisde the big PORTA - 4th bridge from Pontevecchio heading West.

              Local Trattoria - "Orologio" - best Firenze Steak we had! Best value!! Huge portions. Also Oltrarno

              4 Replies
              1. re: mirandabrooklyn
                Josh in San Francisco Apr 24, 2007 06:57 AM

                Gelato War here. Vivoli is by far the the best gelato in italy. besides, they're very friendly. Try the gianduia flavor. Neri is dull and unimaginitive.

                1. re: Josh in San Francisco
                  d
                  deangold Apr 24, 2007 04:31 PM

                  VIvoli is iteresting gelato, with a roughr and more rustic texture than many. But I would not call it best even if I belived in ranking food experiences. I think in Firenze Carraibe and Perche No? are both top notch as well.

                  1. re: Josh in San Francisco
                    k
                    kenito799 Apr 27, 2007 07:59 AM

                    No, Grom is much better than Vivoli. Perche No is also better and both are cheaper than Vivoli.

                    1. re: kenito799
                      k
                      kenito799 May 2, 2007 10:34 AM

                      check out this report about Grom, which is opening a store in NYC. I had the Malaga made with $30 Pedro Ximenez sherry!
                      http://www.nytimes.com/2007/05/02/din...

                2. m
                  mirandabrooklyn Apr 14, 2007 05:12 PM

                  Don't miss Gelateria Neri - Via Neri just East(behind) Uffizi. The BEST Gleato in Florence. Do not go to Vivoli. They offered overpriced gelato - and bad service. Neri had the best coffee, "frutta di bosco"(rasp/blackberry), bacio, ciolocolato and fragole - we have ever tasteded - and the nociola!!! Yum! We went everyday!!!!

                  1. d
                    deangold Apr 15, 2007 07:31 AM

                    For a higher end experience I love Osteria di Giovani on Via del Moro. Modern versions of classic dishes plus seafood. Good wine list. Not pricy for what it is. Havent been for a couple of years but Bocondivino in the Oltr'Arno was superb. Very modern and really flavorful preparations. Good game dishes.

                    For cheaper eats: Casalingha right off Santo Spirito is superb. Ppacked at lunch with studnets, local business folk, the menu changes daily and is filled with Tuscan classics. Very cheap and very good. Stick to simpler preparations and you will do great. The Fiorentina looks good but we never have tried it. Mario at the Mercato Centrale is superb. Again a daily changing menu. The specialty is Fiorentina and it is one of the best. Cheap, crowded and fun. Lots of tourists but this is a place not changed by its popularity. Expect a wait. Lunch only.

                    1. l
                      LotsC Apr 16, 2007 03:27 AM

                      Osteria de Benci is fab and well worth going to.....Trattoria Quattre Leone can be pretty hit and miss.....Vini e Vecchi Sapori on Via Magazzini is fab, authentic and pretty reasonable, other good places are the aforementioned La Casalinga and Sabatini. If you are heading up to San Miniato or just feel like something different get an outside table at Enoteca FuoriPorta very simple, gives you the opportunity to try out wines by the glass and lighter food. I hope that helps and have a lovely time.

                      1. r
                        russia Apr 18, 2007 11:47 AM

                        Hi: . Your absolute best restaurant in Florence is Tattoria Garga
                        Via Del Moro 48r
                        Telephone 239 8898 Try the Scalopine All'avocado. Desert definitely Sharon's Cheesecake. . Sharon has published a cookbook "Once Upon a Tuscan Table".Enjoy
                        and let me know how you like it.

                        1. m
                          madsab Apr 18, 2007 11:49 AM

                          Spent one of our best meals ever anywhere eating something called Drunken Pasta. I will search for the name of the resturant. but, I am sure you can find it in a fodor's recommended list.

                          3 Replies
                          1. re: madsab
                            l
                            LotsC Apr 20, 2007 02:27 AM

                            Osteria de Benci - spaghetti al' ubricone (or something similar) totally delicious. Restaurant is very good, well known, great atmosphere (forgotten name of road) but ideal place for your best restaurant - not touristy, traditional Italian food with modern touches and reasonably priced - Tomato salad with anchovies and rocket, roast chicken and potatoes, Spaghetti all' Ubricone and very very good Italian wine....one of my favourites...

                            1. re: LotsC
                              h
                              hazel1 Apr 20, 2007 09:50 AM

                              We really loved 4 Leoni as well (you MUST try the pear pasta with cream sauce - to die for!), and also had an excellent reasonably-priced meal at Antico Borgo at Santo Spirito in the Oltrano

                              1. re: hazel1
                                l
                                LotsC Apr 23, 2007 05:34 AM

                                I think you mean - Borgo Antico - which is good and reasonable; La Casalinga is a very famous authentic & ridiculously reasonable place just round the corner from the piazza santa spirito...

                          2. Josh in San Francisco Apr 24, 2007 06:59 AM

                            check my post april 5 - we just got back.
                            title is "casual pizza and pasta in florence"

                            1. c
                              cicciona Apr 29, 2007 01:42 PM

                              You should check out The Food Lover's Guide to Florence: http://www.amazon.com/Food-Lovers-Gui...

                              It's the definitive foodie guide to the city.

                              1. g
                                Gramercy Foodie May 7, 2007 08:20 AM

                                Try enotecca pinchiorri for your splurge mean (and it will be a splurge). Most amazing meal of my life, but you will pay for it.....

                                1. INNeed May 7, 2007 08:51 AM

                                  Trattoria Mama Gina's on Borgo S. Jacopo which is very close to the Ponte Vecchio has been consistently good every time we have eaten there. They have the best Tuscan Bean Dish, they speak English and everything we have ever eaten has been fabulous. We always gone for lunch not dinner and the prices have been reasonable. It is somewhat touristy given the location but it never felt that way to us. I would highly recommend it. http://www.mammagina.it/UK/index.htm

                                  1. i
                                    intrepid Sep 29, 2007 03:11 PM

                                    ive been to most of the places already posted, all good indeed, bu far better than all, is Zibibbo, garga is good, big tourist hangout out..but food is ok there, go to zibibbo..run, dont walk

                                    Show Hidden Posts