HOME > Chowhound > Manhattan >

Best cheesesteak?

LFeinberg Apr 2, 2007 07:55 AM

Hi all...who do you think has the best cheesesteak in NYC? I'm looking for great meat quality and the perfect fresh roll. Thanks!

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
  1. LFeinberg RE: LFeinberg Apr 2, 2007 09:30 AM


    11 Replies
    1. re: LFeinberg
      jakew8 RE: LFeinberg Apr 2, 2007 09:36 AM

      Woah there relax... 10:55-12:30 on a Monday is when people are usually getting things done at work that need to go out today.

      I like 99 Miles for the meat quality but I admit that the roll isn't so great. It just doesn't stand up to the grease that well. I've also tried Philly Slim's and Tony Luke's and didn't like either as much. (I know, I know, I must have hit Tony Luke's on a bad night...)

      1. re: jakew8
        seal RE: jakew8 Apr 2, 2007 09:40 AM

        Tony Luke's has never had a great cheesesteak. Their pork sandwich is very good, but the cheesesteaks are just ordinary. I'm sure I have been to many local pizza joints that serve better cheesesteaks than TL.

        Only authentic/great one in the city is at Wogie's.

        1. re: LFeinberg
          jfood RE: LFeinberg Apr 2, 2007 09:59 AM

          And let's not forget if you do not have today you have to wait 8 days. :-))

          1. re: jfood
            LFeinberg RE: jfood Apr 2, 2007 10:03 AM

            I guess my last name is a dead giveaway? hahaha. :)

            1. re: LFeinberg
              jakew8 RE: LFeinberg Apr 2, 2007 10:17 AM

              not sure--anyone who eats cheesesteak may not observe K for P, right...?

              1. re: jakew8
                jfood RE: jakew8 Apr 2, 2007 10:30 AM

                Of course we do. It's what many of us eat on days we do not eat sausage and pepper heros. Just a different spot in the sand for the line. On another thread I posted peanut butter on Matzah and it has to be Yehudah from Israel.

                My oldest was going back to college this morning after spring break and we had the first sedar last night. Go figure. It's all a matter of perspective.

                Happy Pesach to all.

                1. re: jfood
                  LFeinberg RE: jfood Apr 2, 2007 10:35 AM

                  Yum...peanut butter on matzah sounds pretty good! Happy pesach to you, as well.

          2. re: jakew8
            premier1979 RE: jakew8 Apr 15, 2007 03:57 PM

            Hey guys new to the boards. I've ate at 99 miles and didn't have a pleasant experience. I found it to be too greasy and it didn't sit well in my stomach. One of the best cheesesteaks that I've had was in Hoboken, NJ, the place is called Philly's Cheesesteak.

          3. re: LFeinberg
            nyccookie RE: LFeinberg Apr 2, 2007 09:38 AM

            I like Carl's and Wogie's.

            I hear 99 miles to Philly is fantastic but I haven't tried it yet.

            1. re: LFeinberg
              roze RE: LFeinberg Apr 2, 2007 09:38 AM

              I like 99 miles to philly the best with Carl's coming in a close second. Wogies (although I love their wings) have rolls hard as rocks and little meat. Ziggiz is decent if you really have a craving and want one they deliver really fast but not great quality.

              1. re: LFeinberg
                jfood RE: LFeinberg Apr 2, 2007 09:54 AM

                I was excited about trying Carl's a few months ago and the best I can give it is a "not bad."

              2. p
                psawce RE: LFeinberg Apr 2, 2007 09:40 AM

                Wogies is the best I've had in NYC.

                1 Reply
                1. re: psawce
                  jsmitty RE: psawce Apr 2, 2007 09:54 AM


                2. thievery RE: LFeinberg Apr 2, 2007 10:17 AM

                  wogies used to be my fav... but the quality had declined a bit. the rolls are great but they need to use more meat if going with the firmer bread. they seem to have started adding way to much oil as well... while mincing the meat to finely. nonetheless... i'd still put it at #2... and it's a restaurant with service and comfortable seating unlike most of the other contenders.

                  carl's is tops at the moment.

                  never cared for the meat or the bread (often stale-ish) at 99 miles to philly.

                  6 Replies
                  1. re: thievery
                    tpigeon RE: thievery Apr 2, 2007 11:36 AM

                    Not traditional, but I like BB Sandwich shop.

                    1. re: tpigeon
                      harrison RE: tpigeon Apr 2, 2007 01:22 PM

                      I'm with you tpigeon. I'll go to Philly for the real thing. Makes it special each time. I think the BB version is a great sandwich that stands in its own category.

                      Will hit Carl's when in desperation mode.

                      1. re: harrison
                        LFeinberg RE: harrison Apr 2, 2007 01:24 PM

                        The restaurant is called BB?

                      2. re: tpigeon
                        psawce RE: tpigeon Apr 2, 2007 01:41 PM

                        is that place still open?

                        1. re: psawce
                          thievery RE: psawce Apr 2, 2007 02:26 PM

                          still open. w. 3rd and macdougal. only 1 sandwich offered... you just decide how many you want. kaiser roll, american cheese, carmelized onions, spicy ketchup and thin, unchopped slices of steakums like meat. not a big fan myself... the sauce overpowers the meat... which i didn't find to appealing anyway. but it has it's devotees and it's unique... so worth judging for yourself.

                          1. re: thievery
                            NAtiveNewYorker RE: thievery Apr 2, 2007 03:07 PM

                            And the cupcakes are great, too.

                    2. v
                      vinouspleasure RE: LFeinberg Apr 2, 2007 04:33 PM

                      Last year I had two very good sandwiches at carl's around 33rd. Two weeks ago I had a terrible sandwich at Carl's on chambers. The meat, roll and cheese were good but the seasonings were off. It was so salty, I didn't eat the 2nd half.

                      1. guttergourmet RE: LFeinberg Apr 15, 2007 05:44 PM

                        Tony Luke's NYC has disassociated itself with the original and changed its name. The quality of their roast pork italian has sadly also left the building. Philly Slim's is too gloppy, 99 Miles is not worth the trip, Carl's is decent, haven't tried Wogies and BB is a different animal. Refuse to try Cheesesteak Factory.Mrs. GG and my daughter wouldn't let me detour last week to Philly to get the real thing on our way to D.C. :(

                        Show Hidden Posts