HOME > Chowhound > Washington DC & Baltimore >
Are you making a specialty food? Get great advice
TELL US

Where to get a wedding cake?

r
Roland Parker Mar 27, 2007 05:17 AM

Close family friend is getting married later this year, and we have been charged with getting the cake.

I have had Patisserie Poupon cakes in the past, and while the cake/buttercream icings have been terrific, it is irritating how the bakery covers their cakes with the sugar gum/fondant.

I went to two weddings in Annapolis, both which had cakes from an unknown Annapolis bakery and which were, I thought, phenomenal. They were the classic decorated wedding cake with only buttercream icing and no fondant. Any ideas as to what bakery this may have been?

How is Charm City Cakes? Having seen the show a few times the cakes look fun and while I'm sure Duff et al can do a traditional wedding cake as well, I get the distinct impression that the attraction is the creative design and not the actual cake itself, which for the most part look to be your basic vanilla or chocolate cake. I quickly searched their website and the list of flavors was long and off-putting. Ginger flavored cake? Green Tea flavored cake? Does the tiramisu refer to just the flavor of tiramisu or is the cake actually one large tiramisu?

  1. MegMD Mar 27, 2007 08:37 AM

    I'm not going to bash Duff on his cakes.... they are creative and artistic. I say purchase a $10 a slice cake from him if you want a work of art and not a culinary treat.

    http://www.sugarbakerscakes.com/

    1. amethiste Mar 27, 2007 08:55 AM

      Patisserie Poupon can do a wedding cake with buttercream. My personal favorite is the fraisier with a marzipan exterior

      1 Reply
      1. re: amethiste
        j
        jrl2929 Mar 27, 2007 09:28 AM

        I've never tasted a cake from Charm City, but I have friends who have and they say the cakes look good, but don't taste as good.. The best cakes I've had, and this place has been around for years, is Fisher's in Old Ellicott City

        Fisher's Bakery
        www.fishersbakery.com
        8143 Main St
        Ellicott City, MD 21043
        (410) 461-9275

        Hope this helps

      2. m
        MrsWheatie Mar 27, 2007 11:13 AM

        We insisted that our cake was buttercream and it came as part of package for our reception. The thing with fondant is that it wont melt, so you should check if it will be displayed outside. Here is a list of bakers from Washingtonian Magazine.
        http://www.washingtonian.com/articles...

        1. pagoda girl Mar 27, 2007 11:33 AM

          I got a cake from Charm City cakes for my mom's 60th birthday bash and it was lovely and fun, and all three of the layers were quite yummy, as were all the little sample nibbles we got to help us decide on the flavors.

          1. g
            gm_smith Mar 27, 2007 04:59 PM

            Well, Charm City Cakes is really nice if you have $550+ to spare. Their cakes START at $550. Before his Food Network show, they started at $175. I think the other suggestions will serve you well!

            1. p
              pigtowner Mar 28, 2007 07:38 AM

              If you your friends are adventurous, you might try the Croquembouche from Patisserie Poupon. I had it for my wedding and it was fabuous! Everyone loved it and thought it was super cool and still (6 months later) keeps telling me how great it was.

              But...you should definately arrange a tasting at PP anyway. They're very nice and you get to try all the different kinds, and you definately don't have to get the fondant.

              I also went to a Charm City tasting with my older sister and I thought the cake was very good. Definately expensive, but very tasty cake. At the tasting you get sent away with a little box of about 8 different flavor combos, you can request any you like. And Duff was very nice and spent lots of time with us. My sister ended up getting the strawberry cake from PP anyway, which is totally delicious.

              I haven't heard of anything in Annapolis, but my friend who just got married got her (very small cake) from a bakery in Columbia (I think) that is also french and it was very yummy cake too.

              1. b
                baymd5 Mar 29, 2007 10:41 AM

                It may have been Graul's Market.

                We used them for my daughter's wedding last summer. You can call them and they will give you free cupcake samples of their standard cakes and icings.

                Our caterer recommended them as they are also very reasonable. They deliver and set up for a nominal fee in the Annapolis area.

                My daughter brought them pictures of cakes she liked and they created just what she wanted. Everyone raved about the taste of the cake.

                http://www.graulsmarket.com/default.aspx

                1. c
                  cakeguy Mar 29, 2007 01:11 PM

                  Give Sugarbakers Cakes a try. They specialize in cakes that taste as good as they look. They also provide a free anniversary cake on your first anniversary. No need to keep the top tier in your freezer for a year. The free tasting and consultation was fun.
                  www.sugarbakerscakes.com

                  1 Reply
                  1. re: cakeguy
                    sistereurope Mar 29, 2007 06:12 PM

                    Yes, I agree with the Sugarbakers recommendation. We got our wedding cake from them (second wedding, discriminating groom!). They were reasonable and the cake was yummy...

                  2. j
                    jrussd Mar 30, 2007 06:00 AM

                    I'd second all of the recommendations for Patisserie Poupon and Sugarbakers. They seeem to be the top two, if you're going for taste and not presentation. For the presentation, see if you can get in to Charm City Cakes. I'm getting a cake there for a friend's birthday and you need to order at least several months in advance and even then you're not guaranteed to get a cake. The Food Network Show, while creative and entertaining, has really made Duff's shop very selective.

                    Show Hidden Posts