Psst... We're working on the next generation of Chowhound! View >
HOME > Chowhound > Cookware >
Mar 24, 2007 02:27 PM

Need advice on Best Electric Griddle

My pancakes and french toast are either under or over done so I think I should invest in an electric griddle. Any tips on which one to purchase? Thanks for your advice.

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
  1. I got the cuisenart griddler for my wedding shower. It's a panini press that has a flat side, too. The whole thing flips open to lay flat like a regular griddle, but it has two sides so you can do bacon on one side and pancakes on the other, or pancakes on both sides. I really like it. Haven't used it much yet, but no problem so far. It got good reviews (I researched it a lot before adding it to my registry), and I would recommend it.

    1. I think electric griddles/frypans might have made sense years ago when they were built well with well adjusted thermostats but to spend money on them today would be a mistake.

      The best way to get consistent results with pancakes & French toast is the same way to get to Carnegie Hall - practice, practice, practice. A "test cake" adds a bit of time to morning cooking but helps to ensure the rest of the batch looks ready for a magazine.

      Of course there is a "trick" that will help is know the proper temperature. There are several sources that state the standard temperature range that frying occurs at is 350-375, most pancake recipes suggest a griddle of 400 and all cookbooks will recommend the 'water drop test'. I like using a non-contact thermometer:

      Depending on the ingredients & temperature of the batter, the amount of oil and mass of the skillet / griddle I've had good results between 380-410.
      It is very helpful to watch the rate of temperature change as the pancakes cook, crepes heat through about 3x faster than "IHOP" style risers...

      1. The original comment has been removed
        1. I also have a Presto. Easy to clean, non stick, easy to slip back into the closet when done (we don't have griddle breakfasts enough for it to warrant kitchen space). The size is perfect- I like being able to do a large batch of pancakes at once, instead of 4 at a time in a regular sized skillet.

        2. I can't say it is the best, but we have been using the same Farberware electric griddle since the mid-70's. It has a thick, un-coated aluminum griddle area. It has worked well for us and we still use it occasionally. I suppose there are better ones available these days but we have never had cause to replace it.

          1. I did similar research about a year ago and bought a Presto Tilt & Drain. It is huge and great for making pancakes. Since then, most of my family has bought the same grill after seeing it in action.