Psst... We're working on the next generation of Chowhound! View >
HOME > Chowhound > General Topics >
Mar 20, 2007 05:01 PM

Coca Cola will go back to the original formula

Coke said they will use real sugar instead of corn syrup for Passover. This is the real coke .So why does Coca Cola sell and tell us it is the Original formula and use corn syrup as a sweetner instead of sugar. (Real Original Formula)The NY Post also said that they stop using real sugar in the 1980's. The NY Post also said that is a a less sweeter taste with sugar. I don't know about the rest of the CH but you bet i will get my hand on a few cans.

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
  1. Those of us living in the Southwest are lucky enough to often get our hands on the real deal, Coke from Mexico, made with sugar. Sadly, the Coke bottlers down there are starting to switch to HFCS too; there's a distinct difference between the two, and the stuff from Mexico is WAY better.

    2 Replies
    1. re: JK Grence the Cosmic Jester

      Yes, we get Mexican Coke here in San Francisco as well...but a warning to those who buy it with their luncheon does NOT have a screw off top!!!
      So, remember to have them open it where you bought it..or find your old 'church key'
      I prefer this is sort of 'dryer' and tangier!

      1. re: ChowFun_derek

        You can get Mexican Coke in the Mexican grocery stores in the Pilsen neighborhood in Chicago. I would guess that you can find it pretty much everywhere that has a large Mexican population. I only drink real Coke (vs diet) once every few months or so, but I greatly prefer the real sugar formula.

    2. The reason Coke stopped using sugar in the US is that the government has a floor price on sugar to "protect" the US sugar industry from foreign competition. It became cheaper for Coke, the all American soft drink, to use corn syrup rather than pay artifically inflated sugar prices. A benefit for Coke is that, since corn syrup is cheaper than sugar, they make more profit and 99% of the American public can't tell the difference.As always it all comes down to money.

      3 Replies
      1. re: Vint1955

        That's really interesting Vint -- I never knew that. So is the protectionist policy toward sugar part of the overall reason for the widespread ascent of HFCS? That would make sense... WOW!

        1. re: Vint1955

          I've heard the explanation about protecting the US sugar industry before, but I believe the big winner is the US corn producers. The amount of corn grown in this country is far larger than the few sugar cane growers. I imagine they make a lot of money growing corn that is processed into HFCS.

          1. re: jackrugby

            The corn industry (and therefore the corn lobby) in the US is absolutely huge. Read "The Omnivore's Dilemma".

        2. I have to cop to being a little paranoid sometimes, but I think the whole "New Coke/Old Coke/Classic Coke" thing way back in the 80s (?) was really a misdirection ruse to allow Coca Cola to switch from sugar to HFCS.

          1 Reply
          1. This happens every Passover. The bottles have a yellow cap.

            1 Reply
            1. re: KTinNYC

              Hate to say it but I picked up some Passover Coke and I gotta tell ya I prefer the Coke with HFCS, not sure if my taste buds have aged too much(I grew up on 6.5 oz ikes in the traditional bottle) but I was disappointed with the sugar sweetened Coke...

            2. Um ... I hate to break it to you, but Coca Cola has made kosher Coke for Passover evey year since the switch to HCFS in the mid-80s.

              Also, there's ZERO chance of Coke going back to the original formula, because the ORIGINAL formula for Coca Cola contained five ounces of coca leaf per gallon of syrup, yielding an estimated nine milligrams of cocaine per glass. At that dosage, there's no way in hell the FDA would allow Coke to be sold over the counter.

              6 Replies
              1. re: mclaugh

                Bet it sure would taste good! :-))

                1. re: mclaugh

                  Yes that is is before my time. The real Coke.

                  1. re: FAL

                    Ok, so last night was the first time hearing about this buzz so I had to try it today. In between break at work I went to the local Ralph's and lo and behold 4 bottles of the yellow cap with the UOP sign. I was enthused and downright anxious- I bought all four bottles (they even had a buy 3 get 1 free).

                    I got home, made me a bologna sandwich (like as a child) and took a sip of what I expected to be my childhood. WHAM! It was that coke taste I really missed and adored as a child. Somewhere along my time, I realized coke didn't have that kick at the end anymore and until the other day didn't realize why. It was the sucrose replaced with fructose. It really does taste that much better and I don't think I can go back to drinking fructose coke again.

                    So I gave 1 bottle to my boss at work, 1 to my GF Danimal, 1 in the fridge, and 1 in the garage for later. I think I will stock up just in case I have cravings until next Passover.

                    All I can say is, nostalgia-overload!


                  2. re: mclaugh

                    Not quite. Coca Cola has been 100% coca free since 1929, and even before that, by 1902, had reduced the levels to less than 1/400 grain per ounce of syrup or .06 oz./25 million gallons of syrup.


                    1. re: GVDub

                      One would think that with all the competition in the soft drink market these days, Coke would do all it could to retain loyal customers by keeping flavor at its best. It seems that Coke drinkers prefer real sugar and would pay for it therefore offsetting the cost of manufacturing with the real thing. I loved the taste of old Coca Cola and stopped drinking it when they started the whole "new" coke vs Classic Coke in the 1970s. it just never tasted right after that.

                      1. re: hot tamale

                        Hmmmm..I realize that people of all ages drink Coke, but I wonder whether the key demographic is younger folks who grew up on HFCS, and have absolutely ZERO idea that Coke ever tasted different....In other words, there's no nostalgia among teens and 20-somethings for Coke as it tasted in the "old days"