HOME > Chowhound > Manhattan >

Discussion

NY Pizza for Chicago Visitors

My mom and brother are coming into town in March for a long weekend.

I'd like to take them out for "authentic" New York City pizza, but don't want to be hassled with long lines/waits (Lombardi's, Grimaldi's).

I'm hoping you can mention places that are a bit more off the beaten path where they can still enjoy a good slice.

I'd prefer to stay in Manhattan (they are staying in the UES, but we're willing to take the subway) and I'd like something with a little more ambiance than your favorite take-out/delivery place.

TIA!

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
Delete
  1. how about arturo's? ny pizza, usually not ever too long of a wait.

    3 Replies
    1. re: lisabnyc

      Arturo's is terrific. We were there on Sunday afternoon. We got there at 3:00, when they were just starting up for the evening, and by 3:30, the place was pretty packed. Definitely worth going to!

      1. re: hiddenboston

        Love, love, love Arturo's -- if atmosphere is a consideration then this is the place. One thing, though -- I don't believe they do slices.

    2. If you are on the UES, its a short bus or cab ride up to Patsy's at 1st Ave and 117th St. Arguably the best pizza in Manhattan and no long lines.

      1. I second Patsy's on the UES (this location is the original and all the other Patsy's around NYC pale in comparison), however, Arturo's is also damn good and in a much better neighborhood (the edge of SOHO and the Village) for walking around.

        6 Replies
        1. re: ultbil

          Patsy's is the right move. It's delicious and historic...perfect for a tourist visiting NYC. (It was the first pizzeria to sell slices. It broke away from Lombardi's, the original NYC pizza. But Lombardi's has since moved from its original location and has lost a step...so not the best place for tourists.)

          (The cast of the Godfather ate at Patsy's to warm up for the movie. They sat in the back room according to their new roles, with Talia Shire serving all the male actors. Sinatra also loved the place.)

          1. re: NAtiveNewYorker

            wrong place - sinatra loved the PATSY'S restaurant on w56th.

            otoh being they are on the ues and seeking good ny pizza, i think no question they should go there for pizza too.

            1. re: mrnyc

              Sinatra went to BOTH Patsy's. Just ask the pizza chef.

              And you are right. Easy to visit from the UES.

            2. re: NAtiveNewYorker

              Some more movie trivia. In the movie, "The Warriors," the scene where the guys go to meet the girl gang, The Lizzies, and have a shoot out was filmed in the back room at Patsy's uptown. The scene had nothing to do with Patsy's and Patsy's was never shown in the film. It was just the right sized space during a lack of regular studio facilities in the city.

              1. re: NAtiveNewYorker

                Lombardi's expanded, they have not moved.

                1. re: shorts

                  Wrong. They started out in the middle of the block accross the street. (It's now a bar.)

                  http://www.lombardispizza.com/history...

            3. Please try Posto on 1st avenue in the teens or Franny's in Brooklyn on Flatbush avenue. Posto's room is comfy, with wooden booths and a very homey feel. Franny's is a bit more NY, small hip bar and a touch bigger. I like arturo's a lot as well. I personally think grimaldi's and lombardi's are no better, perhaps even inferior to posto and franny's. Not sure why posto does not make some of the pizza lists, but they are remiss as they continue to forget this great spot. The andouille pie is great. Overall both places, creative and standard ingredients(a good idea for both more conservative and more foodie crowds), good sauce and crunchy crust.

              1 Reply
              1. re: jsmitty

                POSTO, 310 Second Ave. at 18th street. Two other places operated by the same people, GRUPPO, 186 Ave. B between 11th St. and 12th. and VEZZO, 178 Lexington Ave. at 31st. street.

              2. I know you prefer the city. That said, if you're open to Brooklyn, Spumoni Gardens (thick, not thin brick oven variety). I usually get take out from Lombardi's, because the service at Adrienne's downtown is poor (they are supposed to have good pizza). I also walk across the Brooklyn Bridge to the pizza place (brick oven) on the other side (nice to do with out of towners when the weather is nice).