Log In / Sign Up
HOME > Chowhound > Manhattan >
Hungryfina Feb 21, 2007 06:12 PM

Nobu 57 (Long Report)

Quickly:
Must Order - Toro Tartar, Fluke Sashimi, Shrimp tempura salad with ponzu, Black Cod with Miso, and, Milk Chocolate Yuzu cake
Didn't like - Creamy Spicy Crab
Overall - A-/B+ very fun place to have dinner, lively but not too crazy, food was for the most part delicious, very nice servers, and I left completely stuffed

Full Review:
I was quite surprised at Nobu 57’s casual vibe. There is no question that it was busy from the time we arrived at 9:15 until we left at 11:30, but it was not the glitzy, mad house I was expecting. Ordering was easy (I had already decided ahead of time), and for the most part we loved every dish we had.

Each dish came one at a time, and the entire meal was very well paced. We started with the Toro Tartar with Caviar, followed by the Yellowtail Sashimi with Jalapeño, the Fluke Sashimi with Dried Miso, and finally the Tuna Sashimi Salad. The toro tartar is so finely minced that it almost tastes pureed, but just made it seem even more indulgent and rich. On the other hand, the tuna sashimi salad was much less delicate than I was expecting and definitely the largest of our cold dishes. In my opinion, the standout was the simple fluke sashimi (perhaps because it was the only item I had never had elsewhere).

Next we moved on to the hot dishes, which were equally delicious although harder to enjoy as I got more and more full. Our first hot dish, the Rock Shrimp Tempura Salad with Ponzu Sauce, was my favorite course of the entire night. I am not usually a fan of fried foods, but the shrimp was so crisp on the outside, wonderfully moist inside, and perfectly paired with the light salad and zingy ponzu sauce. This salad was followed by the only disappointment of the night – the Creamy Spicy Crab. I had read a number of raving reviews about the crab, and I was quite surprised to discover that the crab came absolutely drenched in an overly salty and not very spicy sauce. We finished on a better note with a beautiful display of sizzling mushrooms and, of course, the buttery and delicious Black Cod with Miso (better than Koi’s in my opinion).

Finally, I expected that a sushi restaurant would not pay much attention to dessert, but I was very impressed with what we ordered. The favorite dessert was heavily debated at our table. I was a fan of the Milk Chocolate Yuzu cake (a small red cake composed of milk chocolate, hazelnut, and layers of praline with a scoop of ice cream on the side), but my dinner companion relentlessly voted for the Banana Caramel Soy Toban Yaki (caramelized bananas tossed with chopped pecans and toped with ice cream). Not to be left out, the Kama Meshi 57 (Vanilla rice pudding) was also quite good and the Catalan Ice Cream that was served on top was by far the best of ice creams. Overall we finished dinner extremely full, but also extremely pleased. Too bad San Francisco doesn’t have a Nobu yet!

For Pictures feel free to check out my blog: http://savorymorsels.blogspot.com/200...

  1. p
    Pismo10 Apr 25, 2008 05:15 AM

    Nobu 57 is great, easy to make reservations if you are flexible. Food is superb, even the sushi, which they are not known for as the staff will tell you, was very good, better the 2nd time I went. Fun, lively atmosphere but not too much. Minimal attitudes, great service. Great house beer.

    Share with your friendsX