HOME > Chowhound > San Francisco Bay Area >

BBQ Man Cafe in Menlo Park.

David Sloo Feb 21, 2007 10:22 AM

I went to BBQ Man in Menlo Park soon after it replaced the greasy spoon that was regrettably there for years. Disappointed at everything I had that first time, I hadn't been back till yesterday. BBQ Man is a expanded, fixed version of the proprietor's former two carts in the area.

I'm glad I went, because, although not wonderful, BBQ Man was considerably better than I remembered. The prices were fair, and it is exceptionally convenient to Willow / 101 / Dumbarton Br.

I had the 3-meat platter, which lets you combine any two meats, a choice of two sides, and two half-slices of garlic-and-butter on toast. I had two ribs, a pile of pulled pork, and a pile of brisket.

All three meats were slathered with sweet, mildly spicy, thick barbecue sauce. Next time, I will ask for sauce on the side. The sauce is unexceptional and likely a commercial concoction.

The ribs, like almost all adult pork- and beef ribs, I found dull. There are certainly ways to slow-smoke ribs, get the tendon- and bone flavors into the meat, and not dry out the meat. To their credit BBQ Man's ribs were not dry -- some posters on Yelp have had different experiences.

The pulled pork was just fine, clearly cooked slowly, very moist, and exceptionally tender.

The brisket was actually quite good, and it would make a tasty, simple sandwich. Like the pulled pork, it proved extremely tender.

My sides were coleslaw of the blandest and most forgettable possible character. And beans. The beans surprised me: whole, rich-maroon kidney beans with some red fresh pepper. They reminded me of kidney beans that I've had in all-bean chili made by a west Texan to prove that the chile family can admit beans. I had expected the usual pintos or great northern beans, but I got big kidney beans instead. Good for BBQ Man.

The whole meal, which easily fed two, was $15. This is, locally, not a bad price.

I would go back specifically for a brisket sandwich (applying sauce myself) and a side of beans.

Ribs are much better at the barbecue that Mike runs behind New Sweet Home Church nearby (weekends only). Back-a-yard across the freeway has better quality pork (in a completely different style).

BBQ Man Cafe, 555 Willow, Menlo Park.

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
  1. p
    P. Punko RE: David Sloo Feb 21, 2007 09:17 PM

    I remember their brisket being the best of the bunch there, and the sauce is a doctored commercial one, definitely for the side. I realize some people like a lake of sauce, but it definitely needs to be on the side here.

    1. k
      katg RE: David Sloo Feb 21, 2007 10:13 PM

      thanks for the report. i've always driven by this place and always wondered what it's like. perhaps if i'm in the mood for bbq, i'll check it out.

      1. j
        JSB RE: David Sloo Feb 22, 2007 06:25 AM

        I went a month or so ago for lunch and have had fewer more disappointing meals. THe brisket was dry and crumbly and the sauce of no redeeming quality. I can't remember what else I had because none of it was good. I didn't even finish; but not because there was an overabundance of food. The sides were awful - I didn't expect the beans to be simply kidney beans with chunks of ground beef, ugh. Maybe it was that it had just opened or something, but I have no plans to go back when there are other quality places nearby (Uncle Frank's etc.)

        5 Replies
        1. re: JSB
          P. Punko RE: JSB Feb 22, 2007 10:38 AM

          Uncle Franks has its own problems (I like them but...)- they clearly have Mesquite or some other acrid wood in too high proportion in their smoking mixture leading to a sour taste. The sour taste is more obvious in leftovers.

          1. re: P. Punko
            jeffypop RE: P. Punko Feb 22, 2007 02:28 PM

            where is Uncle Franks? I've also driven by BBQ Man many times and wondered if it was any good.

            I like BCC (aka Jon Jon's). It's down in San Jose, I think on Oakland Rd. Pretty good, although it doesn't match up to the BBQ in Texas.

            1. re: jeffypop
              P. Punko RE: jeffypop Feb 22, 2007 03:04 PM


              Uncle Frank's is in the back of a bar called Francesca's, you enter through the bar and can order drinks at the bar.

              2135 Old Middlefied Way
              Mountain View, CA 94043
              (650) 964-4476

            2. re: P. Punko
              Robert Lauriston RE: P. Punko Feb 22, 2007 02:33 PM

              Mesquite charcoal is neutral, not acrid. What's distinctive about it is that it burns very hot.

              1. re: Robert Lauriston
                P. Punko RE: Robert Lauriston Feb 22, 2007 02:38 PM

                Mesquite chips are extremely acrid for longer smoking. Definitely great for grilling, not for smoking. Very sour. This is the predominant smoke taste at Uncle Frank's (to my palate).

          Show Hidden Posts