Psst... We're working on the next generation of Chowhound! View >
HOME > Chowhound > General Tristate Archive >
Feb 6, 2007 04:33 AM

looking for great lobster roll, and tuna hero?

will be at hampton bays, amagansett, montauk point area,
any good fruit and vegetable markets out there now,

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
  1. There is a fruit/vegetable market on the east side of Amagansett, north side of the road, that appeared in the Seinfeld show. It may not be open in the winter.

    If you want GREAT lobster rolls, you will have to go to Red's Eats in Wiscosset, ME. It is a large hotdog roll, overflowing with the meat of more than one lobster, served with butter sauce or mayo on the side, all for about $16. There is NOTHING like that on LI.

    1. You must go to Lunch in Montauk. Great Roadside eatery with lobster roll and other seafood fare. Think seafood diner. wonderful.

      3 Replies
      1. re: Janefoodie

        Lobster Roll (aka Lunch) Closed til May. All farm stands closed til asparagus appears (Easter?) Milk Pail in Bridgehampton/Sagaponack is open but just apples and pies I think. And great hot cider. Not open every day. This time of the year, I detox from great fresh fruit and vegetables, I buy root veggies at the grocery store and roast in the oven. That way, when I see local asparagus and spinach, which is the first crop, it tastes that much better! You may want to stop in Citarellas in Watermill and/or Easthampton, if you want some fancy produce.
        Tuna Hero, not sure what you mean. If you want a great sandwich with fresh local tuna, go to O'Murphys and see if they have their Tuna Melt on the special menu, it's one of the best sandwiches I've ever had. But they didn't have it last week, that's the trouble with local and fresh!!!!

        1. re: Janefoodie

          There is also a 'Lobster Roll' in Baiting Hollow that may be open. It is on the North Road, east of Edwards Avenue. This is the north shore version of 'Lunch'.

          1. re: Fred19

            They were closed last month, I think they've reopened but probably not every day. And they like to say they're in Baiting Hollow, but they're actually a little east of there, in Riverhead.

        2. I like the lobster roll at the sea food market in Wainscott - the name of which I do not remember - to go only.

          1 Reply
          1. re: MMRuth

            Believe it or not, it's called the Seafood Shop. That's probably why you can't remember!

          2. I thought the lobster roll at the Baiting Hollow Lunch wasn't very good. It was frozen lobster, lots of filler, lots of mayonaisse, and pretty small plus not cheap. I prefer their clam chowder and the raspberry pie from Briermere.