HOME > Chowhound > Home Cooking >
What are you cooking today?
TELL US

Black & White Cookie Recipe

s
sunnygordy Feb 5, 2007 11:19 AM

Help! I'm trying to find a recipe for the classic NYC deli cookie, the Black & White. I've tried a few that I've found, even the one from Zabar's, but none seem to be hitting the right spot. They're either too delicate or too dense. I'm looking for just the right balance of cakey goodness & something w/ a crumb strong enough to stand up to being frosted.
I'll take any help I can get! Thank you!

  1. Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
Delete
  1. r
    rockycat Feb 6, 2007 06:19 AM

    My problem has been finding a chocolate fondant recipe of the right consistency. Either it's way too drippy or it seizes up before it gets out of the bowl. Had that problem a few years ago when I was making a pizza pan sized black & white as a "birthday cake/cookie." If I remember correctly, I used the recipe from Molly O'Neill's "New York Cookbook." I liked everything except the chocolate icing.

    1. bluesman13 Feb 6, 2007 06:51 AM

      I think the cookie part is the hard part. My recollection of NYC black and whites is that there is nothing special about the frosting. I've made the Martha Stewart recipe and didn't find the cookie/cake to be the same as I remembered it.
      Here: http://www.marthastewart.com/page.jhtml?type=content&id=recipe2694

      This one looks pretty cakey: http://allrecipes.com/recipe/black-an...

      Here in Minnesota, I am able to get a packaged product from Zabars with "mini" blacka nd white cookies. I guess it's as close as I'm going to get.

      Would you post back here when you find a good recipe?

      1. j
        jujuthomas Feb 6, 2007 10:51 AM

        My sister and I were just wishing for a recipe last week! My granny used to make 'em, but neither of us has her recipe. I'm going to have to call my aunt...

        1. w
          WineWidow Feb 6, 2007 10:58 AM

          I have a great recipe for them, but it's at home. It's in my Dr. Oetker baking book, and they're called "amerikaners". Will try to remember to post the recipe tonight or tomorrow.

          1. k
            KeriT Feb 6, 2007 11:00 AM

            Never tried the recipe, but I like this bake shop's black and white cookies, it's on the UES of NYC. Their recipe is at this link (if it works)

            http://glasersbakeshop.com/articles.htm

            1. w
              WineWidow Feb 6, 2007 11:05 AM

              this Marions Kochbuch recipe looks about right (although I'd use butter instead of margarine), check it out at http://www.marions-kochbuch.com/recip...

              1. v
                virtualfrolic Feb 6, 2007 12:33 PM

                How funny! I was thinking the same thing a few weeks ago. I tried the recipe from Sara Moulton (also on Epicurious), but was unhappy with the frosting. The cake/cookie part was great. Perfect consistency and taste. The frosting? yuck!! Too lemony and pasty for my taste. I'm still on the search for the perfect frosting - I'm thinking the boiled water and conf. sugar is the way to go.

                Here's my attempt - and sort of failure. I put nutella and strawberries on the cookies to make them chocolate shortcakes! I wanted the B&W cookies for a party, and couldn't serve the cookies with the gross frosting. Keep in mind, I NEVER throw things out - the frosting for these went straight to the garbage.

                http://virtualfrolic.blogspot.com/2007/02/last-but-not-least.html

                The recipe I tried:
                http://abcnews.go.com/GMA/Recipes/story?id=1396777

                P.S. Zabar's recipe is online. I haven't made it yet though, so don't know if it'll really taste as good as the real thing!
                http://www.recipezaar.com/50220

                Show Hidden Posts