Psst... We're working on the next generation of Chowhound! View >
HOME > Chowhound > Home Cooking >
Feb 4, 2007 04:46 PM

Freezing homemade Sister Schubert rolls??

Usually when I bake bread, I make it all the same day, whatever we're going to eat. But I am making Sister Schubert rolls (not out of the freezer but from scratch) and have a dilemma. I think the frozen ones at the grocer are unbaked, but I'm not positive. Does anyone know? I'm a little worried about freezing the dough unbaked. I don't usually like to freeze this kind of thing, but I really have more rolls than we can eat (no, strike that - than we SHOULD eat) in one evening. And my daughter loves, loves, loves them, so having a stash in the freezer would be incredibly helpful.

The store-bought bake time for the rolls (after thawing) is 15-20 minutes. The bake time for the homemade rolls is also 15-20 minutes.

If anyone has made the actual Sister Schubert Parkerhouse rolls from scratch at home and has experience w/ freezing them, I would welcome your guidance. Also anyone who has good luck with freezing homemade bread with suggestions as to whether they would be best frozen unbaked, partially baked, or completely baked.

Thank you!!

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
  1. Well, I never got an answer to this, so I just had to wing it. I made 4 pans. Two of them I froze unbaked. One was eaten. Another baked pan is going to be frozen. I'll see how they work out.

    Prying the frozen ones out of the pan wasn't fun & left some dough in the bottom (I didn't freeze them in the pans 1) because it takes up too much room and 2) because I wanted to vacuum-seal them to protect them from freezer burn. So I froze them a few hours and then removed them from the pans to vacuum seal them.

    I guess I'll post on the results when we use them if I remember or if anyone is interested.

    1. OK, help. I hope someone besides me actually replies to this thread - someone who has helpful information, that is!! :)

      I froze one pan of the rolls pre-baked. They turned out pretty decent. The ones I froze unbaked - UGH. They were flat & lifeless.

      These are Parkerhouse yeast rolls. I let the unbaked ones rise and then froze them.

      I have never had success freezing unbaked yeast dough. Can anyone out there give me some advice that will save me from this curse?

      2 Replies
      1. re: luv2bake

        Freezing completely unbaked dough has not worked well for me. I don't know what Sister Schubert rolls are like. I freeze homemade rolls (including parkerhouse rolls) by baking them until they are just starting to brown. Take them out of the oven when they are still pale. Cool them and freeze in whatever manner you usually use. They usually take afound 15 minutes or so in a hot oven after they come out of the freezer. If you let them get brown before freezing, the crust separates and they get overly brown.

        1. re: wally

          Thanks, Wally. I guess the source of my confusion is that when I buy them frozen at the store, they are completely unbaked. I just can't figure out how Sister Schubert can do that, but I can't even when I use her recipe!

          The one pan that I baked & froze, I didn't bake quite as long as the pan we ate. I do think I baked it a little too long, though, the first time. They were still good but could have been better; I'm going to follow your pale baking advice next time.

      2. I missed this thread the first time around, so I hope my replying now doesn't make you feel like you're talking to yourself!! :-) Did you try to bake them from frozen or did you let them rise again and then bake?

        2 Replies
        1. re: Katie Nell

          I actually baked them frozen because we remembered at the last minute.

          The ones I buy at the store are frozen, unbaked, and I don't have to let them warm or rise before baking. (You're supposed to let them thaw, but we don't always do that!) And they always turn out wonderful.

          Any idea how I can accomplish that? Although at this point it's probably principle more than anything else!

          By the way, thanks both for your replies. I haven't checked into CH for a few days - things have been hectic!

          1. re: luv2bake

            I don't know... I've only had success with doing a first short rise, freezing, thawing, and then a longer rise with yeast breads and pizza dough. I agree with you- it would be nice to have the capability, but I just wonder if it's something we can't accomplish at home.

        2. Sister Schubert uses only the finest ingredients, no preservatives, bakes them to perfection and freezes them fresh

          1. I also missed this thread the first time around. Baked bread is actually an item that keeps well in the freezer, so long as you plan to heat or toast it upon defrosting.