Psst... We're working on the next generation of Chowhound! View >
HOME > Chowhound > New Jersey >
Jan 26, 2007 08:20 AM

Bring Buffalo to Union County!

I'm jonsing for some Buffalo wings.

You know, the real thing, not some take-off of them. Makes me crazy when a place says they have them and then you get some poor representation of them made with some other kind of sauce, which bears no resemblence to Tabasco. Or the wings come out soft and sort of underdone, like they don't understand the skin should be on the crisp side.

I've had some decent ones here and there, for instance, Jeffrey's in Westfield makes a respectable wing - but it sure isn't a Buffalo wing, even tho he's serving it was blue cheese dressing. I think I had them at the Tavern if I'm not mistaken too, and a few other bar type places (probably the Jolly Trolly, maybe it was Charlie Browns, which burned down the other morning anyway so that's out). Anyway, suffice it to say none have come close to what I know a Buffalo wing should taste like.

My favorites are made in NYC at Blondies - if anyone knows them, then you know exactly what I'm aiming for. Those ARE the real deal.

So, anyplace around Union Co. that I don't know about? I'm sure there has to be. I really don't want to go out of the county - it isn't like I'm on a quest major here, I want it to be as close to home as possible but surely this can't be a complete wasteland for this one food, can it? I know I can make them at home, however, my husband isn't big on them and making such a mess for myself isn't very appealing. Rather go out for dinner, let him have what he wants, and let me make a pig out of myself on what I want :-)

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
  1. Hi Laurie! This is off your topic, but can you tell me if that Hotel is still open in Cranford? I think it was called the Cranford Inn? After I read the "Jolly Trolley" (which brought back happy memories as a child :) I thought about the hotel's restaurant. Strange location, but I suppose many, many years ago it was busy.

    Well, just thought I would ask. I cannot help you on the wings!!! Sorry.

    Have a great weekend!

    2 Replies
    1. re: Angelina

      Hi Angelina. As far as I'm aware, it still is open. I know they put up a parking garage right by it, kind of blocks the view of some of the rooms I assume. I searched online and there does not seem to be a website, however, here is their address/phone #:

      1 S Union Ave
      Cranford, NJ 07016
      (908) 276-2121

      Funny thing is, you actually DID help about the wings! In doing that search, it mentioned the restaurant "The Porch" which we'd never been to and lo and behold, it says they serve wings! So, I think we'll have to give it a shot one night. Worst comes to worse they won't be what I'm looking for, and if I'm lucky I'll have found someplace close to home to satisfy my occassional craving.

      1. re: Angelina


        I know this is a very old link. I was looking at this site for the first time tonight. I have to say, we try to go to places for Wings and have found the Cranford Hotel to have the best around. I told a buddy of mine from Buffalo about it. He said, "come on, you can't get good Buffalo Wings in Cranford, NJ." I brought him there, and he said they were certainly real good wings. My kids beg to go to the Hotel for wings as well. I would give it a try.


      2. That is so funny! I can't beleive I remember that place! Well, I hope you enjoy your wings!

        1. Unless "The Porch" restaurant at The Cranford Hotel has had some kind of renaissance, the food will probably be as dreadful as the couple of times that I ate there.

          Please allow me to recount my second bad experience there:

          My SO & I ordered the "Chef's sauteed veggie platter" as an appetizer. After about 15 minutes, the waitress returned to announce that "the chef doesn't have any vegetables to saute". Hmmm....this was not a good sign, in my opinion, but we opted to skip an appetizer, since we were hoping that our entrees would be coming out soon. Of course, lingering in my mind was the thought that a restaurant not having any vegetables to sautee at 6:30 p.m. was an indication of some serious problems in that kitchen--either in the nature of bad management or perhaps a failure to rely on fresh vegetables. After perhaps another 10 minutes, the waitress emerged again to announce that the "Veal and mushrooms" that I had ordered was not available.

          By this time, I was not about to order something that I would later be told was unavailable. So, in view of the fact that there were other veal dishes on the menu and there were many dishes featuring mushrooms, I felt that I needed some guidance, and so I asked, "Is the chef out of veal, or is he out of mushrooms?". The response--"No, he's out of veal and mushrooms!".

          So, unwittingly, the waitress had revealed that nothing was actually cooked to order in that kitchen, and in fact, may have revealed that the kitchen relied on pre-cooked, pre-portioned foods (Chef's Sauteed Veggies could well have been a frozen microwaveable item that they had run out of, and the same could apply to Veal & Mushrooms). I decided to play it safe and order the burger and fries combo that seemed to be on every other table.

          Eventually, the burger and fries arrived and they proved to be quite mediocre. Since my previous visit had been...unimpressive at best, and this visit proved to be even worse, The Cranford Hotel went to the top of my "never return" list.

          1. Ok, you swayed me totally from going :-)
            Thanks for the warning!

            1. You know that Buffalo Wings are made with Frank's Red Hot Sauce, not tabasco, right?

              deep fry wings in hot oil...
              toss in sauce made of...
              1/2 Frank's Red Hot sauce
              1/2 melted butter/margarine

              that's it.