HOME > Chowhound > Mexico >

Memorable dinner in Cabo San Lucas

Mimi Jan 17, 2007 09:27 PM

Some friends invited me to stay with them for a week at Esperanza and I'd like to treat them to a fantastic dinner as a thank-you. Any suggestions? I've heard that the restaurant at the One and Only Palmilla (Agua, I think it is) is great but I can't find a menu. Is the food comparable to the restaurants at Esperanza? We like fantastic food and good wine but don't necessarily need a stellar wine list. I was hoping to spend less than $500 for 3 adults. Is that reasonable? Thanks!

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
  1. e
    elizabean RE: Mimi Jan 17, 2007 09:47 PM

    I am vacationing in Cabo in a few weeks. The one restaurant that is consistently mentioned as a must visit is Aqua. I have already made a reso. Not certain about cost. I hear ridiculous comments about the mark up on wine (at least 3x). I was told dinner for 2 with wine will cost $400.

    1 Reply
    1. re: elizabean
      Cabo_Traveler RE: elizabean Apr 18, 2007 10:01 PM

      Haha, Aqua is one of the most expensive restaurants of the area, and some people say that is not so good but ive never tried.

    2. d
      DC Gal RE: Mimi Apr 21, 2007 06:34 PM

      Depends on what you want. Edith's in Cabo is fun and a great atmosphere with wonderful mesquite grilled steaks, fish, etc. The banana's foster for dessert is superb.

      I also LOVED Mi Cocina in San Jose del Cabo. More formal, eclectic menu and a beautiful courtyard setting.

      I don't think you could go wrong with either choice.

      1 Reply
      1. re: DC Gal
        flytofish RE: DC Gal Jun 4, 2007 12:30 AM

        We didn't like Edith's, the food is good, but 25 dollars for a chicken breast and almost 50 dollars for a USDA ribeye is way too much. Its Cabo, not Monaco.

      2. mambooster7 RE: Mimi Jul 21, 2007 04:11 PM

        Don Emiliano

        2 Replies
        1. re: mambooster7
          italiana3 RE: mambooster7 Jul 25, 2007 12:50 PM

          Just went to Cabo last month. You must go to NICK SAN!!! I abslolutely loved that place. We went twice. Personally, I felt every meal I had in cabo was average at best. I went to Edith's (nothing special). Went to Mi Casa( again average...very touristy, there is a clown making balloon creations. We thought it was a horrible atmosphere). Went to Pityhaya (great atmosphere...average food). WE had a drink at Las Ventanas. That place was divine. I think there is a restaurant there, I would check it out. Very upscale. I also went to Esperanza for another drink. Great place. If you go to Nick San, go to the one in Palmilla. They have one in the town of Cabo too. I was not a fan of the town. Palmilla was quieter and more upscale, if you are looking for atmosphere.
          I was overall disappointed with the food in Cabo. The prices were insane . I do not mind spending money on GOOD food, with the focus on food. Good luck!

          1. re: italiana3
            Eat_Nopal RE: italiana3 Jul 26, 2007 09:33 AM

            I hate to say it... but you chose tourists traps despite having other places reviewed here.

        2. h
          HungryLetsEat RE: Mimi Jul 26, 2007 09:42 AM

          Charlie Trotter's restaurant - C - is the one at One and Only. How could you go wrong there?

          Show Hidden Posts