HOME > Chowhound > San Francisco Bay Area >


Cheese shop with great selection on the peninsula?

  • 8

The gourmet supermarkets don't seem to cut it and are completely overpriced, even compared to manhattan prices.
Any suggestions would help! Thanks!

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
  1. You might try the Milk Pail on California Street in Mountain View. Wide variety of choices, very good prices

    2 Replies
    1. re: doc

      I'm not sure if 'cut it' means measure up or literally ... cut it. If the latter ... Milk Pail has a great selection of cheese ... some that I can't find in SF or Berkeley.

      The caveat is that it is precut and you really need to keep an eye on the expiration date.

      1. re: rworange

        I also love Milk Pail. You get some great deals with their specials (Parmigiano Reggiano for $7-8/lb., Roquefort for $7/lb.).

    2. I know you don't want gourmet markets, but whole foods palo alto has the most knowledgeable and friendly cheese people, plus at any of the wf markets you can have them cut the cheese! Sigona's in redwood city has a fair selection, though, not extensive. I'll have to go to Milk Pail, sounds good...

      1. Try Woodside Deli on Woodside Road in Redwood City. Good selection, very knowledgeable folks. Avoid lunchtime, though, when the crowds are out the door. I assume you've also tried Draegers in San Mateo or Menlo Park.

        1. Milk Pail is great - on a recent visit I picked up a nice La Tur for either $7.99 or $8.99 - I've seen this at almost twice that price at Draeger's and the like...

          1. I agree on Milk Pail, although it does have the drawback of being all pre-cut, so you can't choose sizes or, more importantly, taste before you buy.

            If you're further north on the Peninsula, Stangelini's in San Mateo has maybe 15 or 20 different imported Italian cheeses. Some of it is pre-cut, but they've always been willing to cut larger or smaller pieces on request and give tastes. They don't have a huge selection, but both their Asiago and imported Provolone are much better than the stuff they sell at Whole Foods. (I haven't actually bought cheese at Draeger's so I can't tell you how it compares other than by its $$$$iness.)

            If you want Italian cheese, it's worth a stop at Stangelini's. You can pick up a sandwich and some soup, some bulk polenta and a bottle of just about any flavor of Torani syrup while you're there. (I really love this place -- can you tell?) It's on San Mateo Drive, just north of Poplar, a few minutes from the Peninsula Ave exit on 101.

            1. Thanks for the suggestions, definitely been to Milk Pail, and the issue with the expiration dates scared me a bit when venturing into the more gourmet varieties (the stuff most people don't buy)