HOME > Chowhound > Kosher >


Kosher bakery in Manhattan

Looking for a kosher bakery for a cake for my daughter's birthday. Any suggestions?

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
  1. Where in Manhattan? Dairy or pareve?

    1. the only one I know is Gertels downtown and it's eh

      1 Reply
      1. re: pitagirl

        Is Gertel's even offering retail service any more?

      2. One good place is William Greenberg. Very good desserts, pretty expensive but worth it. Some people like Crumbs, but I've never tried anything there.

        1 Reply
        1. re: Clarissa

          I was on the UES a few weeks ago and tried Crumbs for the first time. It's a good thing for me that they're not located anywhere near where I live. I'd be a frequent customer! Their cupcakes are first rate. Not only beautiful but delicious. They even offer parve cake selections, if pre ordered.

        2. Greenberg has good cakes. Fairway has some damn good milchig cakes too.

          2 Replies
          1. re: DeisCane

            Where is Greenberg? I'm in the gramercy park area.

            1. re: mikeinnyc

              It's on Madison in the high 70s on the west side of the street.

          2. My most favorite dessert. Also, make sure you check the hashgacha on Greenberg.

            1. I here Buttercup Bake Shop is pretty good...and it's under OKS.

              141 West 72nd Street
              Between Broadway & Columbus Avenue Map data ©2007 TeleAtlas - 10023

              Taken From:

              1. Buttercup is one of those Magnolia spinoffs. It's good.

                1. I tried Buttercup once (while scouting it for a friend's birthday cake) and wasn't impressed.

                  1. I've only had the cupcakes--at their east side location--and they were good (ie not great). :-)

                    1. The sheet cake at the East Side branch is pretty incredible. Yellow cake with lemon icing. The fact that it is kosher didn't play into our decision to purchase, and everyone was thrilled with it. In my opinion, their cake is much better than their cupcakes.

                      1. Fairway makes great custom cakes at reasonable prices, and I think Moishe's on 2nd Avenue does good work. their rugalech and some danishes and strudels are fabullous. I think their cheese strudel is good too, but pretty sure they do birthday cakes to order. Gruenebaum (Gideons) in Washnigton Heights always had birthday cakes in stock... I guess they still do though haven't been there in a while

                        1. Crumbs is yummy, and they just opened a new branch on 8th street