Best Indian in San Mateo?
Expand to Foster City, and go to Tabla! This place is very authentic. Young guys at formica tables, big plates of biryana, dosas to kill for, and lots of bollywood screens in every direction. Not your run of the mill north indian tandoori and curry. And look to the specials list - last time I was there I had a great goat curry.
1088 Shell Blvd, Foster City, CA 94404
When I lived in Millbrae, Nawab was our go-to restaurant for Northern Indian food. We liked it for awhile, were really disappointed with our one buffet experience, and were underwhelmed our last visit there for dinner three years ago.
Annapoorna which serves South Indian is actually better. Another option is Roti Bistro in Burlingame. It seems to be universally loved in Chowhound. We visited several times. It is in a great setting but the food is pricey and not always great.
Here's my Annapoorna review:
I Claim This Aloo Bonda for Spain…er, India! – An Awesome Indian Snack at Annapoorna in San Mateo
Here are my two Nawab reviews:
Ordinary Nawab Cooks Indian Classics Extraordinarily Well (San Mateo)
San Mateo’s Nawab: Highly Raita-d for Dinner, but Lunch Buffet? Aloo-ser
2299 S El Camino Real, San Mateo, CA 94403
Roti Indian Bistro
209 Park Rd, Burlingame, CA 94010
Nawab India Restaurant
5 S Ellsworth Ave, San Mateo, CA 94401