30th Birthday for my wife
I need an italian restaurant with a private room (if possible) in Manhattan for a surprise dinner.I think we have about 30 people.I tried Fresco and they are not available.
Any suggestions will be greatly appreciated.
Il Buco, a restaurant with tasty food but overpriced and has a fear of putting a decent portion of food on a plate has a private cellar that would likely be accomodating. Not sure if it holds 30 though.
Trio is more "Mediterranean" I think, but is pretty good. I find the room a bit too dark (low lighting with very dark woods) but for some, that's a good thing.
I think Crispo has a private room - may not be big enough though. Del Posto has plenty of private space in their downstairs area.
Be careful doing a surprise - it seems your wife also uses this account, correct? Clicking your handle (kgnyc) shows this:
That being said, do you have a budget in mind? I know Trattoria Dopo Teatro (right in Times Square) has some beautiful private spaces downstairs... their food is not 4 star but the prices are reasonable, too.
Crispo is a great suggestion - I think they would give you the back room, which is a nice spot and should be the right size. The atmosphere there, particularly in the back room, is excellent, and the food is great too.