356569 Wed Jan 03 16:03:51 -0800 2007 11 18 Manhattan 0 2148412 Thanks to a tip from kayonyc, myself and the other half made a brief stop at Cafe d'Alsace before a movie last night. Since then, I read the other not-so-rave reviews among the Hounds. We didn't have much time, and only had a couple of apps and a beer, but apart from some ditzy service, we thought it was great. Wonderful potato salad, very very good Venison sausage over creamy choucroute. Crispy fries. All washed down with two bottles of delicious Belgian beer, Corsendonk, I believe. Perfect send-off for a movie, and we'll definitely go back for a more in-depth try. - Sean Wed Jan 03 16:03:51 -0800 2007 11294 Sean Dell 1 2148969 I like Cafe D'Alsace. Solid food at decent prices. Its my go-to place in the neighborhood. Brunch is good also. Wed Jan 03 18:23:55 -0800 2007 2148412 18406 wild child 1 2150408 I had a great first meal there and then two disappointing meals. I have been enjoying B. Cafe lately. It is a low key Belgian Restaurant on 75th off 2nd. Wed Jan 03 23:21:59 -0800 2007 2148412 17496 vinominer 1 2150652 We went there about 4 months ago and we thought then that the dishes we had came close to Alsatian fare only in appearance and nothing more. There appears to be a lot of beer choices, but everybody seem to be drinking out of too many overly gimmicky glasses. Good description with the "ditzy service" - our waiter seemed to presume that every customer have no clue as to what or where Alsace is. If ever there is a next time, which is unlikely, I'll try the sausages. Thu Jan 04 00:40:22 -0800 2007 2148412 10578 RCC 1 2152150 I go fairly often but harbor no illusions about the food--it can be delicious, but it's unfortunately inconsistent. I don't really care what kind of glass my beer is poured in as long as it tastes good ... and they do have a lot of delicious beers--try the Finnish porter. RCC--I like the meat sausages, but find the seafood sausages pretty mediocre. Thu Jan 04 15:32:26 -0800 2007 2148412 21820 Kanger 2 2154570 Thank you for the tip on the sausages. Based on the very mediocre, that tasted something that was previously-frozen, trout in white wine sauce that I had, I think I should not attempt seafood if I ever decide to go back. I'm glad somebody down on this thread mentioned the surly host. That person may be the most uptight and snnotiest host ever in a low-to-mid-range class of a restaurant. Fri Jan 05 00:36:05 -0800 2007 2152150 10578 RCC 1 2153220 Glad you enjoyed the place. I'm surprised by the number of bad reviews - but I'll just chalk it up to maybe an inconsistency in the kitchen? I'll admit, I am not exactly a regular. I will definitely go back and try the sausage and choucroute! Thu Jan 04 19:30:33 -0800 2007 2148412 53427 kayonyc 1 2153232 We had dinner there a few months ago and thought it was horrible, not worth another try. The choucroute was salty with scanty and bad meat in it. Thu Jan 04 19:32:28 -0800 2007 2148412 18941 tsiblis 2 2153634 I had the choucroute last week at lunchtime and really liked it. Lots of different meats, all good, with enough leftover for a doggy-bag lunch at home the next day. And since I'm not a sauerkraut fan, I was glad that the kraut was mild. Thu Jan 04 20:46:33 -0800 2007 2153232 12731 Boswell 1 2153506 In general, the positive reviews come from people who had beer and a snack and the negative reviews come from people who sat down for a full meal. I do like the beer selection and have sampled a few of their beers but have never eaten here. Thu Jan 04 20:20:32 -0800 2007 2148412 13203 Scott V 2 2153945 I'd give the place an overall thumbs up (can be great, but inconsistent) and I usually sit down for full meals ... but I much prefer the appetizers to the entrees (and order accordingly), so I fit into your theory. Thu Jan 04 21:48:24 -0800 2007 2153506 21820 Kanger 1 2154264 IMO, the food at Cafe D'Alsace is mediocre to good. The beer list is good to very good. The prices are reasonable. It would be a perfect neighborhood place if not for the aloof yet surly welcome from the host. Even if you have a reservation, even if the restaurant is a 1/3 empty (which it often is), they will not seat you until they've put you in your place. Thu Jan 04 23:07:05 -0800 2007 2148412 23114 Fielding