Psst... We're working on the next generation of Chowhound! View >
HOME > Chowhound > Greater Boston Area >
Dec 31, 2006 12:48 AM

Best Pizza on North Shore???

For discussion:

Top 3 + 1:

1. Bianchi's-Revere
2. Sebastian's-Gloucester
3. Gallo Nero-Peabody

*Honorable Mention-Little Italy-Beverly

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
  1. wow, new places i havent heard of! Where's Gallo Nero?? what kind of pizza do you like? Can you describe these? I am so tired of pizza disappointment.. love to find new ones! Haven't thought of Bianchis for a while but i think i do remember liking there slices..I think Sal's in Gloucester was good if i remember , but didnt try Sebastians.
    Other good ones:
    1. Fauci's in Lynn for Sicilian slices. Prefer them over the whole pizzas there
    2. Calitri's in Danvers. Wish people here would try this place. I usually like my pizza Regina style, floppy and drippy and doughy and this is much different but really really excellent. It is a very thin crispy pizza. The edges are like a very light breadstick in texture. It's addictive and you want to eat the whole crust. The sauce and toppings are great too. Very authentic, i think like i remember in Italy years ago.

    3. Regina's at Polcaris but i always end up thinking it is either too overcooked or not comparing to my memories of Reginas years ago in North end.

    4 Marios in North Reading.. Was a lot like Reginas the first time and we were excited but not as good the second time

    5 Toscana's in Peabody. Another place chowhounds should really try. Nice casual but semi upscale family run place. compimentary after dinner cordials too. excellent home cooked food and loved the pizza, especiall the thin onion slices the first couple times we had it. Closest to Reginas north end but has been a lot of variation in subsequent visits.

    6 Replies
      1. re: marilu

        This is where the "what kind of pizza do you like" plays a factor. Industrial strength pizzanlike Same & Joes just isn't my thing - but it's the real deal for some. Diversity for everyone!

      2. re: chompie

        Had some great pizza from MArios a few weeks ago. I hosted a bd party for my nephew, and my brother brought the pizza- had pepperoni, white pizza, chicken broccoli and cheese. I always judge by the cheese. It was great- thin crust, greasy top, sauce was good. The pepperoni and white pizzas were great, too. The chi;cken broccoli (alfredo) was all gone long before I was able to try it!
        Used to get Mario's pizza years ago, then stopped as they were not as good. I think they are back to their old form.

        1. re: chompie

          I typically like Italian style pizza with a thin crust and a sauce on the sweet side. Gallo Nero is in Peabody Square on Main St. I would desribe it as Reginaesque, but not as doughy. Sebastians and Little Italy are on the thicker side, Little Italy has a very unique sweet sauce. My wife pointed out I did not add one of my other true favorites, Caruso's in Melrose, where the zazza pizza reigns sumpreme. I went to Calitris a couple of weeks ago and thought it was good, but the cheese was a little oily fo my taste. Reminded me of Sam and Joe's in Dancers and Monte's in Lynn. I'll have to try Toscana's and Mario's. I used to frequent where Toscana when it was Antonelli's.

          1. re: rogerroy

            chompie- will have to try the zazza pizza at Caruso;s. Have been there numerous times- like their food, and their pizza, but have never tried the zazza. Love their eggplant parm subs,too.

          2. re: chompie

            Stay away from Marios,they are not good. Can't even get a sub order right. I live next door and have had enough

          3. Little Italy is a shell of what it once was. Yeah, if you like entering a restaurant where all the employees are drunk, and are more intrested in staring you down than being friendly, then you found your place for badly done pizza. Luigis on Rantoul street in Beverly is run by the former owners (family) of Little Italy, and thier pizza is as good as it was years ago. By far the best Pizza on the North Shore. No web site, but phone is 978 922 2828. Yes Mama still works there. Shes a bit older now, but still makes you laugh with the "old school" Italian attitude. God bless you Mama,

            1. Prinzi's in Beverly is often overlooked - thin crust, good sauce - feeds the need.

              6 Replies
              1. re: ipsofatso

                sorry you didnt like calitiri's that much. I happen to like oil on pizza. We tried Gallo Nero and actually didnt like it at all. I guess diffierent tastes is what makes the world interesting! and actually the last two times i went to Calitris i am sorry to say that i was disappointed. The crust was hard instead of melt in your mouth crispy.. Since my last post here, I have found two pizzas that I highly recommend. One is not really that North Shore but is north of boston. Flatbread Company in Bedford. You go to the Burlington Mall exit and just go past the mall about a couple miles. It is the best pizza I have had since original Reginas years ago. There is a post here called "King of Pizzas' You can read my description there. Basically its a wood burning clay oven, very very thin and drippy in the middle and bubbly and doughy fresh bread on the outside. with cauldron cooked sauce and organic ingredients. Its very very craveable. Also a great new addition to Middleton, just past Richardsons, is Sals, a chain from Merrimac and New Hampshire. They make a 3 lb, 19" pizza for about 10 bucks. Its really good crust, good quality cheese, standard oregano flavored sauce, and a great deal with very nice taste and texture. Sal's is a welcome treat. Flatbreads is a wonder.

                1. re: chompie

                  Coincidentally, I went to Little Italy for the first (and only time) on Friday night, and the pizza was disgusting. It was weirdly sweet, like it was made with Sweet n Lo.

                  1. Riverview Pizza in Ipswich
                  2. LaRosa's in Gloucester

                  1. re: resipsaloquitor

                    Bianchi's in Revere
                    Brown jug in Chelsea

                    1. re: phatchris

                      Time for a new listing on this board. Just tried Anna's Pizzeria on 400 Highland ave, Rt 107. Salem at former site of Big Peters. Owner is from Southern Italy and puts out a nice fresh thin crust pie with very fresh ingredients. As far as the old posts, Montes in Lynn has tremendous atmosphere but in my opinion a very average pizza. Riverview in Ipswich and Bianchi's in Revere get the thumbs up from me but there is no place to eat inside at Bianchi's. It's much nicer to get a pie hot out of the oven and eat it where it's prepared. And last but not least, Romano's in Marblehead never disappoints this chowhound.

                      1. re: StevefromMarblehead

                        Still looking for a decent pie on Cape Ann since La Rosa's changed its recipe. Had a pizza at Espresso's last week and it was OK but flavorless.

                        1. re: StevefromMarblehead

                          I have to disagree about Monte's. I grew up in Lynn and this was and still is a popular pizza, especially if you favor the thin crust style. The days are long gone now but their mantra used to be..."Monte's Monte's by the sea, buy 2 pizzas, get one free."

                2. Since this thread is over 3 years old and now revived, I guess I'll add:

                  1. Santapio's - E. Boston
                  2. Angela's - Saugus
                  3. Pisa Pizza - Malden

                  1. J & M Italian - 340 Central St. Saugus
                    Oreganos - Newburyport

                    Do not like Sebastians - too sweet, dough too thick

                    4 Replies
                    1. re: ipsofatso

                      The potato skin pizza at J & M is unbelieveable. Try it if you haven't already.

                      1. re: hhookk

                        Just had J & M today...OMG as great as ever.

                        1. re: ipsofatso

                          1. Santarpios
                          2. Cristy's Pizza Salisbury Beach
                          3. Riverview Ipswich
                          4. Antico Forno North End

                          Antico Forno
                          93 Salem Street, Boston, MA 02113

                          Cristy's Pizza
                          13 Broadway, Salisbury, MA 01952

                          1. re: JustinKnowsFood

                            Had a fantastic lunch at Antico Forno.

                            Antico Forno
                            93 Salem Street, Boston, MA 02113