Psst... We're working on the next generation of Chowhound! View >
HOME > Chowhound > Cookware >
Dec 15, 2006 06:54 PM

Question on Rehabbing Old Cast Iron

I have a 10" Lodge frying pan that I've had since college. I never even tried to season and washed it in soap for its first ten years of life. For the last two, I've regularly seasoned with bacon fat.

My question is that I'd like to strip it and start from scratch. I've given it two hits with oven cleaner, and most of the black patina came off but some patches just wouldn't. After that I've scrubbed it thoroughly with steel wool and antiseptic soap, dried it out and am ready to apply the first coat of Crisco.

Should I be worried about the patches (particularly along the walls of the interior) that underwent an application of oven cleaner but didn't come off?

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
  1. Assuming you have a self cleaning oven, I'd strongly suggest running it through that before you start. Maybe soak it in the sink for a few minutes to get rid of that even cleaner - not like overnight, you don't want the thing to rust, but maybe for half an hour or so. Maybe change the water a couple times? Next time (if there is a next time) go simply for the self cleaning oven, no need for chemicals. Just hope you didn't "season" your cast iron with oven cleaner.

    1. Why on earth would you want to throw away ten years of good seasoning? Why? That's like stripping the Mona Lisa because you want to start from scratch.

      2 Replies
      1. re: andreas

        It seemed to be uneven and rough in spots, which was probably the result of it accumulating by chance rather than a regular seasoning program.

        1. re: Sam Harmon

          That's probably as good a reason as any. I might well do the same.

          I agree with the above poster about getting the pan really hot to burn off any nasty stuff that may have accumulated. Since you're planning to reseason anyway, no harm in getting it glowing. You could do this just as well using a burner on top of the stove. If you have a fireplace or something like that, you could just throw it into the coals for a while. You ought to be able to burn off the stubborn seasoning patches, as well as any oven cleaner residue.

          Once you've done that, just scrub it clean and treat it like brand new. The lodge web site has pretty clear instructions if you need 'em.

      2. I also agree with the recommendation that yo run it through the self cleaning cycle in your oven. It works like a charm. You will see some oxidation when you remove it from the oven. This will wipe right out and then start seasoning and don't try to use oils for seasoning it. They will leave a sticky redidue. Just start cooking bacon, a lot of bacon.

        1. That's what I love about cast iron. To get it really clean you can put in a fireplace. Try that with $200 calaphon!

          1. A metals website that I found strongly disagrees with the clean-by-intense-heat scenario. It can lead to cracking (cast iron is not indestructable) and if badly cracked, can explode during use with high heat.

            These folks are antique cast-iron collectors, and have devised an electrolysis method for removing the crud so as not to harm the precious collectables. This might appeal to the Popular Mechanics types out there.

            I have no such special apparatus, which involves a dip and electrical charge, so I use the fireplace coals method.

            Not a roaring fire, but banked coals from a medium sized evening fire. Place the pan upside down over the coals and let the subsiding heat work on the gunk. It does take several sessions to get all the areas, but I feel safer with the lower heat. No exploding pans for me, thank you. ;-)