HOME > Chowhound > Manhattan >

Discussion

The Sad State of Pizza in the UES

  • 7

I have tried my best to find a decent, true NY style, slice of pizza in the UES, to no avail. Most of the places i have scouted out on this message baord have soggy crusts, oily/waxy cheese and lackluster sauce. There are some good Neopolitan/thin crust/pie-only places, such as Tontonno's and Nick's, but that just doesnt suffice for when I have folks over for a ballgame or when I want to eat cold pizza leftovers for breakfast. Where can I get such a pizza? I'm so desperate i'm considering ordering a pie from Agata and Valentin's on 79th and first just because their pastas are decent. Help!

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
Delete
    1. Have you tried Pintaile's Pizza? Very thin crispy whole wheat crust. They have several locations but there is one located on York Ave btwn 76th & 77th St.

      1 Reply
      1. re: TryThis

        I love Pintaile's. I'd actually eat there over some of the great downtown pizzerias, location aside. I go to the one on 91st btw Madison and 5th.

        (by the way, the crust may be whole wheat but it ain't a healthy pizza--have no fear)

      2. Nick's is good, but if you are willing to travel head to the original Patsy's on 118 and 1st. It's coal oven and thin crust. I can eat a pie by myself though.

        1. is mimi's still good? i haven't been in a while but it's always been reliable as far as I remember.

          2 Replies
          1. re: adam

            Really? Try living in Louisville, KY. The UES has plenty of fantastic pizza.

            The best options have already been mentioned. For delivery (or a slice when walking by) Mimi's on Lex and 84th. is excellent. If you really like a very thin crisp crust, then go for Pintaile's (several locations).

            For sit down, Nick's is SO worth avoiding the train ride down town.

            Tipsy

            1. re: adam

              I haven't had Mimi's in a while, but it definitely always was a reliable plain slice. Don Filipo on Lex btw 78 & 79th has great topping pizzas like Chicken Pesto or BBQ Chicken. They also have a slice called "El Diablo" for the adventurous. These two places don't compare to DiFara/Lombardi's/Grimaldi's, but they are solid neighborhood options.