HOME > Chowhound > Chicago Area >

Where to buy/order top-of-the-line prime rib roast for Christmas

jbentley4 Dec 11, 2006 09:40 PM

Any ideas? I'm thinking Fox and Obel, Whole Foods or someplace like that, but I'm wondering if there might be some other placs offering similar quality for better value. Thanks!

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
  1. r
    RMA RE: jbentley4 Dec 11, 2006 10:01 PM

    I actually think you'd be better off at a butcher/meat market than at the places you mentioned, in terms of both quality and value. If you're in the city, Paulina Market and Gepperth's come to mind as places that both fit the bill (both have been mentioned in fairly recent posts, I believe). Here is a link to Gepperth's in Lincoln Park:


    1. abf005 RE: jbentley4 Dec 11, 2006 10:25 PM

      All Sam's Clubs offer very nice packinghouse "choice" grade cryovac packaged cuts of meat, the prime rib is definitely worth a look.

      1. d
        donna5657 RE: jbentley4 Dec 12, 2006 01:31 AM

        There are great meat markets on Lake Street, just west of Halsted. I have purchased beautiful cuts of pork and beef at a fraction of the price in a grocery store.

        1 Reply
        1. re: donna5657
          OP178 RE: donna5657 Dec 14, 2006 05:05 PM

          There are great meat markets on Lake Street, just west of Halsted. I have purchased beautiful cuts of pork and beef at a fraction of the price in a grocery store.

          So Donna, which meat market? Lake street is full of wholesale places with really big trucks and guys in white coats. Which ones are worth our while?

        2. leek RE: jbentley4 Dec 12, 2006 01:01 PM

          I got mine from Paulina Meat Market last time I did one, and it was very good and their service was very good also.

          3501 N. Lincoln Ave., Chicago
          (corner of Lincoln and Cornelia)
          Tel: (773) 248-6272

          1. j
            jbentley4 RE: jbentley4 Dec 12, 2006 08:36 PM

            Thanks for the suggestions!

            1. m
              MikeLM RE: jbentley4 Dec 13, 2006 02:29 AM

              If the western suburbs are convenient, you could go to Casey's Meat Market in Western Springs. They will customize any order you would wish, and it's all top-of-the-line.


              1. a
                amoncada RE: jbentley4 Dec 13, 2006 05:55 PM

                HMMMM. YOU GOTTA LOVE MEAT!

                I'm surprised no one mentioned Costco. Great meat for competitive prices.

                Definitely second the Paulina Meat Market recommendation. While you're there, buy some homemade wieners and veal brats...great stuff.

                There are a number of great ethnic deli/butchers in town that would likely be mush less expensive;

                Kurowski's on Milwaukee Avenue, Great meat, Kielbasa. I usually start by hunting down an English speaking patron. The number of sausage varities are mind boggling.
                Bari Foods on Grand Avenue, outstanding Italian Sausage too
                Andy's Deli on Milwaukee Avenue
                Minelli's Bros. in Niles on Northwest Highway. Great meats, Italian Sausage, Mama Minelli's fresh frozen pastas, marinaras, pestos, pizza's are excellent.
                Gilmart's on South Archer Avenue, the best Keilbasa, deli, meats
                Bobak's on South Archer Avenue
                Riviera Foods on Harlem Avenue in Elmwood Park, great meats & sausage

                1 Reply
                1. re: amoncada
                  nsxtasy RE: amoncada Dec 13, 2006 06:28 PM

                  If the near north suburbs are convenient to you, Zier's in Wilmette is a wonderful place for high-end meats. We've gotten prime rib there and it's always been excellent.

                  Zier's Prime Meats & Poultry
                  813 Ridge Rd
                  Wilmette, IL
                  (847) 251-4000

                2. r
                  RMA RE: jbentley4 Dec 13, 2006 08:08 PM

                  I second the Casey's recommendation, if you're in the western burbs. In addition to being in Western Springs, they have a large presence in Naperville. (Located in the Colonial Plaza at Washington and Gartner.) Casey's has one of the best butcher counters that I personally have ever seen...If you've never been there, you'll be amazed.

                  1. c
                    chicagoann RE: jbentley4 Dec 13, 2006 09:04 PM

                    Though more and more people seem to be going the cryovac route at Costco, I travel many miles to get my prime rib at:
                    Devon Avenue Meats, inside Morningfield Grocery in Park Ridge
                    800 Devon Ave
                    Park Ridge, IL 60068

                    For a lengthy, and indeed obsessive, discussion of how to cook it once you've bought it, see http://lthforum.com/bb/viewtopic.php?...

                    1. j
                      jbentley4 RE: jbentley4 Dec 15, 2006 02:55 PM

                      Thanks again for everybody's suggestions. After a little more research, I ended putting in an order with Gepperth's. They're fairly close to me (Lakeview) and I like to support local/independent/small purveyors when possible. I don't have a car, so some of the places in Western suburbs, for example, would not have been very convenient. However, they all sounded in like good sources so I will mention them to friends and colleagues who do live in those areas. Also, thanks for the forum link about preparing rib roast. As with turkeys and virtually everything else, there are different schools of thought about preparation and they are fun and interesting to explore.

                      Show Hidden Posts