Sliced to order bacon in Lower Westchester
The quality at Whole Foods for their bacon was terrible. I bought it several times and when I got home noticed it was slimy and turned. I complained several times and the past few visits I noticed they didn't carry bacon anymore. I don't know if that is temproary or not but my last visit was a few days ago.
I would go to Fairway at 125th St in Harlem. It's right off the southbound 125th street exit on the Hudson River Parkway. I got some great bacon there recently.
Try local Italian pork stores. This places carries one type of decent slab bacon.
A&S Italian Pork Store
1789 Central Park Ave
Yonkers, NY 10710
Zuccarellis Deli does NOT carry slab bacon but I thought to include the info anyway.
321 White Plains Rd
Eastchester, NY 10709-2808
In Queens Monya and Misha on 108th St and 63rd carries around 4-5 slab bacons, most are imported, including a double smoked one. I have tried all their types and they are really great.
6446 108th St
Karl Ehmers makes a fantastic low sodium/nitrite bacon that is great. Also a really good Irish Bacon. The nearest Karl Ehmers to Westchester, now that the New Rochelle branch has been closed for five years is Queens or Yorktown Heights.
Karl Ehmers NY Locations
Queens- Factory and retail store
63-35 Fresh Pond Road
Ridgewood, NY 11385
185-24 Horace Harding Expy
Fresh Meadows, NY 11365
70-03 Myrtle Avenue
Glendale, NY 11385
48 So. Ocean Avenue
Patchogue, NY 11772
36-08 So. Merrick Road
Seaford, NY 11783
2022 Saw Mill River Rd.
Yorktown Hts, NY 10598
Danbury, CT 06810
6 Federal Road
re: Pat Hammond
Yes, it is interesting about the bacon at Whole Foods--I purchased it there once a few months ago and did not have a problem. The last time I got slab bacon by the slice was a few weeks ago when I had the occasion to travel to the "Big City" on Metro North--there is a wonderful German charcuterie in the Grand Central Station market which had thick, smoky bacon by the slice.
They're prices make my teeth hurt! But my daughter goes, and I'll have her pick up some bacon for me. Karhl Ehmer once was in New Rochelle? Shoot, that's just down the street! I'm relatively new to the area, and don't know the name, but it sounds good. I'm also going out Mt. Vernon way to scout around. Thanks, all!
Pat Hammond, they used to be where the bagel store is now, across from Blessed Sacrament church. I think...that may have just been a pork store and Karl Ehmer was somewhere else. At any rate, they're both gone from New Rochelle now.
cteats, I forgot about the Pork Store in PortChester. I don't remember seeing bulk bacon but it makes sense that they would have it. Their wursts are wunderful!
Try Crisfields Meat Market in Rye. I'm guessing they would do it. They have great meats and I've been able to get them to custom order and custom cut lots of different cuts. If they don't have it on hand, I'm sure you could order it the day before and they'd custom cut it for you. Heck, you could probably order the whole belly if you like.
Finding the place is a bit of a mess, but it's a great butcher shop.
I still need to try the pork store in PC.