Psst... We're working on the next generation of Chowhound! View >
HOME > Chowhound > San Francisco Bay Area >
Dec 3, 2006 03:56 PM

baguette and butter tasting

I was asked to put together a tasting of baguettes available in the East Bay for a dinner party, and by the time I was done, I had 10 different baguettes from seven different bakeries (I now have seven partial baguette loaves -- if anyone has any ideas on what to do with them, I started a thread on the Home Cooking board).

Purchased direct from the bakery:
Bread Garden: "Traditional"
Bread Garden: "Country French Sourdough"
Bread Garden: "19th Century"

La Farine: "Rustic"

Feel Good Bakery: "French"

From Whole Foods:
Artisan Bakery: Sour baguette
Semifreddi: Sweet baguette
La Brea: Sour baguette
Grace: Sour baguette

Acme: The person who was supposed to pick up an Acme "rustic" from the Berkeley bakery called in sick, so someone brought a standard Acme sour baguette that was apparently purchased at a market.

One reason I bought some baguettes at Whole Foods (in particular the Semifreddi) was that I wanted to see if there was a difference between store-bought and bakery-bought baguettes, and to my mind there clearly was. I thought all the bakery-purchased breads showed a distinctly higher quality. At the very least, they were fresher (the La Farine was still warm when I bought it that afternoon, and I believe the Feel Good was also from their "late bake"). I bought Semifreddi because their baguettes are ubiquitous; sadly this baguette actually met my expectation in that I thought it was the most characterless of the bunch, with a mass-produced look and taste.

The clear winners in my book were the French baguette from Feel Good and the 19th Century baguette from Bread Garden. Although the texture was faulted for being a bit soft (perhaps because it was a little *too* fresh), the Feel Good baguette had the most complex, well-developed flavor. The 19th Century baguette also had a complex flavor and a satisfying chew.

The La Farine baguette made a surprisingly poor showing. It was also a little soft (again, too fresh?) and blander than I expected. The Bread Garden Country French Sourdough had the most pronounced sourdough flavor of the bunch, but it wasn't as crusty as I would have liked. Not surprisingly, the Acme had the best thick, chewy crust, but I was surprised how bland it tasted next to some of the others. The La Brea is very similar to the Acme. The Bread Garden "traditional" and the Artisan fell into the "decent but not exciting" category, and the Grace landed next to the Semifreddi at the bottom.

I had actually gone into Whole Foods intending to buy butter, and when they didn't have the butter I'd gone in for (Jana Valley, which they apparently aren't carrying anymore), I couldn't decide what to buy. That's when I figured we might as well have a little butter tasting to go with our bread, and bought four different unsalted butters:

Celles sur Belles -- French, 82% fat, includes "milk cultures"
Parmagiano Reggiano "Il Burro" -- Italian, 83% fat, includes "cultures"
Anchor -- New Zealand, 82.9% (that's what it says!) fat, no mention of cultures
Orangic Pastures Raw Butter -- ingredients: raw cream, no fat content listed, but according to their respective nutritional lables, a 15 ml serving has one less gram of fat than the New Zealand butter (11 rather than 12).

The Parmagiano was the most distinct. According to the label, it's made with the same appellation/quality controlled milk used to make the cheese of the same name. I don't know if it was the power of suggestion or if the cultures they use are the same (seems likely), but it has a very cheesy smell and taste. I would use this butter on the table, but not for baking.

Conversely, the Anchor had a sweet, clean taste. A very good "neutral" butter that would be perfect for baked goods that shine with high quality butter.

The Celles sur Belle I thought was the best "all purpose" butter of this group. A little more flavorful than the Anchor, but without the cheesy/earthy flavors of the stronger butters.

Finally, the raw butter. I've been looking for an excuse to buy this, since it's very expensive ($7.99 for 8 ounces at Whole Foods). But if you like butter that actually tastes like it came from a cow, than this is for you: strong, complex flavor with just a bit of buttery sweetness on the finish.

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
  1. Wow, that sounds fantastic. What a great idea for a tasting! I'm jealous. And hungry. And I just ate breakfast.

    (Bread pudding. Savory sausage for the sourdough, sweet for the sweet.)

    2 Replies
    1. re: lintygmom

      Yeah, it was really fun. And at $2 each, buying a lot of different baguettes makes for a fairly inexpensive tasting.

      If you have recipes (or links to recipes) for the bread puddings, I'd really appreciate them!

      1. re: Ruth Lafler


        Please post any recipes on the Home Cooking board. (We have moved lintygmom's recipe there.)


    2. Isn't it surprising how a back to back tasting really accentuates the flaws of some items.

      First of all, the baguettes at Semifreddi are not their finest bread even direct from the bakery. I liked Semifreddi a lot until the one day that I made the mistake of buying the same rolls at Acme ... don't remember which roll it was, but it just highlighted how vastly superior Acme is.

      I like Bread Garden alot and they slice the bread (not baguettes) for you. Nice to hear the did so well in the tasting. One of these days I'll get over to Feel Good ... it's on my list.

      Interesting about the butter. I don't buy butter often and when I do, it is rarely from a supermarket unless I'm desperate. You never know how it was handled. Wonder if the cheesy notes were the actual butter or the way it was handled.

      1. Shame you didn't have an Acme rustic from the bakery. That's the gold standard in my book.

        Butter made from cultured cream has a slight cheesey tang.

        1 Reply
        1. re: Robert Lauriston

          Not for lack of trying! The guest who was supposed to bring the Acme rustic from the Berkeley bakery called in sick when I was already on the ramp to the I couldn't stop by the Ferry Building bakery. Then we tried to intercept the arrivals from Woodlands, but they were running too late to get to Acme in Berkeley before closing time.

          I agree that the gold standard is Acme's rustic. But sometimes I find it too heavy when what I want is a lighter style of baguette. I think Bread Garden's 19th struck a happy medium for texture with fullness of flavor.

        2. I prefer the "regular" baguette from La Farine to the rustic by a wide margin. They say it's the same recipe, so the difference may just be the size. The texture works better when confined in a smaller space. I don't think you'd find the same "softness" problem in the non-rustic.

          1 Reply
          1. re: mcchowhound

            Interesting, I was under the impression that the rustic baguette gets a longer rise for more flavor.

          2. Not seeing the thread on the home cooking board but...The Zuni Bread Salad recipe I believe requires day old bread and is delcious with the roast chicken recipe.