HOME > Chowhound > Manhattan >
Brewing beer, curing meat, or making cheese? Share your food adventure

Dinner after Marriage Proposal

Yanni Nov 29, 2006 01:51 AM


I plan on proposing to my girlfriend in mid-December (not in a restaurant) and could use some assistance in finding a good restaurant for dinner to celebrate.

Nothing formal, but romantic would be nice. I would prefer to keep the cost under $200 for dinner. We're staying in the East 40s but wouldn't mind heading into other parts of Manhattan. She likes French, Mediterranean, and American Cuisine.

Thanks for your assistance!

  1. jon Nov 29, 2006 02:40 AM

    whatever you do, don't go to il buco. i suggest l'impero, delicious delicious food.

    i wrote this after i "popped the question." good luck!


    1. Non Cognomina Nov 29, 2006 04:10 AM

      I can't imagine a more comfortable, romantic restaurant for a special occasion like that and in the price range you mentioned than Gramercy Tavern. The ambiance, food, and service are just wonderful. You can make a reservation in the dining room and let the reservationist know that you will have just proposed and I have no doubt that they will take good care of you. You could also eat in the Tavern Room, but they don't take reservations so you may have to wait. Good luck popping the question!

      1. c
        chowNYC Nov 29, 2006 12:26 PM

        For our first anniversary we went to March (east 58th between 1st and York). I'm sure they can accommodate you and try to put you in the 'back' of the restaurant where there is a beautiful enclosed Atrium. When we went there they gave me (the wife) a rose and the meal was delightful. It will be right around $200 total. It's quiet, intimate, and a bit of a taste of an "old New York" feel.

        1. ronoc Nov 29, 2006 02:30 PM

          second the gramercy tavern recommendation, but not sure you'll make it out the door under $200. if you want to go a bit cheaper, maybe red cat? i bet the same quality of service if you let them know it was a special meal.

          1 Reply
          1. re: ronoc
            selizara Nov 29, 2006 06:00 PM

            I liked the Red Cat, but I'm not sure it is the place for a romantic meal. I thought it was very good, but it was also extremely loud and not an easy place to be heard by your companions across the table.

          2. c
            CTCajun Nov 29, 2006 02:37 PM

            I would say Cosette (French). It is in low 30's between Lex and 3rd I believe. Great small romantic atmosphere.I thought the food was delicious as well, my duck with a cherry reduction was cooked perfectly and my girlfriends mussles were delicious as well. Also, with wine and such you still will probably only spend $100-130. It is just the owners who run the dining room but they do a great job.

            1. m
              MalibuAly Nov 29, 2006 02:41 PM

              To go dinner from DB Bistro while on a horse drawn carriage ride in Central Park.

              MATZELTOV!!!!!!! So lovely. Best of luck to you.

              1. c
                centrejack Nov 29, 2006 02:43 PM

                I second March - I took my partner there several years ago to celebrate our 1st anniversary. The food was amazing, but the service was impeccable. I remember thinking they were ninja waiters - everything was always taken care of, but you never noticed them - just the way it should be. If I recall it is a choice of 2 prix Fix menus (I think 3 or 5 courses) I don't remember which we ordered, but I do remember regretting that we did not get the wines that they matched to each course.

                Good luck

                Show Hidden Posts