After theater dessert
Friends will be visiting from out of town this weekend. They are asking me for a recommendation for an after theater dessert place. They are frequent visitors to NY so i'd like to avoid the more touristy suggestions. They are staying on 57th and 5th...so anywhere b/w there and the theater district is preferred but if a place is really great they will travel to a different neighborhood.
I can't think beyond Serendipity, Fiorellos, Venieros, Payard, Le Pain Quotidien...