HOME > Chowhound > Great Plains >

Discussion

Best Butcher in St Louis?

  • 16
  • Share

Whole Foods? Straubs? Annie Gunn's market? Bauman's? Im looking for Prime, dry aged beef specifally.

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
Delete
Posting Guidelines | FAQs | Feedback
Cancel
  1. I'll be curious to see the response to this. I don't eat a lot of beef because I don't feel that the quality I can get in St. Louis is all that great. I've not really seen any butcher that was truly dry aging their meat.

    One thing that irks me is that I can't find any grass fed beef that hasn't been frozen.

    Anyway, I've seen wet aged prime meat in some places, but not specifically dry aged. I do think The Smokehouse Market (Annie Gunn's) while not the cheapest, is one of the better shops in the area do to the butchers who are quite helpful, friendly, and do an excellent job.

    1. We had dry-aged beef the other night from Whole Foods. Not sure if it was "prime" or not. All the same, it was very good.

      1. I have to say, Straub's in both Clayton and CWE usually have very nice meat- often prime and some choice also. HOWEVER they have stopped dry aging their beef. When I asked about this, the butcher mentioned that there aren't enough people willing to shell out 40 or 50 per pound for dry aged prime, even if they have the money for it. As far as finding it around st. louis, i'm not so sure... at least it's a process of elimination.

        I had porterhouses two nights ago from the CWE that were fantastic.

        1. We usually use Straub's for high end beef but I've also driven out to the Bull Market out in the valley. They have prime beef and some other stuff too. They're still out there, right?

          1 Reply
          1. re: shannoninstlouis

            Where did you happen to buy the half side of beef and have it dry-aged at? I would like to be able to see their prices and see about getting it myself. I have a large family ( 6 ) and we would like to be able to get it so that we can have a source of good-quality beef for grilling and special occasions.

          2. I haven't had much luck with this question when you're looking for just a few cuts. I did buy half of a grass-fed cow a few months ago, and the rancher found a butcher shop that would do the cutting and dry-ageing for us. I know that buying that much cow doesn't fit into everyone's budget or household freezing capabilities, but it's worth it if you really want great beef. Some butcher shops to check out on the Illinois side would be Wenneman's in St. Libory and Behrmann's in Albers. Both shops have real friendly staff and usually are very helpful in finding what you want; they mainly deal with pork, but they can probably help you locate some grass-fed beef.

            3 Replies
            1. re: cookingkid

              I would add Schuberts in Millstadt, IL to that list as well.

              1. re: cookingkid

                cookingkid,
                Do you by chance have a contact for the rancher and butcher? I would love to friend a great local contact for fresh meat.
                Thanks,
                JohnnyBBQ

                1. re: JohnnyBBQ

                  I can't find the info for the rancher, but you can find a number of grass-fed farms in the area. If you're in St. Louis, there are two guys that sell at Maplewood Farmers' Market that raise grass-fed cattle. You can also check into American Grass Fed Beef out of Fruitland, MO.

                  I'm a little hesitant to say the name of the rancher who I bought from, mainly because he might not appreciate a cold call. Who knows, so you could look in the Sparta, IL area and you could probably find him.

                  The other thing to do is to call the local butcher shops. They buy cattle from local farmers and they process their cattle. They know who does what, what breeds they raise, and how to get in touch with them. It might be tricky at first, but the people who run Wenneman's and Behrmann's are nice enough to humor almost any request.

                  Wenneman's
                  http://www.wenneman.com/services.htm
                  7415 State Rt 15
                  St. Libory, IL 62282
                  618-768-4328

                  Behrmann's
                  http://www.behrmannmeats.com/Publicat...
                  the link is weird, but I don't know why their website doesn't come up anymore.

                  Shubert's
                  http://www.schubertspacking.com/
                  Just found out that they provide more goodies than before for the at home sausage maker.

              2. Bull Market in Chesterfield is great, but they are moving sometime away from their Savage Foods operation. Lots of items and easy to shop. If not there, I would go to Straubs for prime.

                1. Is Matekers still around? Up by Baptist Church/Concord Plaza? That used to be the only place my parents would buy meat. I think you'd be much better off looking for a small independent butcher than one of the big stores. Although can't quibble with Annie Gunn's. There's also a decent butcher out in Gray Summitt on Old Highway 100.

                  1 Reply
                  1. re: TwoPointers

                    Matekers is a good suggestion and they are still around:
                    http://www.matekers.com/

                  2. It sounds like it would be a pain-in-the-rump, but it's not impossible to dry age beef at home - I tried it with a prime rib I did a few years ago - we've also moved away from beef (health reasons) so I haven't had occassion to do it again, but it was really not difficult and if we had a bigger fridge (or a second fridge) it would have been easy easy easy - If you want a good age on your meat, I think it's worth giving it a try for the control it gives you over quality and price. Sorry I can't give you precise instructions - I think I got my method from Alton Brown - but I bet you can find instructions online.

                    1. The only grocery store in St. Louis carrying prime beef is Straubs. A few restaurants serve it, but only a few.

                      1 Reply
                      1. re: robt5265

                        The Bull Market in Chesterfield carries it for way less than Straubs.

                        FOTD

                      2. I also have been on the look out.
                        Here are my findings when purchasing Whole Beef Tenderloins.
                        Kenricks - No (Select and some Choice)
                        Behrmanns - No (Select) Although they have the best prices.
                        Wennemans - No (Select)
                        Whole Foods - No (Select/Choice)
                        Straubs - Prime/Choice but not dry aged

                        I have bought dry aged beef online from Lobel's of New York.
                        https://www.lobels.com/index.asp
                        Excellent products and quick ship but not cheap.
                        They also have grass fed