HOME > Chowhound > Los Angeles Area >

Honda-Ya Down Hill?

MEalcentric Nov 27, 2006 02:58 PM

Went last night and ordered some of my usual items(fried oysters, some skewers, ramen, etc.) Nothing was great and somethings werent even good. Nothing seemed fresh and the ramen had an off smell to it. Service was great as usual, but I am really hoping this was an off night.

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
Delete
  1. russkar RE: MEalcentric Nov 27, 2006 03:09 PM

    Unfortunately We have had the same experience twice in the last year and I don't get what the big deal is about Honda Ya other than it's open late?
    Same goes for Tommy's Sushi around the corner, absolutely terrible! I looked at the Fish in the Sushi Bar Case and walked out, frozen gassed tasteless Ahi.

    1. JAB RE: MEalcentric Nov 27, 2006 03:30 PM

      I've not been impressed with Honda-Ya's skewers. I find Shin Sen Gumi much better for that. I've had success with Kama and Crab Shu Mai at Honda-Ya.

      1. elmomonster RE: MEalcentric Nov 27, 2006 03:46 PM

        Aw, say it ain't so. I haven't been in a long while, about six months, and have been wanting to go back. I, too, hope what you experienced was just an off night. Cross-fingers.

        http://elmomonster.blogspot.com

        1 Reply
        1. re: elmomonster
          r
          Rummy RE: elmomonster Nov 27, 2006 07:02 PM

          Maybe three weeks ago, my husband and I met up in Costa Mesa with six of members of my family. During the day, we girls went shopping, hung out at the beach and tried out several local places for breakfast/lunch that I've read about here on Chowhounds (my favorite stop was the Mitsuwa market). We planned to have dinner at Honda-Ya on a Saturday evening and reserved seating in a tatami room. I was very excited to finally have an opportunity to check the place out for myself.

          Honestly, I was entirely nonplussed. While the service was good, only one person in our party of eight was happy with any of the food. We ordered at least ten different dishes, none of which impressed me. The garlic greens were a new experience for everyone and I did like them well enough (solidifying my belief that everything tastes better/great with bacon), but everything else...I just didn't get.

          Happily, this thread has been enlightening for me as I found Honda-Ya terribly disappointing and left the restaurant entirely bewildered by all of the positive reviews I've read for it here. Now I realize that perhaps the praise was not off, but rather Honda-Ya was off.

        2. g
          gachimai RE: MEalcentric Dec 16, 2006 12:40 AM

          I know this topic is old, but just found it... I agree Honda-ya has totally gone down. Izakaya Kan Yuzen in Torrance is my favorite Izakaya right now. For sure won't take family members from Japan to Honda-ya when they are homesick.

          I think Honda-ya got so popular and just started coasting on their reputation. My wife is convinced that the food is frozen.

          1. g
            GrindzHound RE: MEalcentric Dec 16, 2006 01:06 AM

            I hope this is just a case of an off night, but it sounds like it may be a trend. Was just thinking of eating there too, hmmmm.

            1. q
              quinntran RE: MEalcentric Dec 28, 2006 01:58 AM

              My hubby and I ate there last week..... we ordered the usual of ramen, yakitori and spicy tuna rolls. The ramen was way too brothy and bland and the sushi stank like it was really old..... the yakitori was still great though..... boo

              2 Replies
              1. re: quinntran
                elmomonster RE: quinntran Dec 29, 2006 02:23 PM

                Actually, their sushi never was any good. I had their poke bowl once and it was bad. This was three or four years ago, and since then I stuck to the cooked dishes. (Although not once have I ordered ramen -- I know it will never surpass Santoka, so I don't bother.)

                I just went last night after a haitus of six months, and had the usual:

                Spinach Garlic
                Garlic Greens wih Bacon
                Deep Fried Soft Shell Crab
                Homemade Crab Shumai
                Chicken Karaage and Salmon Teriyaki (2 Item Combo)
                Kalbi
                Sticks of Bacon Wrapped Okra
                Sticks of Grilled Quail Eggs
                Kani Cream Croquette
                Nikujyaga
                Green Tea Ice Cream.

                All were exactly as I remember, except the kalbi (which was a touch too sweet).

                So for me, it was fine. And I really was looking for missteps last night after reading this thread.

                What's even more surprising was their service was really efficient and top-notch last night. They anticipated exactly when we needed more refills, cleared plates, etc.

                http://elmomonster.blogspot.com

                1. re: elmomonster
                  q
                  quinntran RE: elmomonster Jan 7, 2007 08:27 AM

                  visited Honda-Ya today for my father in law's b-day dinner and was glad to find that the food was great this time around. Yay!

              Show Hidden Posts