Psst... We're working on the next generation of Chowhound! View >
HOME > Chowhound > Outer Boroughs >
Nov 22, 2006 01:26 PM

Help! I need to buy a pie today (Park Slope area).

Hi, I didn't order a pie in advance and need to go out and get one soon. Any recommendations for a good pumpkin pie and not ridiculously priced? Park Slope or Court St. preferred. Thank you and Happy Thanksgiving!

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
  1. Cousin John's on 7th Avenue might have what you want. Also, Sweet Melissa is on both Court Street & 7th Avenue. You could try calling them to see if they have pumpkin pie. Good luck and happy Thanksgiving.

    1. second cousin John's the apple crumb is great
      get a square for the road!!!


      1. I may get flame-broiled for this, and my apologies if its not what you're looking for, BUT:

        My mom (Brooklyn born and raised, as am I) swears by the Mrs. Smith's pies she gets from the supermarket (Key Food generally, but C-Town might have them). Pop them in the oven for a couple of hours and they come out looking and tasting great. I really love their apple, and have for years. I don't much care for the pumpkin, but my sister likes this one pretty well, I've found.

        (also, there's always Two Little Red Hens, in addition to Sweet Melissa and Cousin John's. I wonder if Lopez Bakery is doing Pumpkin pie?)

        1. Jump on the F Train to Manhattan and head for the Cupcake Cafe ... 9th Ave and 39st. The Apple or Cherry crumb pie both rock.

          1. I bet Union Market has 'em. No idea of pricing of course...