HOME > Chowhound > Home Cooking >

Discussion

Potatoes for mashed potatoes?

  • j

I'm making mashed potatoes for Thanksgiving (traditional kind with just milk, butter, salt & pepper) and have seen dissenting opinions on the best kind of potatoes to use. What do we think about russets vs. yukon golds? Thanks in advance!

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
Delete
  1. Either one will work. There are people who will tell you Yukon Golds aren't “floury” (starchy) enough for mashed, but they're my preferred spud for the task; I like the flavor better, and I find that russets are almost too starchy and therefore get a little “cottony” when mashed – YGs have better body. Strictly my opinions, of course.

    1. I like both, but my new favorite is fingerling (boil whole with the skins on and then mash, don't whip)

      When I do russets I bake and then rice them - gives a great, earthy potato flavor. When I use Yukons I boil, lends itself to a creamier mashed potato, and is perfect for whipping, IMO.

      1. I agree with GG. Either will work, but I prefer the flavor and creaminess of Yukon Golds over the classic Russet. No matter what you choose, I recommend baking & ricing instead of boiling, as I find it yields lighter, fluffier, and more intensely flavored mashed potatoes.

        1. We always use Yukon Golds, they make outstanding mashed potatoes. In fact, we have a friend that almost won't eat mashed potatoes unless they're Yukon's. Guess I wonder how we made out in the "old days" when there were no YG's.