HOME > Chowhound > Manhattan >

Good Cupcakes in NYC

jbel2879 Nov 16, 2006 08:49 PM

Going to Magnolia last night reminded me that they are NOT my fave. As of now Kitchenette Uptown is at the top of my list but I want to branch out. Tips?

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
  1. p
    pcwd RE: jbel2879 Nov 17, 2006 01:36 PM

    Buttercup has great cupcakes.

    1. l
      Lucia RE: jbel2879 Nov 17, 2006 03:17 PM

      tons of threads on the Manhattan board about this. Do a search.

      1. m
        myratana RE: jbel2879 Nov 17, 2006 05:54 PM

        Amy's Bread has good everything...especially the yellow cake with chocolate frosting...exactly like my mom used to make!

        however, i'm a bit biased, as personally i think my own homemade cupcakes are the best ; ) !

        1 Reply
        1. re: myratana
          themicah RE: myratana Dec 23, 2006 12:26 AM

          I wouldn't say Amy's has good everything. Amy's challah sucks. It's like stale brioche. But most of their other stuff is pretty good.

        2. j
          jem RE: jbel2879 Nov 18, 2006 06:39 PM

          If you like buttercream frosting, Cupcake Cafe is your place. Love them so much I had their cupcakes in place of a wedding cake.
          I recently had dessert Thai iced tea cupcakes and vietnamese coffee cupcakes that were really good...really moist cake and yummy frosting at Tigerland restaurant (one of my new fav places to eat).

          1. c
            chocokitty RE: jbel2879 Nov 19, 2006 01:16 AM

            Sugar Sweet Sunshine Bakery on 126 Rivington St. is one of the best I've tasted.

            4 Replies
            1. re: chocokitty
              Peter Cuce RE: chocokitty Dec 4, 2006 05:02 AM

              I find them sickly sweet, with no actual taste besides sugar. My faves are Two Little Red Hen's, Billy's, and Burgers & Cupcakes.

              1. re: Peter Cuce
                chocokitty RE: Peter Cuce Dec 29, 2006 02:12 AM

                Originally I had the Sugar Sweet Sunshine over a year ago, it tasted fine. I don't know if they've changed the recipe recently.

                I actually had a TLRH Brooklyn Blackout Cupcake a few weeks ago. I must say, it's truly divine.


              2. re: chocokitty
                BoerumHill RE: chocokitty Dec 29, 2006 04:40 PM

                I agree about Sugar Sweet Sunshine. I also think cupcake cafe is gross. The frosting is way too thick, its like if you dont close the cap of the toothpaste, and it gets all thick and nasty... ::Sigh::

                1. re: BoerumHill
                  lvecch RE: BoerumHill Jul 23, 2007 02:35 PM

                  Sugar Sweet Sunshine makes a very good Red Velvet.

                  The frosting at Cupcake Cafe tastes like wax.

              3. PlomeekSoup RE: jbel2879 Nov 22, 2006 06:35 PM

                If you want good cuppers without the eggs/dairy, try Babycakes (248 Broome --- they do frosting shots!), 'Snice (45 Eighth Ave) or Teany (90 Rivington).

                1. e
                  emmers RE: jbel2879 Nov 22, 2006 08:26 PM

                  Throwing Crumbs into the mix. Several locations around the city, almost 3 or 4 times the size of a magnolia cupcake and all sorts of funky flavors.

                  I also second Sugar Sweet Sunshine and Buttercup. Billy's Bakery is worth a try too. Personally, i go to magnolia just for the banana pudding!

                  1. SunnysideUp RE: jbel2879 Nov 22, 2006 09:34 PM

                    Little Pie Company

                    1. s
                      starfish RE: jbel2879 Dec 2, 2006 07:36 PM

                      Two Little Red Hens (Brooklyn and Manhattan) has fabulous blackout chocolate cupcakes -- really rich and delicious.

                      1 Reply
                      1. re: starfish
                        jayal RE: starfish Jul 17, 2007 05:12 PM

                        Agreed and also the red velvet

                      2. s
                        slippek RE: jbel2879 Dec 2, 2006 07:42 PM

                        There's a spot called Sage American Kitchen in Long Island City, Queens (one stop out of Manhattan on the N, R, W, E, or V) with FANTASTIC faux-Hostess treats, made in a very grown-up style. The ho-ho is a rich, moist choco cake filled with cream-cheese cream, and a great, silky, frosting. MMMM. They are affiliated with St. Bart's cafe in Manhattan, but I dunno if St. Bart's does the baked-goods thing.

                        12 Replies
                        1. re: slippek
                          nativeNYer RE: slippek Dec 3, 2006 06:52 AM

                          i've also heard two little red hens is great . i agree with re to crumbs and buttercup. i'm sure there are better, though. there's a place just south of hell's kitchen....way, way, west. i can't remember the name. it looks like a dump but it isn't. just old-fashioned and very cool.

                          1. re: slippek
                            shortstop RE: slippek Dec 3, 2006 04:15 PM

                            The Dean & Deluca on Madison &85th Street carries their cupcakes as well. The NY Times cupcake taste-off a while back gave Sage's cupcakes high praise.

                            The midtown Buttercup seems to be showing signs of slippage. Their cupcakes have been dry of late.

                            Two Little Red Hens Blackout cupcake is excellent, but their vanilla cupcakes aren't as good. Sugar Sweet Sunshine's are the best I've had recently. The cake part is incredibly moist and flavorful the frosting doesn't overpower.

                            Crumbs is nowhere on par with the City's best. Unique flavors and the cupcakes are huge, but they just don't taste good.

                            1. re: slippek
                              jenniebnyc RE: slippek Dec 5, 2006 04:56 AM

                              i second SAGE

                              1. re: slippek
                                Yaxpac RE: slippek Dec 21, 2006 05:57 PM

                                where is this Sage place, specifically? Thanks.

                                1. re: Yaxpac
                                  chompchomp RE: Yaxpac Dec 21, 2006 06:03 PM

                                  it's in Long Island City, Queens, just near P.S.1. though Dean and Deluca carries the cupcakes. they are literally the size of softballs.

                                  1. re: chompchomp
                                    Yaxpac RE: chompchomp Dec 22, 2006 12:38 PM

                                    do you have an address in LIC. I live in Astoria so it would be easier for me to go there, than to go to D&D. Thanks!

                                    1. re: Yaxpac
                                      chompchomp RE: Yaxpac Dec 22, 2006 01:30 PM

                                      Sage American Restaurant
                                      26-21 Jackson Ave (Cross Street: 43rd Avenue)
                                      Long Island City, NY 11101
                                      (212) 838-2257

                                      1. re: chompchomp
                                        bobodl RE: chompchomp Jan 12, 2007 10:23 PM

                                        I just stopped by Sage today based on this thread. I was so excited to find out that Queens finally has bakery that people are willing to recommend. I bought a couple items. I love red velvet cupcakes and I hate to say that the red velvet cupcakes at sage just didn't cut it for me. I took a bite of the cupcake and at first, I thought it was ok, but the more I ate, I realized that the cake portion was really dry. I'm not sure if this is because I went at the end of the day and the cupcakes were sitting out. If it wasn't for the frosting, I would say, the cupcake would be unedible. I also had a brownie and I liked that-not too sweet.

                                        For red velvet cupcakes, my vote so far goes to Joyce's bakery in Brooklyn.

                                        1. re: bobodl
                                          jenniebnyc RE: bobodl Jan 13, 2007 01:39 AM

                                          didn't even know they made red velvet. soory to hear it wasn't good. you must try the "hostess" cupcake. really good.

                                          1. re: bobodl
                                            nyufoodie RE: bobodl Jan 25, 2007 09:45 PM

                                            my vote for best red velvet in any form cake/cupcake is cake man raven in fort greene. he has tons of yummy old fashioned style cakes available too.

                                            1. re: bobodl
                                              apple842 RE: bobodl Feb 21, 2007 12:36 AM

                                              I like the red velvet cupcakes at Prospect Perk better than Joyce, if you're in that proximity. I think they are a little more moist, and the frosting isn't quite as sweet. Its a really good balance.

                                            2. re: chompchomp
                                              lvecch RE: chompchomp Jul 23, 2007 02:37 PM

                                              I couldn't wait to try Sage after reading this thread. Sadly, I see they close at 4:00 on weekdays and are not open on weekends. I live in Sunnyside and work in Manhattan, so I guess I'm out of luck!

                                    2. chompchomp RE: jbel2879 Dec 19, 2006 04:01 PM

                                      I would go with Sage, Two Little Red Hens, and Yura and Company on the upper east side.

                                      1. f
                                        fetegirl RE: jbel2879 Dec 21, 2006 04:30 PM

                                        Billy's and Crumbs, for sure. And Little Pie does have good ones.

                                        1. d
                                          doodle RE: jbel2879 Dec 21, 2006 04:56 PM

                                          I'm gonna have to chime in and say Eleni's in Chelsea Market.

                                          1. c
                                            chow_gal RE: jbel2879 Dec 21, 2006 09:27 PM

                                            Billy's. Crumbs are crap! The cake itself tastes cheap and artificial - their schtick is to stick tons of stuff in the frosting and filling to create 'theme' cupcakes: Snickers, Reeses, Peppermint.

                                            1. f
                                              fat league RE: jbel2879 Dec 29, 2006 02:08 AM

                                              Hm. I really have to go against the grain on this one. I've tried cupcakes at most of the places mentioned in this post, and my go-to seems to be one of the least popular: Little Cupcake in Bay Ridge. It seems to get mixed reviews at best here, but I think their Red Velvet and Chocolate Cloud are absolute knockouts. Others are good (but not as good) too.
                                              Other opinions on this thread: http://www.chowhound.com/topics/24964...

                                              1. g
                                                guffaw RE: jbel2879 Jan 2, 2007 08:38 PM

                                                Crumbs is my hands down favorite cupcake. next is little pie company....magolia's cupcakes taste like my grandmothers cornbread with sweet butter on top and buttercups are just way to dry.

                                                1. g
                                                  guffaw RE: jbel2879 Jan 2, 2007 08:38 PM

                                                  I also like "burgers and cupcakes" cupcakes

                                                  1. Nosher RE: jbel2879 Jan 13, 2007 06:31 PM

                                                    We like Billy's, Amy's, Little Pie Company, Burgers & Cupcakes, and ONLY the mocha cupcake at Cupcake Café (the rest aren't so great). Crumbs is a gigantic disappointment, as is Buttercup. We used to really like Sugar Sweet Sunshine, but the quality has gotten really iffy there of late.


                                                    NYCnosh* http://nycnosh.com

                                                    1. m
                                                      Maud RE: jbel2879 Jan 20, 2007 04:18 AM

                                                      I always see people mention Out of the Kitchen in the Village (I forget where - Hudson maybe?) in these discussions, but have never tried theirs. Anyone?

                                                      Williamsburg has its own Magnolia diaspora (like Buttercup, Sugar Sweet Sunshine, Billy's, etc.) place, on Metropoitan and Havemayer. I've liked their cupcakes.

                                                      1. s
                                                        snr RE: jbel2879 Feb 5, 2007 10:07 AM

                                                        I agree that Magnolia is not a fav anymore. I have been to Sage American Kitchen in LIC several times, and I have yet to have a bad experience. I really like the "Hostess" style cupcakes, but the red velvets are really to die for. I am a red velvet fanatic and I have never found them to be dry. That is really saying something too, because I think that they are preservative free.

                                                        1. e
                                                          eatchix RE: jbel2879 May 18, 2007 09:18 AM

                                                          definitely try BABYCAKES on 248 broome street for their spelt vanilla cupcakes which are my fav. ...sugar, wheat & gluten free! my other all time fav are the thai tea & vietnamese coffee cupcakes at TIGERLAND on 85 ave a. a true hidden spot, but worth the trip ~ soooo YUMMY!

                                                          1. k
                                                            kam0424 RE: jbel2879 May 21, 2007 01:08 PM

                                                            Try Baked in Red Hook and Atlantic Railyards in Boerum Hill Brooklyn for HUGE ones. Also, I love the banana cake and red velvet cupcakes from Billy's. I agree that cupcake cafe's frosting tastes like plastic.

                                                            1 Reply
                                                            1. re: kam0424
                                                              BrigitteT RE: kam0424 May 23, 2007 08:49 AM

                                                              Tempo Presto on 5th avenue in Brooklyn makes the loveliest cupcakes.

                                                              Light, not overly sweet frosting, with perfectly light, moist vanilla, chocolate or red devil cupcakes.

                                                              The chocolate with peanut butter frosting is my favorite.

                                                            2. g
                                                              gastronaut RE: jbel2879 May 26, 2007 08:04 AM

                                                              Hawthorne Valley Farm cupcakes. Union Sq on Weds. Fri,. and Sat. for a treat made with locally, equitably, and sustainably cultivated ingredients. Or babycakes for something both DEE-LISH but easy on the digestive tract (go out of your way for this one, people).

                                                              Other vegan ccakes of note:

                                                              (forget the name) 18th st off 8 th ave (north side of the street) is a catering/luncheon place that closes at 6. they do a vegan chocolate ccake, which is good.

                                                              s'nice on 8th ave at or around w 4th do vegan ccakes, which are not as good.

                                                              vegan ccakes can be had across town at whole earth bakery (st. marks @ ave A), as well. you may be pleasantly suprised, so long as you check your expectations at the door.

                                                              1. r
                                                                redpoint RE: jbel2879 Jun 5, 2007 10:37 AM

                                                                My 2 cents: I've tried Two Little Red Hens about five times, after many assurances that it was great, and have never been happy with my cupcakes or cakes there, Brooklyn Blackout included. I was also disappointed with Baked. My favorite by far is the cliche, red velvet from Cakeman Raven (though I haven't had them in a year).

                                                                1. e
                                                                  elizabeththinks RE: jbel2879 Jun 5, 2007 10:55 AM

                                                                  Billy's is pretty similar to Magnolia - if you're looking for somethign different, this might not be the best choice.

                                                                  1. b
                                                                    bluishgnome RE: jbel2879 Jun 13, 2007 08:09 PM

                                                                    Magnolia is disgusting. I always laugh out loud when I see a line around the corner out the door of that place. Poor fools who can't see past their blinders.

                                                                    My vote goes to Crumbs, which has a fluffier cupcake than any other I've tried... and I know they might be adding some weird stuff in there to make it that way, but heck, so be it.

                                                                    2 Replies
                                                                    1. re: bluishgnome
                                                                      addictedtolunch RE: bluishgnome Jul 4, 2007 03:27 AM

                                                                      This week as I passed Magnolia and saw no line I caved in and tried a couple. Words cannot express how wrong it is that people are being ripped off there. The cupcakes are better almost everywhere else, including probably a few prisons.

                                                                      1. re: addictedtolunch
                                                                        bluishgnome RE: addictedtolunch Jul 4, 2007 07:09 AM

                                                                        You live and you learn. ;) Better to have tried it without waiting than to have had to wait 20-30 minutes on a tourist infested line.

                                                                        Do try Sweet Sugar Sunshine on 126 Rivington St @ Essex St in the LES. It was recommended on this board and I thought the cupcakes were perfect.

                                                                    2. h
                                                                      hercules q. einstein RE: jbel2879 Jun 20, 2007 11:13 AM

                                                                      My preference would be for Downtown Atlantic in Boerum Hill (Atlantic between Hoyt and Bond). I've tried them a number of times and haven't been disappointed.

                                                                      I guess people have realized Magnolia is overrated. It seems like it's only tourists there now. I admit I always liked their banana pudding. I wouldn't go back even if the cupcakes were great - consistenly rude service means they don't get my business.

                                                                      1. gaylenwaydelich RE: jbel2879 Jul 17, 2007 11:58 PM

                                                                        The red velvet at Bubby's in tribeca was so good it made me cry. WTF is with Magnolia? I bought some for my kid and her roommate at NYU and they were inedible. The best part about them were the cute retro halloween plastic decorations. We like Crumbs in a pinch. Little Pie Co is always dependable.

                                                                        1 Reply
                                                                        1. re: gaylenwaydelich
                                                                          foodcitybytes RE: gaylenwaydelich Jul 20, 2007 10:31 AM

                                                                          Crumbs cupcakes are delicious. As are the ones from Magnolia Bakery but best wait till there is no line.

                                                                        Show Hidden Posts