HOME > Chowhound > Manhattan >

Comfort Food Suggestions...Depressed & Hungry

c
ChowDiva Oct 30, 2006 05:29 PM

Having dinner with a friend this week and we both are craving some comfort food.

Choices we're considering...

Dinner:
Home
Good
S'mac

Dessert:
Max Brenner
Chikalicious
Room 4 Dessert

Any other places that might fit this bill and be better options? Pref. below 23rd Street. Thanks...

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
Delete
  1. l
    Lucia RE: ChowDiva Oct 30, 2006 06:00 PM

    I think Home is mediocre, and good is just good for brunch. For my comfort food fix, I'd go to Maroons or Cornelia St. Cafe. From what I've read, Chikalicious and R4D aren't exactly comfort dessert places--they offer more high concept plates. And I think Max Brenner is more theme park than quality. Maroons has some great desserts if you opt to go there. otherwise, I'd opt for homestyle treats at Billy's Bakery, Amy's, or Little Pie Company.

    1. p
      piccola RE: ChowDiva Oct 30, 2006 06:21 PM

      Maybe Comfort Diner, Veselka or Miss Mamie's? Or even City Bakery...

      For dessert, try Rice to Riches if you like rice pudding. Or hit Sarabeth's.

      1. w
        wingman RE: ChowDiva Oct 30, 2006 07:06 PM

        I'd consider Phebes right off of Great Jones on Bowery - it's pretty cheap, has comfort food and is really just a nice relaxing place.

        I wouldn't suggest s'mac - I think frozen stoufers is better than their version of mac & cheese.

        1. j
          jthefoodie RE: ChowDiva Oct 30, 2006 07:49 PM

          I totally agree, s'mac tasted like cardboard and cheez whiz. I like Eatery (Hell's Kitchen) and Chat 'n' Chew (Union sq. area). Haven't been to any of the dessert places, Room 4 Dessert is on my list though. It's just a cafe, but Cosi has a fun s'mores dessert! Billy's is great. Good luck!

          1. Uptownflavor RE: ChowDiva Oct 31, 2006 04:38 PM

            I haven't tried it but people RAVE about Mamas. For some comfort soul food below 14th I suggest Day-O or Pink Tea Cup (which I also haven't tried). Oh yeah, I heard Maroons is fantastic!

            2 Replies
            1. re: Uptownflavor
              m
              maeisner RE: Uptownflavor Oct 31, 2006 05:20 PM

              The mac 'n' cheese at Mama's (east village, sadly west village now closed) is outstanding. It has about 2 cloves of garlic per serving. If you're a garlic lover like me, that's a good thing, but I could see other's being put off. Mashed potatoes are great too and I've heard raves about the fried chicken and meatloaf.

              1. re: maeisner
                Non Cognomina RE: maeisner Oct 31, 2006 06:05 PM

                I LOVE Mamas. Crave it often. The mac and cheese and mashed potatoes with any of the sauteed greens make a great comfort dinner. Of course, the fried chicken is a winner when I need something really comforting. Plus, it smells so good in there. Just don't sit by the front door on a cold day--you'll get a chilly breeze every time someone comes in.

            2. j
              jenhen2 RE: ChowDiva Oct 31, 2006 04:40 PM

              I liked S'mac's veggie mac, but that was the only one I've tried. There is nothing like mac n cheese when you're hungry and depressed, though.

              1. mashpee RE: ChowDiva Oct 31, 2006 04:55 PM

                I would recommend 41 Greenwich Avenue (formerly known as Jones; also formerly known as Jonez) in the West Village.

                The last time I was there, which was admittedly over a year ago, I had a truly outstanding hamburger interlaced with onions, macaroni and cheese studded with bacon and delicious tomato soup. The menu also has more upscale options, but at its core it is true comfort food that is thoughtful and well executed without being gimmicky.

                I like Chikalicious, but would not recommend it when one is searching for comfort food. These are more fussy desserts.

                Hope you feel better!

                1. b
                  batiekakes RE: ChowDiva Oct 31, 2006 05:56 PM

                  I ate at 24 Prince the other night and thought it was pretty good ...

                  1. h
                    haleyjen RE: ChowDiva Oct 31, 2006 06:06 PM

                    Cafeteria or Eatery. Both good for this.

                    1. c
                      coolpapabell RE: ChowDiva Nov 25, 2006 10:39 AM

                      Rice to Riches on Spring should do the trick. Best to take home and eat over a period of time. A little rich for one sitting. Or try their small Diva size (Chocolate Chip).

                      1. emilia RE: ChowDiva Nov 26, 2006 03:05 AM

                        i second the nom for Chat n' Chew (off union sq)'s mac n cheese- the ultimate in comfort food.
                        my personal favorite comfort food would be a big steaming bowl of homemade ramen, courtesy Rai Rai Ken (on 10th b/w 2nd & 3rd, i think).

                        Show Hidden Posts