HOME > Chowhound > New Orleans >

Discussion

Fried Oyster / Shrimp Po-boys

  • j
  • jnc Oct 30, 2006 02:47 PM

When it comes to a fried oyster or shrimp po-boy place, is there a standout choice within walking distance of the quarter? Acme's oysters were a bit too breaded and overcooked for me last time (6 mo ago) and Johnnie's shrimp po-boy (also 6 mo ago) was voluminous yet quite ho-hum. Some of the best fried stuff (to me) used to be at the sadly now defunct Deanie's. Thanks for your recommendations!!!

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
Delete
Posting Guidelines | FAQs | Feedback
Cancel
  1. I'll probably get flamed as a tourist for saying this, but I like the shrimp/oyster po-boys at Mothers. Definitely overpriced, but good.

    1 Reply
    1. re: saeyedoc

      thanks for the tip, I only tend to think about the debris / ferdi when I'm there...

    2. get the oyster loaf at casamento's. you would have to take the magazine st. bus to get there, however, but its the best oyster place in town. i also like the shrimp po-boys at mothers, and i am local.

      1 Reply
      1. re: charve1

        will do, thank you!!

      2. Crabby Jack's, 428 Jefferson Highway, Jefferson, (504) 833-2722.

        It's owned by Jacques, the owner of Jacques-Imo's, and the po boys are terrific!

        2 Replies
        1. re: Friend of Bill

          thanks, I didn't know that!

          1. re: Friend of Bill

            Absolutely not walkable, but I second this rec.

          2. absolutely gotta ditto Crabby Jacks...but yeah, gotta get a rental car, cab ride is too much...had their duck po-boy yesterday....really sloppy and really good

            I'll also second Mother's, yeah it caters to tourists but it's still amazing!

            One other recommendation...Domilise's...bit of a treck but if you're taking the bus uptown by way of Magazine it's not that bad a hike if it's a nice day.

            1. I will confess - my kid worked there when he was a Tulane student! (Also at Jacques-Imo's). But it is still good!

              1. Do not forget to try Liuzza's By The Track, near N. Lopez & Esplanade. It is a good walk from the Quarter, but their po-boys are super, especially the Garlic Oyster and the BBQ Shrimp ones.

                1. I've had some very good oyster po-boys at the Broad St. Discount Market, corner S. Broad & Banks. I'm always interested in the low cuisine, you might say, and liek to take the opportunity to get po-bys from the mom and pop groceries. Good crispy french bread and nice, crispy, but small oysters. Good and sweet, tho, with a nice salty aftertaste on them. Their oyster po boy is about 7.99, I think, and they also do a 36-inch monster for families. No problem with number of ersters---you'll have enuff falling off to put on some white bread. As a historical note, my old favorite was the College Inn, but they have a revamped and much abbreviated menu.

                  1. Mother's Mother's Mother's

                    1. What is this "debris" all about?

                      1 Reply
                      1. re: Sara T.

                        Debris refers to broken-up pieces of roast beef soaked in gravy...can be shreds or small chunks or the small irregular outside pieces that can't be cut into uniform slices.

                      2. There are (or were) TWO Deanies's--the one on Annunication Street at Poeyfare has fabulous shrimp po-boys. Also try Elizabeth's at Chartres and Gallier. They are excellent.