HOME > Chowhound > General Topics >
Brewing beer, curing meat, or making cheese? Get great advice
TELL US

Why are most entrees limited to one type of meat?

ipsedixit Oct 22, 2006 02:37 AM

With the exception of surf 'n turf offerings (lobster/steak), most entrees generally feature only one type of meat.

Why?

Why not have a dish of tilapia and dover sole, and just reduce the portion of each type of fish?

Or how about pork and lamb? Maybe scallops and prawns?

Your thoughts?

  1. h
    Humbucker Oct 22, 2006 02:52 AM

    There are plenty of entrees that feature multiple meats, but they are generally known by names that don't describe the meats they contain so they may seem less obvious (paella, jambalaya, cassoulet, mixed grill, club sandwich, etc.).

    1. d
      diropstim Oct 22, 2006 03:14 AM

      Also, most of the above are casserole or single-pot dishes. Seafood dishes often will contain a medley of different proteins, since they all cook quickly and in the same sautee pan. (Except when I cooked at Oceana. The poor kid on the line next to me had to sear off each kind of fish for the bouillabaisse separately. In a different pan. TO ORDER.) The only other fish dish I can recall that combined different species was this precious french dish wherein I had to actually braid together long strands of salmon, sole and bass before steaming the braid in court-bouillon. I always thought that was kind of a dumb dish. As for mixed grills, I've served my fair share and let me tell you it is NO FUN to have to mark off and moniter temps on four pieces of meat for every single cover that comes your way. The degree of difficulty, the lack of storage for all those proteins ( without cross-contaminating them )under the line, and the simple fact that they're clunky, presentation-wise ( no matter what you do, you basically got a heap o' brown on your plate) may all factor into their scarcity on most chefs' menus.

      1. PBSF Oct 22, 2006 03:21 AM

        There are many things that go into planning a menu. First is to balance the menu with number of poultry, seafood and meat entrees. That takes care of certain diners that do not want lamb or can't eat pork or allgeric to shrimp but not scallop. If there is lamb and pork in one entree, it won't satisfy either a pork hater or a lamb hater. Also certain marinade or preparation or sauce is better suited for one type of meat. There is also the sides to consider...mashed potato may go well with a beef dish but not a lamb, eggplants might go better with lamb and not beef.

        1. AnneInMpls Oct 22, 2006 04:30 AM

          One of my best meals of 2005 featured roasted monkfish with shredded braised beef ribs. It was amazing. I had some qualms when ordering it, as I couldn't picture fish with beef, but I was so pleased once I did.

          This meal was at Vincent in Minneapolis (a top French restaurant), but they change the menu frequently, so this dish is long gone - alas. I could eat it every day.

          Anne

          1. limster Oct 22, 2006 05:40 AM

            It's quite traditional to cook chicken with ham or even certain types of fish with ham in Cantonese dishes. And of course the luxurious Buddha Jump Over the Wall has several types of meats and seafood all in the same dish.

            1. Morton the Mousse Oct 22, 2006 07:26 AM

              Just off the top of my head, I've eaten most of these within the year:

              pancetta wrapped halibut
              fresh pasta stuffed with short ribs and salami
              bollito misto
              filet topped with foie gras
              quail stuffed with foie gras
              quail stuffed with sausage
              quail stuffed with bacon
              cassoulet
              rotisserie chicken with mussels
              fish and shellfish stew
              bacon wrapped squab
              porridge of duck, pork cheek and beef brisket
              hamburger with bacon
              Then of course there's the two, three or four way in bbq.

              You tend to see multiple meats in stews, and cured pork goes well with just about everything.

              2 Replies
              1. re: Morton the Mousse
                Glencora Oct 22, 2006 05:40 PM

                I'm very jealous. Especially of all that quail. Rotisserie chicken with mussels sounds strange, though. Was it good?

                1. re: Glencora
                  Morton the Mousse Oct 22, 2006 06:07 PM

                  The chicken with mussels worked alright, though it was not the highlight of this list. The sauce at the bottom of the plate combining chicken drippings with mussel juice was excellent.

                  I've got a great French take out place down the street from my house - two stuffed quails for $17! So I eat a fair amount of stuffed quail. I love it, especially the one with foie gras.

              2. Karl S Oct 22, 2006 11:33 AM

                Because most diners are picky. REstaurants have learned this the hard way.

                1. NovoCuisine Oct 22, 2006 05:56 PM

                  True, what Karl said.

                  I eat at a lot of Portguese places and it is quite common for seafood and sausage to be together. Mostly stew-type-things, though; oh, but there are clams and choriço, one of my favorite combos.

                  Other than that, I can't think of any mixing of meats.

                  1. pilotgirl210 Oct 27, 2006 12:12 AM

                    One of my favorite foods is Hong Kong Special Low Mein....bbqd pork, ham, shrimp, beef and chicken sauted with water chestnuts, peapods and bok choy in a wonderful sauce over pan-fried noodles. The meats don't compete at all.

                    1. m
                      Mr. Cookie Oct 27, 2006 12:39 AM

                      Actually, in L.A., the rage among many high-end restaurants is to serve a fish dish with meat components/flavorings. As someone who loves fish and doesn't eat meat, this is driving me crazy.

                      Show Hidden Posts