HOME > Chowhound > Manhattan >

Steak Tartare

w
wazup1999 Oct 20, 2006 09:41 PM

I'm craving steak tartare. I want it to be delicious and be so big that I'll laugh trying to finish it. Esoteric and random spots are encouraged. I'm thinking about Payard, Steak Frites, Balthazar?

Thanks again!

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
Delete
  1. h
    hardcore RE: wazup1999 Oct 20, 2006 09:55 PM

    some of the better that I've had recently.....Blue Ribbon...Bette (ask for the entree portion..superb!).....360 (it was a special..so call ahead)

    1. h
      haleyjen RE: wazup1999 Oct 20, 2006 10:00 PM

      Le Bilboquet's is pretty damn good.

      1. d
        diropstim RE: wazup1999 Oct 20, 2006 10:10 PM

        Balthazar has quite the delicious tartare (in both app and entree portions.Trust me, get the app--- it's so frickin' rich that I normally split the app with another hound and am still satisfied with the portion. Plus, this leaves room for the best oysters and frites in the city, and I defy any and all to contradict me on either of those assertions).
        One caveat:well, two, actually: One: the tartare is pre-mixed in the kitchen, not tableside, and two: the meat is ground, rather than brunoised, so it's likely sirloin, strip and Cote de boeuf scraps, not tenderloin. And the mouthfeel is definitely not quite what it should be. Oh, and three: no raw egg yolk, unless it's already been ground in there, which is a real possibility. I mean, something in there is riching it out. So overall I guess I'd give Balth's tartare a 7.5.
        For the whole diced, tableside shebang go to Employees Only on Hudson street near Bleecker. And the quintissential, archetypal ur-mother of all tartares continues to reside, as ever, at the 21 club. But now you're talking serious scratch.

        1. c
          cricri7 RE: wazup1999 Oct 20, 2006 10:19 PM

          I had one at Père Pinard, on the lower east side, and it was made at the table. It was really good and not too expensive. The terrace in the back of the restaurant is quite nice. Y9ou go there when it is not too hot outside because with the kitchen, it gets quite hot inside the restaurant...and also quite noisy! The wine is not too expensive.

          1 Reply
          1. re: cricri7
            m
            mrnyc RE: cricri7 Oct 20, 2006 10:41 PM

            ^ i second that, its my usual tartare spot. i also get my tartare at FLEA MARKET too fairly regularly, but its made up back in the kitchen. both are good and rather inexpensive choices in the les/ev.

          2. c
            cfrick004 RE: wazup1999 Oct 20, 2006 10:52 PM

            I don't eat meat, so I can't personally comment. But friends had it at Employees Only and I thought it looked interesting.....they liked it.

            1. l
              lynny_lynny RE: wazup1999 Oct 20, 2006 11:42 PM

              ok well i tried all over the city and I have to say that the appetizer portion at Balthazar's is by far the best around. You will not be sorry! The second in line is from Dylan Prime on Laight Street downtown. Enjoy!

              1. d
                dbird RE: wazup1999 Oct 21, 2006 12:12 AM

                In NYC, I have had the steak tartare at Les Halles, Balthazar, Pere Pinard, Employees Only, Odeon, Country, A Voce, Pastis, Payard, L'Express, La Goulue, Artisanal, and I am sure I am missing others as I order it whenever I see it on a menu. I have posted previously on a number of these so will just say that a craving right now would send me to Payard, Odeon or A Voce. Payard's is presented a little fussily but the brunoise and flavour are just right. Odeon is more classic but not tableside. A Voce is decadent with walnuts and maybe also truffle (can't recall) and presented in quenelles but mighty tasty. I can't believe NY Mag named Country's best in NYC. The pickling obliterates both the chanterelles and the meat.

                1. t
                  tsiblis RE: wazup1999 Oct 21, 2006 10:10 PM

                  My favorite is at L'Express on 20th St., which isn't as upscale as the other places but I prefer the way the meat is seasoned. Their fries are great but so are the fries at Balthazar and Pastis.

                  1. guttergourmet RE: wazup1999 Oct 22, 2006 12:09 PM

                    I'd add Casimir on Avenue B and Bistro 60 on 60th between Park and Mad

                    Show Hidden Posts