HOME > Chowhound > San Francisco Bay Area >

Discussion

Olive Oil Tasting in the Napa Valley

"Wait, let me get this straight...you're coming to Napa Valley but you don't drink wine?!"

That was the proprietor of Dutch Henry wines when I called to ask if I could visit his vineyard to taste his olive oils. Though a bit amused, he was happy to have me. Good thing, because his EVOO (extra virgin olive oil) was incredible.

When most people think of the wine country the last thing that comes to mind is sitting on a gorgeous estate taking leisurely sips of oil. Yet, Napa is home to over 50 artisinal olive oil producers and the industry is growing fast. The Mediterranean climate is ideal for olive trees and there is a well established clientele for luxury food items. However, the olive oil industry has yet to become a tourist destination and despite myriad producers, organizing a tasting is fraught with difficulties.

A few weeks ago I spent several long hours calling every certified EVOO producer in Napa. When I started, I assumed that I was going to be able to pick and choose which producers I visited from the lengthy list. Instead I found that only a handful would have me. There are several factors intrinsic in EVOO production which makes public tastings unrealistic. Most EVOO producers are small scale farmers that do not have the resources to offer a formal tasting room. They have neither the capital nor the supply to mill on site, they send their olives to a community mill where the oil is bottled and then distributed to retail outlets, and it is inefficient to transport the oil from the mill back to the estate. Most importantly, production is extremely limited and for good EVOO demand exceeds supply. A producer can expect a yield of about one gallon of oil from a healthy olive tree. A good producer will sell out of their entire crop every year. Why bother pouring free samples and investing in a tasting room when you're already selling out?

Despite these hurdles, I tasted about 25 EVOOs over the past two days and a third as many vinegars. The purpose of this report is to guide anyone who is visiting Napa and looking to take a short break from the standard series of wine tastings. I will direct you to a few choice destinations where you can taste superior EVOO and learn a bit about tasting and production methods.

Round Pond was the highlight of my visit, and I highly recommend it to anyone visiting Napa who has any interest in food. They are the only place in Napa that specializes in EVOO production and offers tastings and tours of their facility. I saw their state of the art mill, learned how the milling process worked, learn the techniques they use to guarantee a superior oil (including picking every olive by hand!) and enjoyed a wonderful tasting. I learned the proper way to taste an olive oil (you take a large sip in your mouth, let it coat your tongue and then suck air through it to release the flavors) which was incredible useful for the remainder of my trip. Equally fascinating was learning how to taste vinegar by sucking it off a sugar cube (the sweetness neutralizes the acidity and allows you to taste the flavor of the vinegar).

Not only was the tour informative but the tasting was delicious. Heirloom tomatoes from the garden, fresh mozzarella cheese and their full line of oils, vinegars and fruit syrups. This was just a tasting, not their full lunch, and I was really surprised with their generosity. The cost was $20 for a 90 minute tour and tasting, an excellent value though I wish we could have spent some time walking amongst the private orchards. Most importantly, all of their products were INCREDIBLE! The oils had a wonderful depth of flavor and a lovely, peppery finish. Particularly noteworthy is their meyer lemon olive oil which completely turned me around on flavored olive oils. Whereas most olive oil companies add flavorings to oil, Round Pond mills meyer lemon peels along with the oil creating a unified product that is truly special. After a weekend of tasting I returned to Round Pond and purchased their entire product line.

Longmeadow Ranch is an integrative agriculture operation in Calistoga that produces EVOO, vinegar, grass fed beef, free range eggs and a variety of organic produce. I really wanted to take a walking tour of the ranch but sadly they were closed for a private event. However, I had a great time visiting their public garden and farm stand just off the highway in Rutherford (just north of Napa). They encouraged us to wander around the garden and sample the strawberries and figs fresh off the plant. I purchased some delicious fruit and had a nice chat with one of the owners about issues facing grass fed beef production. The EVOO, though very good, did not stack up to Round Pond's products. Regardless, it was a great stop, ideal for picking up some fresh fruit for snacking, and I can't wait to visit their ranch to sample their beef and eggs. The farm stand is open Saturdays from 10-3.

While in Rutherford, I decided to visit the St. Helena Olive Oil Company. Though retail shops are not quite as "fun" as going to the source, they're nice because you can try a variety of oils in one place. Also, as many producers don't have tasting rooms, retail shops are the only place you can sample their wares. Well, SHOO was a big disappointment. They had a whole range of olive oils and vinegars to sample but they lacked proper sampling equipment and expected you to taste everything using tiny plastic spoons. There was no way to get enough of a mouthful to really taste the oil and the plastic left an off flavor on each sample. None of the oils stood out, but I feel that it is unfair for me to judge them using such poor methodology. I may return with my own tasting glass, but overall I expected much more from a place specializing in olive oil tasting.

After a lovely lunch at Market in St Helena (report to follow) I decided to hit up a few more olive oil shops. Olivier had a decent tasting facility but their oils were entirely unremarkable. Far more impressive was Tasting on Main. Though chiefly a wine shop they had three excellent EVOOs and proper glassware. They were, in fact, the only place other than Round Pond that had EVOO tasting glasses. We wound up purchasing the OliOdessa Koroneiki a Spanish variety with complex flavors that came together for a clean finish. Tasting on Main is the only retail shop that I would recommend.

I ended the tasting with a trip to two vintners that also produce EVOO-Dutch Henry and Silverado. Two nice things about visiting vintners: even if they charge for a wine flight they will sample EVOO for free and even if they don't have proper EVOO glasses a wine glass will always suffice. Dutch Henry was a lovely spot with a gorgeous estate and a quaint little tasting room. Their EVOO was outstanding – much more mellow than Round Pond's but with a real depth of flavor. Most of the mellow Spanish varieties I tasted were simply bland, but Dutch Henry was robust and fruity with just a hint of bitterness and a slightly peppery finish. Though the most expensive EVOO of the trip ($42 for 500 ml) I bought a bottle without hesitation. I found the whole experience to be quite charming and I'm curious what some of our wine hounds think of their offerings. Silverado was a fun place to visit though I didn't love their EVOO. It felt like it was straight out of a commercial for Napa Valley – Spanish Revival architecture, sweeping views of the valley, an enormous tasting room chock full of tourists. I had a nice time relaxing on their patio and though their EVOO was perfectly good, it didn't make the cut.

I had a fantastic time in Napa and Mrs. Mousse is thrilled with the collection of oils we've amassed for her cooking (she was with me for the whole trip, of course, I just prefer writing in first person singular). It was fun to do something "different" in a town where every visitor pretty much does the same thing. I learned a lot and I discovered some lovely oils that I will likely buy for years to come.

If I do another tasting I will probably time it in February or March when the oils are newly released as some of the places I tried to visit were sold out (this is the end of the season) and others had a limited selection (I can't wait to try Round Pond's blood orange oil next year). I will bring my own tasting glasses and I will probably branch out to Sonoma and visit McEvoy ranch and some of the other local producers. Some day, if I'm made of money I'll do the Great Olive Oil Tour: for $500+ a head you get access to private estates and oils that you can't sample anywhere else.

Wow! Only three pages single spaced. Can't help but wonder if anyone is still reading...

To summarize my trip:

Round Pond is an absolute must visit

Rutherford Gardens is right off the highway and worth a stop

If you're in St Helena (and you should go, the food is great) drop by Tasting on Main

If you're really into EVOO, take the drive out to Dutch Henry

References:
www.roundpond.com
www.longmeadowranch.com
www.tastingonmain.com
www.dutchhenry.com

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
Delete
  1. Awesome! We've got our tour with Round Pond scheduled, and now I'm really excited. You said the tour was 90 minutes, right? Did you still have room for lunch? Can't wait to read your report on Market, did you go anywhere else?

    Thanks for the report (yes, I read it all). :)

    1 Reply
    1. re: Cindy

      You should have room for lunch about an hour after the tour, it depends on how much oil you eat (drink?)

      I'll have another report or two out tomorrow.

    2. what a fantastic post. definetely will add this to my list of to do's!

      1. Splendid, splendid report! I'm glad you found more tasting opportunities than I thought you would, and had the chance to learn something about the production process. I'd really encourage you to try to taste the new oils in February and March. I've done this a couple times when I've happened to be in France in March and the youthful bite of the new vintage is so interesting to compare with the mellowed oil from the last year.

        Tunisian olive oil tasting -
        http://www.chowhound.com/topics/show/...

        1 Reply
        1. re: Melanie Wong

          Thanks, Melanie, I definitely took your comment as a challenge and I did my best to get my shoes dirty.
          I'm really excited about doing another tasting in March and visiting Sonoma as well as Napa. I'm not too worried about using all this oil up before then.

          That link is great and has a much more detailed description of how to taste the oil than I provided (my post was long enough as it is).

        2. This is one of the best reports I've ever seen on Chowhound. Thanks for all that information that was new to me. Prior to this I thought the olive oil thing was a yawn. I learned so much. Thanks Morton.

          1 Reply
          1. re: rworange

            I agree; I read every word start to finish. Thanks for taking the time to share your research and experience w/ the board.

            If you should venture down to the Santa Cruz area, there's Le Colline di Santa Cruz w/ acreage in Aptos. Haven't been or tasted their product yet, but just something for folks to put on their radar.

            Here's an article from the SC Sentinel:
            http://www.santacruzsentinel.com/arch...

          2. On your recommendation, I went to Round Pond today, and had a great time. I loved the olive oils, but what I fell in love with was one of their vinegars, tasting it was really a revelation. Thanks for this report, I wouldn't have thought of adding this to my Napa trip otherwise.

            1. We did Round Pond this weekend - it was a really fun, informative and informal tour - there were only two of us so we got to ask lots of questions. $20 per person for the tour and tasting is really a good deal!

              They bottle their oil 3 times during the year, to give consumers the opportunity to purchase the freshest oil. The weather from the past year was really damaging - they have no spanish olives (the milder oil) for this coming year. They are out of the spanish olive oil from last year's harvest - the only way to purchase it is to buy their sampler pack (which we did). Their flavored oils for this year will be made using italian olives harvested very late.

              DH and I aren't wine drinkers - but we loved their vinaigrettes - how fascinating to me that a winery would create olive oils, then vinaigrettes (and fruit syrups). What a creative product line!

              Family owned and run. They are building another building across the lane (hopefully by June 2007) to house their wine tours. Highly recommended.

              2 Replies
              1. re: Cindy

                I am thinking of buying some of their vinegars from their website. Could you give me feedback on what you thought of their vinegars? Sangiovese vs cabernet/merlot blend. We love to sip vinegar as an appertif and was wondering if you had a chance to sip some vinegars during the tour. TIA

                Margret

                1. re: margret

                  Okay, keep in mind that we don't drink wine (and therefore don't appreciate its qualities) - I really liked the sangiovese mix. My initial comment was how "unsour" the vinaigrette was - but it was rich in flavors that I couldn't necessarily identify, but I could see myself enjoying.

                  Of course, DH liked the cabernet/merlot blend better. So with the 6-pack sampler we purchased, we gave the cabernet to my MIL, and we kept the sangiovese.

              2. Thanks for the link. I think the Round Pond tour really helps novices like myself who don't have a clue. Now that we know a little more about olive oil and such, we can go to other places that might have tastings but no tour guides.

                1. I wanted to correct a piece of misinformation in this post. Great Olive Oil Tours does not charge $500/head, they charge $75/hour for a group of up to four people. I'm not sure where I got the original price from, but it was incorrect.

                  1. Round Pond does offer a free tasting during certain months on certain days - it's on their website. I went some months ago and it was fantastic. I ended up buying the blood orange olive oil and the lemon olive oil for myself and as gifts. Really great stuff provided by friendly, informative people.

                    1. Great post. Thanks.

                      I joined Round Pond's club last month (mailings are wine plus olive oil) and couldn't agree with you more. Fabulous.

                      Two notes to add: First, the tour at Round Pond winery includes appetizers and wine on the open air level overlooking their vineyards. We had out of state guests who are veterans of Napa. They (and we all) said that the view from this elevation was the most stunning we had ever seen in Napa. You look towards highway 29 but can't see it because the wonderful trees in the intermediate distance frame the landscape. Worth the visit.

                      Second, after the winery tour we took our friends to lunch/tasting at the Round Pond olive oil facility across the street. There, we sampled all their products over a lunch (provided for a fee by Round Pond) of chicken, prosciutto, mozzarella, tomatoes and Italian-type bread followed by cheese and a Meyer lemon/olive oil cake. Delicious!

                      Here's to Round Pond!