This may have already been a topic, but I'm only in town on a monthly basis. I went there last year and thought it was pretty good. I just read a lot of scathing reviews on New York Restaurants. Anyone been there recently and can comment - was going to drag the boyfriend there next trip.
I think its a mediocre steakhouse based on my visit there. All sizzle no steak. The steaks I've had have certainly looked like Peter Luger's but had absolutely no taste. like eating charred tofu. Granted its been about a year since I've last been, but there are so many other great steakhouses in NY I've never had a reason to try them again.
My favorites, besides Lugers, are Strip House, Keens, BLT Steak/Prime.