HOME > Chowhound > All New England Archive >

Benny's in Portland ME--any good?

cfrolio Sep 24, 2006 01:35 AM

Benny's is a seafood-shack-kinda place all by itself at the far west end of Commercial St. I've driven by many times but have never eaten there. Does anyone know if it's any good?

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
  1. i
    irwin RE: cfrolio Sep 25, 2006 11:59 AM

    Keep driving a little more and stop @ BECKY's......

    3 Replies
    1. re: irwin
      Joanie RE: irwin Sep 25, 2006 04:45 PM

      But is Becky's where you want to go if you want a seafood shack?

      1. re: Joanie
        irwin RE: Joanie Sep 25, 2006 09:42 PM

        I thought they are asking if its good or not, and not asking for a seafood shack! Am I right or wrong?

        1. re: Joanie
          irwin RE: Joanie Oct 16, 2006 02:17 PM

          Y E S

      2. c
        cfrolio RE: cfrolio Sep 26, 2006 01:46 AM

        Thanks (I guess) for the Becky's rec! To repeat my question, I'd like to hear from anyone who's been to Benny's and can offer an opinion on the food there

        5 Replies
        1. re: cfrolio
          Boodles RE: cfrolio Sep 26, 2006 05:13 PM

          I go to Benny's every few weeks. It's not too far from where I work. I can get in and out of there fairly quickly. Anyhow, to answer your question, it is good, not great. I usually get a haddock sandwich or fish & chips. I think the portion size is a bit small, but the quality is good and the fish is cooked correctly. I had a lobster roll there once: same comment, small, but good enough. I don't care for Becky's. A lot of hype, food & service just so-so.

          1. re: Boodles
            irwin RE: Boodles Sep 28, 2006 12:36 AM

            HYPE--thats what makes it interesting, especially if you also want to people-watch!

            1. re: irwin
              sophie fox RE: irwin Sep 28, 2006 01:55 AM

              Well, I have not been to Benny's, so I don't know if it's good.

              I did think that that was the question that cfrolio asked - and not how fabulous someone thinks that Becky's may be.

              Can anyone tell us about Benny's?

              1. re: sophie fox
                Boodles RE: sophie fox Sep 28, 2006 02:21 AM

                I spoke about Benny's. Benny's is good, not great. I go there every few weeks. If I didn't work a mile or so away, I probably wouldn't go there, but I do and it's a good place for lunch. The fried seafood is good, the lobster rolls are good. The portion size is smallish. The price is medium. It's clean, rarely crowded, nor deserted. My brother, who lives in New York, likes it as a quick fix for lobster roll when he's in Portland. There used to be a place called Bill's down on the point, back in the 60's that sold clam cakes for 25 cents a piece. Bill's was worth the trip from Peaks Island where we lived back then. Benny's isn't Bill's, but it's what we got now.

                1. re: sophie fox
                  irwin RE: sophie fox Oct 18, 2006 01:33 PM

                  it was a suggestion and not a demand !
                  Sorry if I gave you a bad day.

          2. j
            jackattack RE: cfrolio Oct 17, 2006 10:13 PM

            Wow I always wanted to meet someone who lived on Peak's Island. And wondered where they went to eat.

            1. b
              Boodles RE: cfrolio Oct 27, 2006 01:32 AM

              I drove by Benny's today. It is closed for the season.

              Show Hidden Posts