this is embarrassing, but...
I too, love that show. Unfortunately, the only restaurant post-RM that we've been to is the Silk Road Café. I was impressed with the new decor. The previous one was starting to get a little gungy. The food was good, but not drastically different.
I would like to try the Town Grill as I've heard good things about it.
I can recommend the Town Grill as I was there fairly recently. Had the pea soup with a toasted curry oil to start and it was excellent, for a main I had the beef tenderloin which tasted nice but arrived lukewarm, likely due to the fact that we were a large party and I don't know if the kitchen staff exceeds 1. For dessert I had the "warm butterscotch-walnut brownie" which was delicious.
Service was terrific - our server was a co-owner (the wife of one of the two male owners featured on the show). And she was happy to recount funny stories about the makeover when we brought it up.
Don't be embarassed! I love that show ;)
I like College Street Bar a lot. Great beers on tap, good wines, and tasty food reasonably priced. I was there with my BF for our three year anniversary in February; cozy for couples!
I think the owner changed a couple of things back to pre-RM (e.g. wall colour) so it's interesting to note not everything stays the same after a makeover.