Best of the Trappist Beers
Which of the six do you think is the best?
-
-
-
Since the six true trappists have been hashed to death on this thread, I thought I would mention a few I like that are Belgian but not true Trappist.
Gouden Carolus makes some very nice Belgians, especially their Noel Christmas ale - it might be my favorite Belgian, that or St Bernardus 12.
Struise Pannepot is right up there also.
I love the flavor of Des Rocs Brune and Grand Cru, but you have to get past the weird floating chunks of sediment (which don't bother me).
›6 Replies-
-
-
-
re: gtweath
I'd forgotten about this thread.
Recently my sister-in-law got me a couple of Rochefort 10s...
The best approximation I can make to their taste is "chocolate-covered rainbows"I haven't had the St Bernardus 12 (not available here) but I have had the Prior 8 and it's among my favorite beers; and by far my favorite Dubbel.
-
-
-
-
-
re: Tripeler
me too, and i've drank all other trappist beers multiple times, some on tap and in bottle. but Westmalle tripel (and/or dubbel) every day keeps the doctor away. in terms of price-quality it's a brilliant tripel. plus, most supermarkets stock it. so much beer pleasure for only eur. 1.25
-
re: Pata_Negra
I really like the balance of Westmalle Tripel. Not to far away in any direction, just right.
Of course, Orval is very interesting, but it really needs to be fresh and well cared for.
Rochefort 10 is interesting, but really too much unless it is really cold outside.
Chimay has really been dumbed down too much in recent years, though the White on draft is fairly refreshing.
-
-
-
I've only tried La Trappe (all), Chimay (all), St Bernardus (Prior 8 and Tripel)
From those... My favorites are Trappe Quadrupel, Chimay Red, and St Bernardus 8
I look forward to trying Rochefort 10 (already spotted a place that sells it here in Chile, but it's like $15 for a 330ml bottle) and Orval (same place)
›1 Reply -
-
re: slvrmermaidgurl
I think the constant confusion is due to Koningshoeven Brewery in The Netherlands, who were off of the Trappist Brewery list for 6 years. A few years ago I once again saw the logo on one of their bottles and wondered when the heck that happened.
-
-
re: chimay5
Aren't they the same beers, only labeled differently for different markets? That's the implication given by the US Importer:
"In the USA and Canada the La Trappe Trappist Ales are marketed under the name Koningshoeven Trappist Ale."
-
re: JessKidden
Well, what I saw were La Trappe and Koningshoeven side by side in a retail account last week. I just wondered if the trade mark dispute had been settled with the US holder of the La Trappe trade name.
I'm sure the beers are the same and that one or the other name will disappear.
-
-
-
-
-
Westvleteren, particularly the 12, has been my favorite beer for a long time. When I was in grad school, it was available on the shelf at my local Whole Foods. I haven't drunk it in quite a while, unfortunately--maybe five years now. I know it's available online.
Next, Rochefort. I don't really like the 6 that much but the 8 and 10 are excellent.
Chimay is next. I think I would rate them white, blue, red. I think the white is possibly the best Belgian tripel.
Then Westmalle. I have very fond memories of the dubbel from drinking it in various locations (oh yes, the bar in Amsterdam). It's light and not so complex (compared to other famous dark Belgians, especially quadrupels), but it's elegant and delicious. The tripel is also very good.
Achel next. I've not had this beer so many times. When I have, I've thought, damn all Belgian beers are good, but I've not liked it as much as the ones above.
And last, Orval. This is the one my dad likes, and I realize we have absolutely opposite tastes. This is the trappist beer that tastes most like "beer" as we Americans know it. Dry, tangy, hoppy, refreshing. More often than not, I'd rather have a contemplative beer like Rochefort 10.
Though it's not a trappist beer, I would like to mention that St Bernardus is very much like the Trappists--the 12 (quadrupel) is on par with Rochefort 10 and Westvleteren 12, the tripel is excellent, and the white beer is very good too.
›3 Replies-
-
-
re: kelarry
"St. Bernardus is made from Trappist Beer."
The privately owned St. Bernardus brewery once contract-brewed beer for the Trappist Monastery St. Sixtus (brewers of the Westvleteren beers), but their beers can't be called "Trappistenbier" nor are they "made from" Trappist beer.
One could say that they are made "like" the Trappists beers- thus the term "abbey beers".
http://www.sintbernardus.be/en/histor...
(Rough translation, but one gets the idea...)
-
-
-
-
re: The Chemist
I've been lucky enough to visit Belgium a number of times and have tried beers by all seven of the authentic Trappist breweries. Of course it's all a matter of taste, but my favorite among them (and favorite beer on earth) is the Westvleteren 8. I preferred it to the 12, which itself is a wonderful beer. The 8 is just out of this world. If I could only drink one beer for the rest of my life this would be it, and I'd never tire of it.
Among the rest of the Trappist beers I enjoyed the Rochefort offerings next best, then Chimay, Westmalle, Orval, Koningshoeven (brewed in the Netherlands) and finally Achel.
-
-
-
re: negronilover
Well, it's not like asking someone what their very favorite beer, in any style and of any origin, is. To be honest, I think some of the Trappist beers are overrated anyway. Take Westvleteren, which people seem to hold in ridiculously high regard, no doubt in large part because it's so rare outside of Belgium. If you could walk into your local liquor store and pick one up on any given day, would anyone really think it was so much better than Westmalle, Rochefort, or Achel? Also, as much as I like Chimay Grande Reserve, I think a lot of people call it their favorite because it's so widely available, and they haven't had a chance to try something comparable, like Rochefort 10.
Having said all that, I don't have a favorite Trappist brewery, so much as I have favorites among each of the styles produced by these breweries (dubbel, tripel, quad/cat. S). Additionally, I have a favorite overall beer amongst all my faves in their respective styles, so I think it's a pretty relevant question, with answers that will undoubtedly lead some people to find new and exciting brews they would not otherwise have tried.
-
-
-
i've only had a few trappists (chimay - blue is favorite, westmalle dubbel, rochefort 6 and orval - disliked orval, phewy blechk bandaids) but for my unsophisticated palate and for the money/ease of access, i think that there are many american microbrewers who 'copy' the style well enough to make them frontrunners.
›5 Replies-
-
re: Josh
thanks...alas, they don't distribute to FL (i just checked their website)
however, i have been able to try ommengang, allagash, north coast (love pranqster, haven't tried brother thelonius yet) flying fish dubbel (can't find that in FL anymore though) victory (had that in NC, not in FL) and i've liked everything i've tried as much as or more than those few actual trappist ales i had ;)
-
-
re: Josh
Allagash does an excellent job creating very authentic Belgian-styles ales. Their Tripel Reserve is incredible, blowing away many of the Trappist tripels, IMHO. Four is also awesome, and I eagerly await the day they finally bottle the barrel-aged version of said beer (aged in Beam barrels, I believe).
-
-
-
-
-
-
Ah, my favorite clergymen, the Trappists. Thank heavens the Irish monks didn't brew beer or we would have had trouble on our hands, way back when.
Is Corsendonk a Trappist beer? It's one of the best I've ever tasted, and the little Belgian bistro around the corner from my office stocks it, along with several others (Petite Abeille, in New York, if you're interested)
Keeping the faith..
- Sean
›2 Replies-
re: Sean Dell
Corsendonk is a good Belgian beer but there are only 6 Belgian Trappist breweries, making these beers:
Westvleteren
Chimay
Orval
Achel
Rochefort
Westmalle
There's also a Dutch Trappist brewery, Koningshoeven, which doesn't seem to be in the same league, but I have never tried their beers.
There are lots of great Belgian (and non-Belgian) breweries making abbey style ales, similar to many of the Trappist brews. -
re: Sean Dell
As kenito said, Corsendonk is not a Trappist beer, but it is a phenomenal bargain as far as Belgian abbey ales go. Their Abbey Brown Ale (sometimes also labeled, simply, Pater) is a favorite of mine, but the Abbey Pale Ale (aka: Agnus) is also a decent brew. I absolutely love their Christmas Ale. It's big, dark, malty sweet, and complex.
-
-
-
I've tried several of the Trappist ales, and by far my favorite is Achel Extra. All of the Achel brews are excellent, but the Extra is hugely malty and delicious, going down ever so easily. Of course, I think there are better beers out there, either from independent breweries or from non-Trappist abbeys, that don't get the respect they deserve because they're not made by Trappist monks.
-
-
While I am very fond of far too many begian beers, there are a number of trappist style beers out of Quebec such as Fin du Monde, Raftman and a number of others from Unibroue in Montreal. There used to be a place on Bleeker in the west village run by a greek guy named Hercules (I shit you not) that had a great selection of everything. I've heard that he has moved down to Tribeca.
There is also New Belgium out of Fort Collins CO that makes a nobel effort.
›1 Reply -
-
-
I go with Westvletern 12. BTW if you really, desperately MUST try this beer, it is available through belgianshop.com.
My favorite available Trappist is the Rochefort 8.
Did a blind tasting of all the Trappist beers at a cafe in Amsterdam about a year ago. They were matched up roughly by type, (The 6s and Chimay Rouge the 8s the Tripels and the 10/12s.) Before we started, everyone agreed that Westvleteren 12 was our favorite. While the Rochefort 10, Westvletern 12, Achel Extra and LaTrappe Quad were on the table, we all blindly picked the LaTrappe as the best. After, the tasting, the pub owner admitted that the Quad was 2 years old, everything else was a year old but the Westvleteren 12 was picked up from the Abbey that week.
By type (Orval doesn't categorize and you could pick it out blind easily) we liked:
Westvletern Blond
Rochefort 8
Westmalle Tripel
LaTrappe Quad›1 Reply -
I bought a bottle of Rochefort 8, but maybe I need to buy a bottle of the 10 and try them both.
Do you suggest drinking these alone or what are some good things to snack on w/ these beers?
›4 Replies-
-
-
-
re: JugglerDave
The Chimay cheese is good, but really any good flavorful cheese works. I like stuff like Red Dragon (an English cheese with mustard seeds in it), aged Gouda, dry Jack, aged Cheddar. Anything rich and flavorful is great with those kinds of beers.
I'd stay away from milder cheeses - they can't really stand up to the beer.
-
-
-
-
Hop Devil Grill, perhaps? Decent place.
The best, and cheapest, way to get yourself acquainted with Belgium's offerings, though, would be to stop by New Beer Distributors on Christie and bring home a selection.
I've only found Westvleteren in two locations. The first was the Vienna Whole Foods (in Virginia), where chowhounds pointed me towards a gentleman familiar to us here on the Beer board. The other score was at New Beer Distributors.
I'll reiterate my previous comment that St. Bernardus is a worthy purchase, whether or not the true Trappist ales are available.
›2 Replies-
-
re: big o
Another place for Belgian beers at great prices is American Beer on Court St and Butler in Cobble Hill. They have a great selection and you'll probably end up buying alot of other things while you're there, which is good and bad.
And Rochefort 10 is a multi-course meal in itself.
And Hop Devil does have a good trappist selection.
-
-
-
re: Jill
I have been to Hop Devil Grill, St Marks at Ave A, which has a connected "Belgian Room" with only Belgian and Ommegang offerings. I was drinking lambics so I didnt check for trappist but they have a nice large selection of bottles. The other side of the bar has a ton of IPAs and stuff on tap. The frites are good, too.
http://www.hopdevil.com/Vol De Nuit (148 W 4th) is a Belgian beer bar. Have not been.
http://www.voldenuitbar.com/main1.htmlThe other fantastic Belgian selection is found in Williamsburg at Spuyten Duyvil, Metropolitan and Havemeyer. You could call and see what trappist they have at the moment.
http://www.spuytenduyvilnyc.com/
-
-
Rochefort 10 is the best i have tried, but i have missed out on the Westvleren beers. I need to try those as well.
Chimay Blue label is a good beer that is easier to find.
›24 Replies-
-
re: Jim Dorsch
When we were in belgium, we read/heard that it's hard to find because
1) unlike other abbeys, Westvletren only makes enough to support the order, rather than essentially selling as much as they can
2) In order to get the beer, everyone (individuals, cafe owners, stores) need to call the phone number to find out when and which beers are available, queue in their cars at the abbey, and there is a limit of 10 cases per car or truck. No official distributor system or similar, though I would assume that there is some informal distribution from those who go and get 10 cases and sell to others.
-
re: JugglerDave
What you say is basically the case (although I believe the case limit is less now). However, before the proclamation I mentioned, you could buy bottles in the US for maybe $10-11 each. After the proclamation, the small amount typically available was immediately snapped up, and I've never seen it again in the US.
-
-
-
re: brentk
It might have been. She's not from Columbus but I think she was there, but i think it might have been in Cleveland? I'll have to ask.
That being said, the gf will be in columbus soon, any chance you'll reveal your source? :)
Edit: Yes, it was in columbus. In case you did want to try to obfuscate the location, the initials were FTV.
-
-
-
-
re: jgg13
I am guilty of replying to an old thread, I know but I am a bit surprised that no one called BS on your "obfuscation" of the source for Westvleteren in Columbus, OH. I know you want to protect your sources but please.
Stock up on your bottles and share the source with those of us who might also enjoy one or two for ourselves.
The store name jgg13 and brentk were mincing around is "From The Vine"
-
-
-
-
-
re: jgg13
Do you think they were a few years old? I can't recall if they have dates on the bottles, but I suspect they do. Just wondering if any product is getting into the US at all, outside of someone's suitcase.
There was a big discussion a while back on beer advocate about whether it's ethical to buy this product in the US, given that the brothers don't authorize it for export to our country.
-
re: Jim Dorsch
Will have to ask her (again) about the dates, although reading about the place on BA makes it seem like they have a steady stream of product.
Speaking of BA, as for your second paragraph, I'd argue that anyone who really cares about that needs to get a life. You buy it, it is yours to do with what you want, which would include bringing it somewhere else and reselling it.
-
-
re: Jim Dorsch
I'd guess that properly cellared that the expiration date would be quite a bit in the future. Normally when I've seen those things have expiration dates they're upwards on 10 years in the future.
"There certainly are a few folks on BA that meet your description"
Now that's something I've realized for years now :) I like what they try to do but BA as an organization (including posters and such) don't do a whole lot to contest my belief that modern beer snobs are far snobbier folks than snobs of most other things out there :)
-
-
-
-
-
-
re: Jim Dorsch
"Grey market" Westvleteren (well, even that isn't techincally correct- it's perfectly legal in the US, with TTB approved labels, etc., simply bought by the importer through a secondary source rather than directly from the Abbey) has been available off and on for the past decade or so- brought in by 3 different imports (B. United, D&V and "World of Wines") and those bottles are easily identified by simply *having* a label, which also has the US required "Gov't Warning" and the name of one of those importers.
I don't recall the prices of the bottles when they were "new" (I sort of remember them being even cheaper than Jim mentions) but I've seen them, now 4-5 years old, still on the shelves recently for $15-20.
A "hand carried" or a true "grey market" bottle would be label-less, I would guess.
A copy of the label that's been used in the US can be found here-
http://www.beerlabels.com/labels/labe...-
-
-
-
-
-
-
re: brentk
Besides the link to the Westvleteren bottle photo in my post above, one can see a copy of the US TTB approved label, along with a brief explanation here-
http://www.whitebeertravels.co.uk/sixtus.html
http://www.whitebeertravels.co.uk/images/sixtus_label_us.jpgIn addition, a search of the TTB site https://www.ttbonline.gov/colasonline...
will turn up the actual applications and labels. Search for both "Westvleteren" and "TRAPPISTENBIER" but, note, that that website 's seaches can be squirrelly and will turn up items one time and not another.I'd expect that most bottles one finds on the shelf in retail shops for off premises consumption are going to be the labeled versions. Unlabeled bottles,( i.e.- "hand carried" "self imported" "grey market" whatever term you wanna use) are probably going to be "behind the counter/bar", available only on request >wink, wink<.
By saying the unlabeled bottles are "illegal" I'm not saying that I think the states' ABC's have busted (or should bust) "grey market" Westvleteren sellers (tho' it's not unheard of for the competition to turn folks in for "bootlegging" beers across statelines).
OTOH, stranger things have happened in the current atmosphere. Wasn't there a story soon after the Patriot Act was passed where the FBI was hassling some little novelty shop owner in the PNW for selling "illegal" versions of the Rubic Cube?
-
re: JessKidden
Yeah- a lot of the one's I have seen have had that label. I also recall the "Saint Sixtus" label of maybe 15 or so years ago:
http://www.gyzzj.com/microbrews.html
(scroll down)- but I'm guessing that those were brewed at Saint Bernardus back then and may not have been the same exact beer.
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
I vote for Rochefort 10. The complexity is astounding.
The more forward brettanomyces character of Orval is somewhat of an acquired taste...but goes well with blue cheese & crusty french bread.
›2 Replies-
re: liegey
Agree with Rochfort 10 as the best beer I have ever had, Orval interesting and great but an acquired taste.
This weekend I tried Achel Brown and found it to be the perfect expression of the style, malty, complex, but with a tart backbone that kept it refreshing. So expensive though...can't indulge too often...($7 for 11 oz!)
-
-
The Bride & I had the good fortune to be in Belgium last September. The Westvleteren 12 was found and tried twice in a restaurant, around 5 EURO. It was stunningly fantastic. Westy 8 was good but didn't have the depth.
Rochefort 8 was The Bride's favorite overall, out of 44 beers sampled during the trip. I like Rochefort 10 a little better.
Orval was OK but not great.
I liked Maredsous 8 & 10 better... But then, that was on draft, served in ceramic mugs, and eaten at their outside courtyard.
-
By far, Westvleteren, but good luck finding it - and if you do, consider taking out a loan for a case. Westy 12 was out of this world, yet the memory of the blonde always seems to sneak its way into my head.
Achel is pretty good, I love Orval, Chimay's are always reliable, I'm not a fan of the Rochefort beers, and I love the dubbel from La Trappe but the quad is the most popular.
-
-
-
-
re: kenito799
I like the Chimay Grand Reserve best, and you are right it is subjective, it is in the taster of the beholder, so to speak. Allagash Brewing Company of Portland, ME makes a very decent trappist like brew. Check it out at this site:
-
-
-
-
-
















