HOME > Chowhound > San Francisco Bay Area >
What have you made lately? Tell us about it

NY Pie in Santa Rosa

Melanie Wong Aug 19, 2006 02:04 AM

Has it really been 3 years since I last had a pie here? With all the talk about New York pizza, I dropped in to NY Pie on Fourth and Brookwood on Monday night. I was happy to see that Jeff was manning the oven, as he made the first taste I'd had here and has fired the best examples I've had from this pizzeria. I ordered my favorite, the Neopolitan, which has sliced tomatoes, garlic and basil, and asked for it "charred".

The crust is still very good, and the sauce was more vegetable/tomato-like and less sweet than the last outing. Beautiful whole basil leaves, at least one and sometimes two per slice, and just the right amount of garlic to know its there but not hit you over the head (or repeat all night). I was sorry I forgot to ask for the slosh of olive oil before it's baked, as that would have been the icing on the cake so to speak. The crust wasn't quite as charred on the bottom as I would have liked and the middle of pie got soggy from the fresh tomatoes. And even though it looks more substantial in the photo, the crust is less than 1/8" and has that NY gluten-y chew. But all in all, a very good pie and enjoyed even more for breakfast the next day. The "Arnold Palmer" ice tea and homemade lemonade was very refreshing and is a bargain at $1.25 with refills.

A second location opened at 2700 Yulupa Ave in the Annadel Center. I tried it a while back and wasn't as happy with the pizza execution there, so I'm happy to know that at least the original is still in fine shape. NY Pie now delivers from that location, Thursday through Sunday after 5pm. Maybe the kinks have been worked out and it's on track by now. I also had the side salad with homemade blue cheese dressing that time, and recommend that.

Image of small Neopolitan, 12", $14.95 -

My prior slice of NY Pie -

  1. t
    Tom Hall Aug 20, 2006 10:58 PM

    I remain happy with their pizzas at the original location and now they have Redhook ESB on tap which goes well with the pizza especially after a morning of wine tasting.

    1. c
      ciaogina Aug 20, 2006 11:18 PM

      I've been several times since that journey 3 years ago as friends now live in the area. I find it to be consistent and the service friendly.

      2 Replies
      1. re: ciaogina
        Melanie Wong Aug 21, 2006 06:25 AM

        Cool! I'll mention that I slid in the door around 8:25pm and asked if they were still open and if so, could I eat my pizza there. The countergirl didn't miss a beat in asking me to take a seat. Then I noticed that the posted closing time is 8:30pm, so I was even more appreciative that they let me stay.

        Have either of you tried the lunch time subs?

        1. re: Melanie Wong
          Tom Hall Aug 21, 2006 04:22 PM

          The owner sampled 4 of us a sub- meatball, IIRC and it was very good... but not enough for me to have it in place of the pizza.

      Show Hidden Posts