HOME > Chowhound > Greater Boston Area >
What have you made lately? Share your food adventure
TELL US

the butcher shop? Anything good to say?

a
AmandaRG Aug 10, 2006 08:38 PM

Hi, I have reservations at the butcher shop for restaurant week because I used to hear great things about it. From the postings I've read so far on the board, it sounds like its better days are behind it. Does anyone recomend it? I'm thinking about weather i should change my reservation to somewhere else as I don't get to eat out too often and was looking forward to a nice dinner.

thanks

  1. d
    DoubleMan Aug 10, 2006 08:53 PM

    I like the food a lot. The biggest problems I've found have to do with the long waits and high prices---neither of which should be an issue for you during RW.

    I've never been, but the board view of B&G Oysters seems more favorable than for the Butcher Shop.

    1. lissy Aug 10, 2006 09:15 PM

      I really like the food at the Butcher Shop. Their steak tartare is my favorite of all the versions that I've had. They change their menu pretty regularly and I do enjoy the food there. I think one of the biggest complaints is that the prices have been pretty steep for what you get which also shouldn't be a problem during restaurant week. All that being said, I also love B&G Oysters...

      1. Joanie Aug 11, 2006 12:46 PM

        Rest. Week is definitely the time to try the Butcher Shop when the prices are more reasonable. Then decide if you think it's worth another (more expensive) trip.

        1. l
          lvtotry Aug 11, 2006 12:59 PM

          The best thing about the butcher shop is that you can stand around the butcher block and drink wine and have some cheese, it makes for a nice way to start out a night or just have a nice early one.

          1. Ernie Diamond Aug 11, 2006 03:30 PM

            Meh. I think that it's well past it's glory days. I suspect that you might be able to find better meals and more rewarding experiences in Boston.

            Based on the prevailing attitude there during regular service, I have a hard time thinking RW is going to be leagues better. HOWEVER, if this is your first shot at the Butcher Shop and you're getting a good price, then I'm eager to read your review. Who knows? Maybe they'll work extra hard that week to turn it around...

            1. MC Slim JB Aug 11, 2006 07:45 PM

              I liked the initial concept of small plates, and hated the next, longstanding iteration, of traditional apps and entrees, which I found ridiculously overpriced. I have been meaning to give it another try lately, as I understand the small plates are back.

              1. Angel Food Aug 11, 2006 07:51 PM

                I had a disappointing RW experience at B&G. Based on that, I would consider somewhere else for RW. I know it's a bargain price, but I've tried a number of places for RW and B&G was the biggest disappointment. Portions could be described as "precious". See what's on the menu and if it grabs you, but don't expect to feel like you got a full meal for your $30.

                Show Hidden Posts