HOME > Chowhound > Manhattan >
What are you cooking today? Tell us about it
TELL US

Help me make her birthday dinner memorable

cello55 Aug 10, 2006 02:27 AM

I Love My Wife.
And I would like to make her birthday dinner next Wed. a memorable one.

She has a fine palate and likes really clean food.

I was thinking of something along the lines of 11Madison but I'm not sure about the idea of a pre-fix menu.

Then I thought about Spice Market downtown but was there once and would like someplace a little more intimate.

Is Danny Meyers place at MOMA an excellent choice?

Any recommendations of your favorite, special place are greatly appreciated.

Oh, and some place in Manhattan...

Cello55

  1. p
    Pan Aug 10, 2006 07:43 AM

    Don't overlook the possibility of ordering a la carte at 11 Madison Park if you want to go there and are not sure about doing a prix fixe.

    3 Replies
    1. re: Pan
      m
      meb903 Aug 10, 2006 05:23 PM

      i did not see a la carte on the online menu. do they do a la carte? thanks.

      1. re: meb903
        p
        Pan Aug 11, 2006 09:10 AM

        I haven't yet had the pleasure of trying the cuisine of Chef Humm (I went to 11 Madison Park three times under their previous chef), but according to posts on a thread on eGullet, they do indeed have a carte.

        1. re: meb903
          cello55 Aug 11, 2006 02:03 PM

          I called to inquire and in fact there is a sampling menu in the bar/lounge.

      2. foodiegrl Aug 10, 2006 01:21 PM

        The Modern is a fantastic choice. The Dining Room menu is quite elegant - their summer tasting menu in particular has very 'clean' flavors.
        http://www.themodernnyc.com/modern/me...

        Since it's a Union Square Group restaurant, you're guaranteed excellent service. Be sure to tell them it's her birthday for extra special attention.

        1 Reply
        1. re: foodiegrl
          c
          catherinejones Aug 10, 2006 09:17 PM

          i would not go to the modern for a romantic dinner. it is very formal, very stiff, and nothing about it is romantic. the food was okay. not great. and way too expensive for the quality.

          i would go to babbo.

        2. tbear Aug 10, 2006 04:32 PM

          I really think that Il Buco on Bond St. is the most romantic, intimate restaurant in NYC. Order from the long list of amazing appetizers until satiated.

          1. n
            nycexplorer Aug 10, 2006 08:19 PM

            Since your wife likes clean food, I recommend Blue Hill. The owners also have a farm upstate, which supplies most, if not all, of their fresh, seasonal ingredients.

            2 Replies
            1. re: nycexplorer
              p
              Pupster Aug 10, 2006 08:58 PM

              Actually, taking her to Blue Hill at Stone Barns would be even more special. Very romantic.

              1. re: Pupster
                b
                Blumie Aug 15, 2006 08:55 PM

                Agreed. Rent a car (go to Hertz and get one of their cars with Neverlost in it; it will direct you right to the restaurant) and take her to Blue Hill at Stone Barns. You will not be sorry.

            2. livetotravel Aug 10, 2006 09:04 PM

              "Really clean food" - sounds like a trip to Craft to me.

              4 Replies
              1. re: livetotravel
                cello55 Aug 15, 2006 06:29 PM

                So many great suggestions. Looking at Craft, what about Craftbar down on 19th and B'way?

                1. re: cello55
                  livetotravel Aug 15, 2006 06:53 PM

                  well, get other opinions for sure, but to me Craftbar was all about the bar and not about the craft ;-)

                  1. re: cello55
                    l
                    Lucia Aug 15, 2006 08:50 PM

                    Food at Craftbar is pretty good, but not good enough to make me want to return.

                    1. re: Lucia
                      t
                      Treece Aug 18, 2006 04:29 PM

                      The new Craftbar is not romantic. What about Blue Hill?

                2. cello55 Aug 16, 2006 09:38 PM

                  K, it's getting down to the wire.

                  I remember she mentioned Union Sq. Cafe once as a place she's liked. I've never been.

                  The idea of a destination rest. like Blue Hill is stirring the imagination. Combined with a nice Sunday afternoon drive. Hmmm.

                  3 Replies
                  1. re: cello55
                    r
                    RGR Aug 18, 2006 03:40 PM

                    I'm not a USC fan. Having had one truly disappointing meal there, we've never felt inclined to return.

                    I think you should definitely re-visit your initial consideration of Eleven Madison Park. I'm not sure why you would eliminate it just because the menus are prix-fixes. Definitely opt for the tasting menus. The portions are properly sized and with the addition of the many extra "gifts from the chef," you will leave pleasantly sated but not stuffed. Chef Humm's French-inspired cuisine is sensational, service is outstanding, and the space is gorgeous. To me, it's a perfect place to celebrate a special occasion.

                    I have not yet been to Blue Hill at Stone Barns. Considering the raves it receive, if you can get a reservation there, of course, it's a great option. If not, EMP is hardly a poor substitution. (Mmmm... Looking back again at your original post, I see you were thinking of an intimate place. Granted, EMP's space is not that. But I've always felt that the way the space is partitioned helps to make for more intimate feel.)

                    Wherever you ultimately end up going, Happy Birthday to your wife and Bon Appetit!

                    1. re: RGR
                      p
                      Pupster Aug 18, 2006 04:30 PM

                      Kykuit, the Rockefeller estate, is close to BH@SB; together it's a fantastic day trip. Beautiful gardens on estate premises. You can't beat the time of year for lush Hudson Valley views or the prime time for harvests in the Blue Hill fields.
                      http://www.hudsonvalley.org/kykuit/index.htm
                      Menu:
                      http://www.bluehillstonebarns.com/bhs...
                      Let them know of your special occasion. Do the tasting menu. They will do a fabulous job for you.

                      1. re: RGR
                        cello55 Aug 25, 2006 04:32 PM

                        I'm with u RGR as far as the prix-fixes but I think some folks want the adventure of exploring a menu, which I can understand. Personally, I like leaving it all up to the chef.

                    2. f
                      FranklinTeany Aug 16, 2006 09:48 PM

                      I have to second Il Buco. I just had a dinner there a week ago for the special lady's birthday and it worked out like a charm. Best to go early though as they can get packed and overwhelmed, althogh this didn't happen to me last time I was there. Ask to be seated in the wine cellar.

                      Union Square Cafe has always been reliable, but not terribly romantic. Still, not a bad choice if you're looking for a good meal.

                      2 Replies
                      1. re: FranklinTeany
                        j
                        JennS Aug 18, 2006 04:29 PM

                        I'm also planning a bday dinner for my boyfriend and was thinking of Union Square Cafe...but is Blue Hill (in the city) more romantic? Last year I took him to Jack's Luxury Oyster Bar and we sat upstairs.

                        1. re: JennS
                          r
                          RGR Aug 18, 2006 05:20 PM

                          Everyone's idea of what constitutes "romantic" can differ radically.

                          I didn't find USC at all romantic. But, then, we were seated on the balcony which, I felt, was akin to being exiled to Siberia.

                          As for Blue Hill (NYC), it's a fairly small space with plain decor. In my view, nice enough but not particularly romantic. The seating along the banquettes is extremely close. What saved it for us is that we dined early and were given the table at the corner "L" of the banquette, which was more roomy. Plus, the table immediately next to ours remained vacant during our meal.

                      2. t
                        TheDagster Aug 18, 2006 05:29 PM

                        I am quite late here, but I love Annisa. Quiet, romantic tables, dim lighting. You can get dinner a la carte or do a 5 or 7 course tasting menu. The tasting menu changes daily, and they cater to your likes and dislikes. It was a fantastic, romantic meal. The food was fresh and fit together perfectly.

                        1. j
                          JennS Aug 18, 2006 05:38 PM

                          I've heard great things about Annisa and that was my first choice, but they seem to be closed the week of my boyfriend's bday. Thanks for the recommendation...maybe I'll tell him to take me there for my birthday instead. Any other ideas? We like American, seafood, French, Italian...downtown is preferable.

                          1 Reply
                          1. re: JennS
                            r
                            RGR Aug 18, 2006 06:54 PM

                            Although you say you would prefer downtown, you might want to consider L'Impero (midtown east in Tudor City), which I think is a great place to celebrate a special occasion. The food is excellent, and I'm still dreaming about the polenta and mushrooms appetizer. Seriously delicious! The interior with its soft lighting has lovely ambiance and, if the weather is conducive, the small outdoor patio is very romantic.

                            http://www.limpero.com

                          2. cello55 Aug 25, 2006 04:39 PM

                            No doubt about it, Chowhounds are the best when it comes to fine dining and romance!

                            11 Madison
                            Blue Hill at Stone Barns
                            Il Buco
                            Craft
                            babbo
                            L'lmpero
                            Annisa
                            USC
                            MOMA

                            This list will keep the fine dining and the romance going for a long time.

                            Thanks to everyone!

                            I'll leave you in suspence as to where we dined.

                            2 Replies
                            1. re: cello55
                              r
                              RGR Aug 25, 2006 06:12 PM

                              Hey, cello55, Don't you think you're being a little unfair? After all, you came to pick our brains, we gave you our best ideas, and now you're not going to give us the courtesy of telling us where you decided to go and how it turned out?! If you don't want to provide a blow-by-blow of the meal -- though that would be nice -- at least, give us the name. :-)

                              1. re: RGR
                                cello55 Sep 13, 2006 04:22 PM

                                ok,ok your right.
                                The truth is I didn't want to disappoint.

                                My beloved had been working like crazy (Grant Writer) and after making and canceling plans for 11 Mad, Il Buco, Union Sq. we just stayed local and went to La Lunchenette over on 10th ave.

                                I have a sentimental attachement to La L. but the food was just fair and not like the old days, service was fair with 80% of the tables occupied.

                                That said I hope this great thread will help bring other romantics more success!

                            2. designerboy01 Aug 27, 2006 08:19 AM

                              Aquavit
                              Town
                              Lever House
                              Harry Cipriani

                              These places aren't as loud and more refined.

                              Show Hidden Posts