Psst... We're working on the next generation of Chowhound! View >
HOME > Chowhound > Home Cooking >
Jul 28, 2006 09:46 PM

Ice Creme or sorbet without an ice creme maker?

Is it possible to make decent ice creme or sorbets without an ice creme maker? If so, anybody have any simple recipes or methods to share?

I was especially interested in lavender flavoured ice creme and a watermelon sorbet.



  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
  1. You don't need any different kind of recipe, just a good method. The other night on the Food Channel they made ice cream by putting the ingredients in a ziplock bag, then putting a bunch of ice in a garbage bag and throwing it back and forth. They also tried those balls you roll around on the floor with ice cream in them.
    Granitas are traditionally made by just scraping a frozen pan of ingredients. A watermelon granita would probably be a good place to start, just google some recipes.

    1. I've been making and enjoying a lot of ice cream this summer. I see Chowpatty has already described some methods. But an electric churn makes the whole thing sooooo much easier.

      Is there a reason you don't want to get one? They're cheap now. As little as $50 for one of the coolant in the sealed bowl type. If space is an issue and you have a KitchenAid you can get such a bowl adapted for the stand mixer and only have a single bowl to store.

      Then I can give you recipes if you like. I have a good number that I heartily endorse. But the best things we've had this summer is fresh very ripe fruit mashed to a rough puree with cream. We sweeten this to just a tad sweet and freeze. The sugar is important for the texture of the ice cream as well as flavor. And the reason to go a little on the sweet side is that freezing will dull the flavors so you want to compensate a little. Other things can be added - an extract, a splash of limoncello, Grand Marnier or whatever sounds good. And things like nuts or chips can be folded in when you pack the churned cream into an airtight freezer container to cure for several hours or overnight.

      You'll be so glad you made it yourself.

      1. Hi rainey!

        I didn't want to buy one because of space. I live in a teeny tiny little Manhattan studio.

        Is there a small-sized, space saving one you can recommend? That's also easy to use? I don't have a Kitechen Aid processor. I just have a blender.

        Would you say it's more or less expensive to make your own ice creme versus buying it at the grocery store?



        1. Nigella Lawson describes a labor intensive method of making ice cream by taking the custard or whatever out of the freezer every so often and beating it like crazy to break up the ice crystals and to incorporate air into the mixture. I've never tried this, but I'm assuming it works ok. I have a small Krups ice cream maker that I bought when I lived in a small apartment with what seemed like a miniscule kitchen and it was pretty inexpensive (under $80). I eat a lot of ice cream, and I can't really make enough to keep up with my habit, so I make some and buy some. I don't know that it's much cheaper to make your own -- the ingredients can be pricey depending on what you are making and it does take a small amount of effort, but the purity, flavor, and variety of what you can make just makes it worth it.

          1 Reply
          1. re: grubn

            I forgot to say, the reason I bought the Krups is because I basically can store the bowl in the freezer. That only leaves the blade (it's flat, so doesn't take up any room really in a drawer) and the small motor, which is only about 5 inches wide.

          2. I bought a Deni with an extra bowl, I think I paid under $40 for the lot. It's not a lot of space, I think the unit is about 15" high and 6 - 8" across. It will simplify your ice cream making considerably.

            No, home made ice cream is not cheaper than most store bought. It's comparable with the ultra premium brands - Haagen Dazs, Ben & Jerry's. But IMO the flavors are far superior. I don't like the sweetness of most commercial ice creams, even the boutique versions, so I can reduce the amount of sugar to suit my taste. That's just one example, I put a lot more fruit into my mixes because I want an intensely fruity flavor. And so on and so on.