HOME > Chowhound > General Tristate Archive >
What are you cooking today? Share your food adventure
TELL US

NJ Hotdogging

n
nickdanger Jul 25, 2006 05:43 PM

Looking for recs, other than Rutt's, in northern NJ/Ft. Lee area.

  1. The Engineer Jul 25, 2006 08:01 PM

    Try Dickie Dee's on Bloomfield Ave in Newark, then down the street is JJ's hot dog truck. The dogs at the truck are terrible by the way. There's Jimmy Buff's on 22 West in Mountainside, then further west in Greenbrook or North Plainfield you have Texas Weiners.

    I can't really recommend any of these places, I've sworn off the stuff for a while, but go see for yourself. Actually the central Jersey Routes 22/28 corridor has more dog opportunities than any other place I've been outside of a ballpark.

    1. Striver Jul 25, 2006 08:10 PM

      Had a good dog at Amazing Hot Dogs in Verona, on Bloomfield just west of 23. It's a large beef dog (short and fat but hefty) in a snappy natural casing with a lot of toppings available. The flavor was excellent.

      Their signature dog is wrapped with a strip of bacon, but I didn't find that it added much, and their cole slaw is the creamy style (not my favorite kind). The home-made limeade and the fries were both good.

      Here's their website: http://amazinghotdog.com

      1 Reply
      1. re: Striver
        The Engineer Jul 25, 2006 08:23 PM

        Sounds like Bloomfield Ave is a contender for another dog corridor.

      2. menton1 Jul 25, 2006 11:59 PM

        Galloping Hill at 5 points in Union, and Charlie's italian hot dog in Kenilworth are pretty memorable. Bergen County is a hot dog wasteland.

        1 Reply
        1. re: menton1
          michele cindy Jul 26, 2006 11:41 AM

          You can do a "hotdog triangle"! Start at Galloping Hill, drive up the road to Charlie's for an Italian Hot Dog, continue on to Maplewood, NJ and get a dog at Syd's. If I remember correctly neither of these places serve the same brand of dog. Where's John Fox when you need him!

        2. p
          piccola Jul 26, 2006 01:17 AM

          I think the Star Ledger's Munchmobile did hotdogs recently...

          1. h
            hotdoglover Jul 26, 2006 11:39 PM

            I'm John Fox, but my new screen name since they changed the format is hotdoglover. I am on the Munchmobile S.W.A.T. Dog Team. We have been going to various hot dog establishments all over the state. We are at 59 and counting. Most I've already been to, but there are a few that I've been to for the first time. I heartily recommend Syd's, which is located in the Millburn Mall on Vauxhall Rd. in Union. They use a 5 to a lb natural casing Best Provision dog that they charbroil. Expensive, but as good a hot dog as you'll find anywhere.

            Galloping Hill Inn is a different type of dog; German style beef and pork. They use a dog from Grote & Weigel of Conn. that is the same recipe as the dogs that the old owners use to use from Gaiser's deli. When Gaisers was sold, the dogs weren't the same. A great beef and pork dog; milder than Syd's with a more subtle spicing. Prepared on a griddle, which I prefer to deep frying.

            Elizabeth is home to two great hot dog joints that are next to each other. Jerry's and Tommy's. Tommy's serves a first rate Italian Hot Dog and sausage sandwich. Jerry's serves a natural casing (8 to a lb) Best Provisions dog. It is boiled first, then grilled for extra crunchiness. Along with Syd's and Boulevard Drinks in Jersey City (small natural casing Sabrett), they are my favorite all beef dogs. Amazing Hot Dog in Verona is also one of the better ones. Not grilled, but flash fried. A delicious dog with a wide variety of toppings. I think their chili may be the best hot dog chili I've tried.

            For Texas Weiners in North Jersey, I like Libby's, The Hot Grill, and Pappy's Diner in Totowa. Deep fried Thumann's left in the oil long enough, and topped with flavorful chili sauce.

            JJ's has gone downhill in my opinion. Smaller now and skinless, when before they were natural casing. I've found that many of the trucks use tiny 12 to a lb dogs. Almost a cocktail frank. I like Tony's in Branch Brook Park. Good dog (a less spicy Golden D brand) but bigger than JJ's. Natural casing and tasty chili. They also have good hot onions I'm told. I don't eat onions.

            Hirams in Fort Lee makes a very good deep fried dog, but ask for it well done. Though not considered a Texas Weiner joint, they serve a fine slightly spicy chili that was one of the favorites of the S.W.A.T. Dog Team.

            There are so many great places in Jersey to get a dog. I suggest you read the weekly S.W.A.T. reports in the archives of this year's Munchmobile series on nj.com. Due to space limitations, all of our comments about each place cannot be included. But at the end of the summer, I will give an in depth summary of each place if anyone cares. Also check out the Hot Dog Section on http://www.roadfood.com. The thread on Jersey Hot Dogs is quite extensive. Also, feel free to e-mail me with any questions or if you need directions.

            1 Reply
            1. re: hotdoglover
              h
              Hugh DeMann Aug 26, 2006 05:26 PM

              One of the best - if not the best - hot dog stands is Hot Dog Johnnie's in Buttzville NJ. Pretty place with river view, and great hot dogs with amazing buttermilk.
              We drive 30 minutes out of our way to the Poconos and it's worth it.

            2. d
              dwalker0229 Mar 20, 2007 11:47 AM

              The Salad Bowl has an awesome hot onion dog. It is on Belleville Ave. in Bloomfield. Make sure to bring a tongue scraper, them some hot dogs.

              1. jpr54_1 Mar 23, 2007 01:45 PM

                there is also papaya king in clifton, nj-
                in corrado's complex in back

                1 Reply
                1. re: jpr54_1
                  tuxedo Mar 26, 2007 12:01 PM

                  Is the papaya king in clifton related to the one in NY I keep hearing about???

                2. c
                  chowsue Mar 24, 2007 04:18 AM

                  I tried Rutt's for the first time this week. I hated it. Why is this considered the best hot dog in NJ? It had no flavor. Expensive (I love the dollar dog at papaya in manhattan!) Rutt's was barely cooked. Bland. Blah.

                  I tried Hot Dog House on Route 17 yesterday and it was ok. Nothing worth driving to. It was a boring skinny Sabrett hot dog in a plain bun. They did have quite a few interesting options and toppings..the menu was quite long. Took me forever to decide.
                  They had Home on the Ranch fries- bacon bits, ranch dressing, 5 cheese. Interesting but pretty yuck.

                  I'll stick to the shore weinies, thank you.

                  Show Hidden Posts