HOME > Chowhound > General Tristate Archive >
What are you cooking today? Tell us about it
TELL US

poughkeepsie and other area place (long)

b
bob gaj Jul 15, 2006 06:12 PM

in the past couple months, i've gone to a ton of poughkeepsie area places. some solo, some with friends. ambience means far less to me than quality of food. apologies if i over-use a word, or dont give quite enough details.

couple things i noticed:

> many places are now using more fancy nouveaux plates, that aren't the standard round ones, but square shaped or flat.
> virtually all the places below were much more affordable than i'd have guessed (high teens - low 20s on meals). the french places tended to be slightly pricier than the others, but the quality of food for the price was universally impressive. is that because of the cia influx? i don't know, but i'll take it.
> the places would mention when they were using local foods. good!
> i'd go back to all of these again except where noted.

now, on with the feedback!

french: la batisse (poughkeepsie). went once before, was unimpressed. went back with a couple friends, still remain unimpressed. there's nothing bad about it - just nothing that knocks my socks off and makes me say "wow!".
le pavillion (poughkeepsie). nice flavored foods; small filling portions, but that was fine. presentation was elegant (didn't matter to me, but i have to mention it),the lobster bisque was creamy and tasty (no chunks of seafood, but a more traditional recipe), rabbit was properlycooked, vegetables and sauce were tasty. (lepavillonrestaurant.com)

poughkeepsie: 96 main. voted best ahi tuna tacos in the area...i thought they were quite good, but not as good as umami's. the steak was good, but again, not great. i just realized why this comes off as slightly disappointing: the presentation for the dishes gives the impression that these will be super duper great. if you put them on a regular plate with nothing special, this commentary would sound better.
their speciality is supposed to be the homemade pizzas, which i'll have to try at some point. although they claim to have a website on their signs, that listed site doesn't exist. (parked by a domain stealer).

poughkeepsie: haymaker. yum! yum yum! i wrote down everything eaten and i can't remember, since it was almost the first place to go to. that won't help anyone...sorry. but the food exceeded my expectations. they have just switched over to a new summer menu, so checking out the website won't give an exact menu. i just remembered part of it; a steak with polenta, spinach, and muscat grapes. and some sauce that there's no way i'll remember. all flavors worked perfectly with each other. and carolyn (bennett's mom; bennett is the chef, he and his mom are co-owners) comes over to make sure everything's ok. neat! (thehaymaker.com)

poughkeepsie: maia. underwhelmed. nice presentation, but the food wasn't a knockout. wonton appetizer? took time to prepare, but didn't hit. and the salmon dish - well, just slightly better than made at home. it was adequate, but felt like a disappointment compared to the other places mentioned.

poughkeepsie: main st. i've gone back to los compadres and la cabanita a couple times, and both are real good for what they are (inexpensive mexican places with abuelita cooking in the kitchen). el gallito (693 main st) is a small shop whose speciality is chicken with peruvian? flavoring. they have a bunch of chickens cooking, turning in the rotisserie, when you walk in.
there's also a few caribbean places popping up; janet's jerk relocated, but there are new west indies type shops over near college park (roughly clinton and oakley) and one i think on bement and harrison?

hyde park - twist. i went for a lunch, and just had the burger and fries. don't get the salt on the fries; they already have a cayenne pepper on them! (i almost asked, and tried one first). angus burger was cooked perfect to my liking, and was large. i overheard people talking about the dinner menu being very good, and it is at least family tolerable, so that's good. (www.letstwist.com

)

millbrook - la puerta azul. just got their liquor license a couple weeks ago, so some of the alcohol choices aren't available. empanaditas were small for the price, but tasty. the pork and grouper dishes both were hits, will definitely go back. also, although it's millbrook, it's about 1 mile east of the taconic on route 44. (la-puerta-azul.com)

rhinebeck - terrapin. just for lunch, i've been told dinner is much better. had the quesadilla with mango on top and (i think?) prosciutto and cheeses inside. flavorful, no complaints.

saugerties - new world home cooking. you can find what everyone else says about this place, i second the positive recos. the blackened string beans with remoulade sauce weren't as hot as i was led to believe, but definitely needed some water with them. a local steak was cooked perfectly, the veggies were yummy...and a good mojito as well! just too far away for me to go unless i have an excuse to be up there. (www.newworldhomecooking.com

)

other stuff, some new and some old:

the inn at osborne hill (wappingers? fishkill?) is no longer and is now the brass monkey bistro.
swagat on route 9 has changed names, but is still indian (and also 'pakistani') food.
the hobnobbin pub (north) on route 9 is worse than the hobnobbin pub (corner of route 376).
does adams (poughkeepsie) get their fish from gadaleto's? i saw a large order behind their counter, with gadaleto's name written on it.
arby's new chicken sandwich is much tastier than a fast food chicken should be. i know it seems out of place here...

the rhinebeck farmers market on sundays looks far better than the similar ones in pleasant valley, poughkeepsie, and (unfortunately) most prominently, millbrook. it's all targetted to a much more upscale crowd than any of those places.

there were about 30 vendors there along with a musician. vendors included swoon kitchenbar (from hudson), quattro's meats (pleasant valley), the area's "top mozzarella and upscale foods", and all sorts of jellies, meats, oddball foods and more. not a ton of the fresh fruits and veggies, but it's unique enough that i'll go back.

  1. MisterBill2 Sep 12, 2006 03:04 AM

    So we are meeting friends from Millbrook up in that direction this weekend (we live in Yorktown, we typically eat at the CIA when we meet them). I have been wanting to eat at Twist for a while, and that is our plan. But I wonder if I wouldn't have an even better (and somewhat more convenient) meal at Haymaker. Comments?

    1 Reply
    1. re: MisterBill2
      MisterBill2 Sep 14, 2006 07:16 AM

      Made a reservation for Haymaker. When I called, they asked if it was any special occasion and if anyone had food allergies. Very impressive start. Our friends who we are meeting there said they had heard good things about it. I wanted to get to Amish Market, but I guess Adams will have to do. And our friends have some discount coupons for Stop & Shop gas to use after dinner :-).

    2. b
      B12751 Sep 5, 2006 07:00 PM

      You are being too kind to Le Pavillion. I am a Chicagoan looking for Poughkeepsie's best.

      Went there are on a Saturday night in August'06. Restaurant was not even 1/3 full at 7:00 PM! Have you ever been to a great restaurant that was not filled on a Saturday night in the summer?

      2 veggie soup was boring and bland. Table next to us didn't make it past a spoonful. Pates were OK but nothing special. Coq au vin was lackluster. Didn't wait around for the dessert

      Everything about the place looks authentic, service included, but if there is such a thing as French institutional food then this may be it.

      1. dchow Aug 21, 2006 07:50 PM

        i ate at haymaker last night with my sister, and we thought the meal was pretty good. we started with the red and golden beet salad with coach farm triple-cream cheese. the cheese was cold (i would have preferred a room-temp cheese), but the beets and micro greens were great. she had the hudson valley duck with potato-fontina croquettes. the croquettes were dense, heavy, and doughy, but the duck was perfect -- medium rare, nicely seared with a delicious layer of fat under the skin. i had the grilled marlin special with scallops, shrimp, pattypan squash, and (beet?) risotto. the marlin had a slightly fishy taste (not a good thing), and the squash was oversalted. the risotto was nice, but the magenta-dyed rice was a bit frightening. overall a nice meal with kind service.

        1. n
          NewYorkDave Aug 19, 2006 03:41 AM

          Baron, if you happen to be thinking of Aloy's (and I think you might be), check out the review I just posted. I suspect that it's a long-simmered sauce that begins with some carmelized onions... Just a guess, though.

          1. b
            barongarlic Jul 19, 2006 02:30 PM

            Poughkeepsie style pizza is unique to that area. It has a flavor that I haven't had anywhere else. I would love to get a recipe of the sauce.

            1. markp Jul 16, 2006 05:53 AM

              Thanks bob! You're greatly helped to de-mystify the "where to eat in poughkeepsie" dilemma. This is a "print and stick in glove compartment" post.

              Show Hidden Posts