HOME > Chowhound > General Topics >
Brewing beer, curing meat, or making cheese?

Jim Leff wimps out on the stinky tofu

Gary Soup Jul 13, 2006 12:08 AM

From Jennifer Bain in the Toronto Star:

I line up 15 minutes for a serving, only to discover the tofu's fermented with dried shrimp. I'm allergic — and off the hook.

But none of my four market companions will take a bite — even Jim Leff, the New York co-creator of Chowhound.com (a site "for those who love to eat").

"I can't get it within two feet of my face without feeling deeply, deeply nauseous, which shames me greatly," Leff admits.


  1. wrayb Jul 14, 2006 12:16 AM

    I have had 3 or so variations of fermented tofu. Some very firm some more silky/slimy. Don't know enough to correctly ID them, but I do know that one variety I had at a Taiwanese restaurant in Boston went beyond my limits of comfort. Pungency way beyond any runny stinky cheese I have experienced.

    As for natto, there is variation in flavors there, too. I do agree that it is more of a slim issue than pungency issue.

    And, Gary, thanks for posting that link. Good reminder of the delights to be found when I next visit Toronto.


    2 Replies
    1. re: wrayb
      Ruth Lafler Jul 14, 2006 05:39 PM

      That's okay, Jim! I feel the same way about a lot of tripe dishes. Even worse, I feel guilty when I order a dish in an ethnic restaurant that arrives reeking of tripe and I can't eat it. I feel like I've ruined the restaurant for the next gringo who comes along and will get the "gringos won't eat that" treatment. I look forward to at least trying stinky tofu, but not natto -- that slimy, mucuous appearance is just too repellant!

      1. re: Ruth Lafler
        kare_raisu Jul 15, 2006 03:43 AM

        hey! ive been on a natto handroll for breakfast kick for two weeks running now. I cant imagine my life before it...yes i love it that much./

    2. d
      dippedberry Jul 14, 2006 06:17 PM

      There is a very stinky Korean tofu stew. A variation on daengjang chigae, a stew made from fermented soy beans (like the Japanese miso). Except this daengjang is fermented way beyond stinkiness. I've only tasted it once, from food court purveyor in the top floor of a Los Angeles/Koreatown shopping center, but it was difficult to get close to the bowl. However, to my dad, this rare treat was ambrosial.

      5 Replies
      1. re: dippedberry
        Humbucker Jul 15, 2006 01:29 AM

        Do you know what it's called? I would like to try it.

        1. re: Humbucker
          berbere Jul 21, 2006 01:00 AM

          If I'm not mistaken, I believe the poster is referring to a stew called "chung gook jang" -- my family loves it and my mom makes it as often as she can, despite all the protestations about the stench. It's basically the same stuff that goes into dwaenjang but the soybean paste is not as far gone in the fermentation process.... anyways, the korean stores now carry chung gook jang but it's nowhere as stinky (or as good) as the real homemade stuff -- really, after we have this at home, the house is off limits to visitors for weeks! I don't know of any korean restos that make this though (at least not here in Toronto where I live)...

          1. re: berbere
            Brian S Jul 23, 2006 04:30 PM

            I've had this stew in a Korean restaurant in Manhattan that specializes in tofu (Cho Dang Gol Restaurant). The waiter looked horrified when I ordered it and strongly warned me against it. Usually, when that happens, I know I'm in for a wonderful treat. But this time the waiter was right and it nauseated me. As a point of pride, I ate every bit of the huge casserole. By the end, I got accustomed to it. But I never ordered it again.

            1. re: Brian S
              Humbucker Jul 23, 2006 11:38 PM

              Found it!


              Now I must track down a restaurant in my area (silicon valley) that serves it...

              1. re: Brian S
                dippedberry Jul 24, 2006 03:00 PM

                Was is ChoDangGol, Natural Tofu, LiHua or some other place?

        2. Jim Leff Jul 20, 2006 07:32 PM

          I don't have an "aversion" to stinky tofu (I have aversions to bologna, bleu cheese, and chocolate cheesecake). I'm not psychologically blocked or grossed out. I'm willing to eat it. I like the idea of it. I even love foo-yee, a near cousin (also a fermented tofu) which Cantonese people think NO gringos like.

          But the smell just turns my stomach. Cannot get near mouth. Purely visceral reaction.


          2 Replies
          1. re: Jim Leff
            missclaudy Jul 24, 2006 05:02 PM

            Thank God someone else (especially you dear Jim Leff) has an aversion to bleu cheese.Everyone loves bleu cheese and treats you like a psycho killer if you hate it.I've eaten guinea pigs, crickets, racoon,lobster guts are my favorite food but bleu cheese totally freaks me out.Everyone is always trying to make me eat it. (Shudder)

            1. re: missclaudy
              Jim Leff Jul 26, 2006 01:33 AM

              Bleu cheese tastes like plastic to me. I can choke it down, even gauge a "good" one. But it's just unfood-like to me. And I'm surprised more bleu lovers don't understand. I mean, I love cilantro, but I certainly understand why some don't. It's such a specific sort of taste, it's easy to imagine why some wouldn't deem it food.

          2. kerwintoronto Jul 20, 2006 10:54 PM

            Jim, I had my cousins trying to help me acquire the taste for 'stinky tofu' in HK every summer for almost 10 years. I agree whole stomachedly with your visceral reaction.

            There may be hope for us though ... after about 20 years of on and off exposure to durian I finally acquired the taste. And it used to taste as bad as it smelled (to me of course)...now I am waiting for my next dose. Luckily I am not addicted yet.

            16 Replies
            1. re: kerwintoronto
              Jim Leff Jul 21, 2006 12:45 AM

              I can do durian, in small amounts, as a milkshake. I can ingest it, I just have some...er...issues.

              Stinky tofu I can't get close. Weird that I like foo yee. Who knows.

              1. re: Jim Leff
                kerwintoronto Jul 21, 2006 02:50 AM

                Foo yee rocks!

                I find foo yee more along the lines of a ferment sweet/savory smell...like nuoc mam (fish sauce) or anchovy paste. I thnk stinky tofu is that plus another whole layer of fermenting/aging.

                I never got the stinky tofu to my lips so I can't say much as to the taste.

                1. re: kerwintoronto
                  jennjen18 Jul 31, 2006 03:06 AM

                  Funnily enough, stinky tofu doesnt taste how it smells! It tastes AWESOME if you can put the smell past your taste buds. Perhaps hold your nose next time, until you can get the tofu into your mouth, and then try tasting it. :) Oh, and the chilli sauce (dao ban jeung) helps too.

                2. re: Jim Leff
                  Melanie Wong Jul 26, 2006 01:35 AM

                  Are you allergic to penicillin?

                  1. re: Melanie Wong
                    Jim Leff Jul 26, 2006 04:58 AM

                    No, why? Do you suspect I'm somehow infected?

                    1. re: Jim Leff
                      Melanie Wong Jul 26, 2006 07:13 AM

                      No, no. Pencillium fungus puts the blue in blue cheese. I was musing that your taste aversion might be your body's way of protecting itself.

                    2. re: Melanie Wong
                      Caitlin McGrath Jul 28, 2006 05:30 AM

                      Don't think it works that way. My mother's allergic to penicillin and is fond of blue cheese, whereas I have no physical aversian to penicillin, but a definite "taste aversion" to blue cheese.

                  2. re: kerwintoronto
                    HLing Jul 24, 2006 03:12 AM

                    In Hong Kong, on burrow street at Wan Chai Rd there's a small take out place that makes better Fried Stinky Tofu than most other places. The light golden outer layer had this blistery (but fine) texture while the inside was honeycomb-like, and just the right driness. I think the guy makes it better than the woman. It's also especially good of course, just fresh out of the oil.

                    Someone asked if "anyone ever crave stinky tofu"...The answer is, "you have no idea how much!!!"

                    1. re: HLing
                      Gary Soup Jul 24, 2006 06:25 AM

                      Something like this specimen from Shanghai, perhaps.


                      1. re: Gary Soup
                        HLing Jul 24, 2006 09:38 PM

                        I wish I could post pictures and have them come up as fast and painlessly as yours....

                        Anyway, the ones from Hong Kong are pretty big and rectangular.

                        The ones from my childhood in Taiwan were square but much flatter and has almost nothing inside. so, pure fried tofu skin with a kick.

                        The ones from the US's Taiwanese restaurants are almost always like the ones in your picture....I guess things change within the same country through different times...

                        And how about the stinky tofu from Wu3Han4? Flat, black, not sure if it's even deep fried...but more like a dougan texture. Pretty good, too. In fact, if I couldn't have the ones from the olden time of Taiwan, I'd prefer this.....

                        Of course, the stinkiest might be the Shanghainese STEAMED stinky tofu...!!!

                        1. re: HLing
                          jennjen18 Jul 31, 2006 03:09 AM

                          Oh I've seen the blackened stinky fu's. They look horrid!!! They're so black I dont even wanna put it in my mouth. What makes them that black?

                      2. re: HLing
                        OnceUponABite Jul 28, 2006 02:25 AM

                        I totally crave stinky tofu! The good kind. BUT I'm sorry to say, last visit to Taiwan two years ago, I didn't find it all that great! My mom told me what I remembered from childhood were probably stinky tofu produced 'authentically', with real mold and rot :P While now days with sanitary standards, they can't possible produce the same kind of stink and taste. Alas, I think she might be right.. I tried stinky tofu in two different cities in Taiwan in four different street stalls, all were lacking.

                        I've not been to HK, but if I ever do, I will definitely check them out there too.

                        1. re: OnceUponABite
                          Gary Soup Jul 28, 2006 06:25 AM

                          Your mother is right. Here's the smoking gun.


                          1. re: Gary Soup
                            Blueicus Jul 28, 2006 06:35 AM

                            I went to HK half a year ago, and I must admit that although the smell of the tofu was quite pungent, I have to admit that the taste was less than overwhelming. Perhaps the sanitary standards got to them too (since street cart food is mostly illegal if not outright so these days in HK and has practically vanished from the cultural milieu of the city).

                            1. re: Gary Soup
                              Gary Soup Jul 28, 2006 06:44 AM

                              I spent three months in HK in 1997 and lived near the Temple Street Night Market. Every night a woman would show up and start frying stinky tofu on a portable burner. Every night the police would show up after about an hour and chase her away. The following night she would return. Her tofu was especially odoriforous, but delectable, and her regulars knew when to be there to score some.

                              1. re: Gary Soup
                                OnceUponABite Jul 28, 2006 04:10 PM

                                PRICELESS! Some scientist wrote a paper on stinky tofu! Now that's a real chowhound!

                        2. s
                          Steve Jul 22, 2006 04:23 PM

                          Excuse me, but has anyone yet said they actually crave the stuff?

                          I've had it once, at a very good Taiwanese restaurant, and the best I can say about it is that it doesn't taste as bad as it smells. But as a tofu lover I must say that I can think of hundreds of other versions I like better.

                          So can anyone tell me it's a taste worth developing?

                          3 Replies
                          1. re: Steve
                            Jim Leff Jul 22, 2006 05:10 PM

                            As you'll soon see (via a photo essay I"m working up), vast teeming hordes of people lined up for this stuff at the Toronto Night Market....

                            It's like stinky cheese. Love/hate.

                            1. re: Jim Leff
                              Robert Lauriston Jul 22, 2006 05:12 PM

                              Most stinky cheeses taste a lot better than they smell: Muenster and Liederkranz, for example, would be disgusting if they tasted the way they smell.

                              Stinky tofu, what you smell is pretty much what you get.

                              1. re: Jim Leff
                                Steve Jul 22, 2006 09:00 PM

                                Maybe.... one man's "smell" is another man's "aroma." But I have never smelled a stinky cheese that rivals stinky tofu. I look forward to seeing your photo essay! Too bad Smell-O-Rama never hit the Internet.

                                One question - did you wear nose plugs?

                            2. Robert Lauriston Jul 22, 2006 05:09 PM

                              I tried stinky tofu for the first time recently, plain deep-fried version at Spices!3 in Oakland. I liked it. The other three people at the table had a bite each if that, so I got to polish off the whole basket myself.

                              1. JMF Jul 23, 2006 02:00 PM

                                I have two different jars of fermented tofu in my pantry and have never gotten around to opening them.

                                I wonder how long it stays bad?

                                1 Reply
                                1. re: JMF
                                  steinpilz Jul 27, 2006 05:52 PM


                                2. shirlotta Jul 24, 2006 09:51 PM

                                  fermented tofu is very nice in small doses. it's especially good with kong shing tsai - erm, i don't know how to say it in english, but it's a green chinese vegetable with a hollow stalk and many leaves coming off of it in long tear drop shapes. sauteed with garlic and a litle fermented tofu - just for taste. maybe if you try it that way it'll be a little less offensive? also it is good in congee - just a small dab, mix it in. you may become used to it if you try small steps. it's really not meant to be eaten by the spoonful, although some people love it that much.

                                  i really hated bleu cheese for a whole long while, but then i had a little bit of bleu cheese with a pear and arugula salad, and i have turned into a stinky cheese lover! fermented tofu can do similar things for certain chinese dishes (like sauteed vegetables).

                                  8 Replies
                                  1. re: shirlotta
                                    Jim Leff Jul 26, 2006 01:34 AM

                                    shirlotta, the sort of fermented tofu you're referring to is "foo yee" (in Cantonese), which I, too, love....and which is indeed fairly cheesey.

                                    1. re: Jim Leff
                                      Gary Soup Jul 26, 2006 05:16 AM

                                      Foo Yee, a.k.a. sufu (in the north) is pretty tame compared to a good chou doufu. It's great in pao fan (a local version of jook).

                                      As usual, the redoubtable Soy Daily has a comprehensive treatment of fermented doufus:


                                      1. re: Jim Leff
                                        Pan Jul 26, 2006 11:24 AM

                                        I've also had it with nam yu, the red fermented tofu.

                                        1. re: Pan
                                          Blueicus Jul 26, 2006 04:25 PM

                                          Oh, I love nam yu, especially served with the crispy chicken. Thanks for reminding me... now I gotta go get some

                                      2. re: shirlotta
                                        Pan Jul 26, 2006 11:23 AM

                                        "it's especially good with kong shing tsai - erm, i don't know how to say it in english, but it's a green chinese vegetable with a hollow stalk and many leaves coming off of it in long tear drop shapes."

                                        Water spinach is the name I usually see here. In Malaysia, they call it kangkung, which comes from another Chinese dialect (I'm not sure which one).

                                        1. re: Pan
                                          Phoo D Jul 26, 2006 04:07 PM

                                          It sounds like on choi or ong choy (which is what my local Cantonese place calls it). Great with foo yee.


                                          1. re: Phoo D
                                            Pan Jul 28, 2006 05:34 AM

                                            That's right. I wasn't sure whether that was Cantonese or Mandarin. What's the Mandarin name for it? Kong shing tsai, as posted above?

                                            1. re: Pan
                                              limster Jul 30, 2006 02:56 AM

                                              Yep that's the approximate Mandarin pronunciation. (kong1 xin1 cai4 in pinyin)

                                      3. p
                                        Peter Cherches Jul 27, 2006 08:24 PM

                                        I'm one of the diners who donated my stinky tofu to Robert Lauriston.

                                        However, I do like ong choi with fermented bean curd sauce. Fine as a condiment (as is fermented shrimp sauce), but not as a main attraction for me.

                                        Jim, I hope your bologna aversion doesn't extend to mortadella.


                                        Show Hidden Posts