HOME > Chowhound > Ontario (inc. Toronto) >

Didier? or Le select?

j
j6p Jul 8, 2006 04:47 PM

I've been meaning to try these two restaurants but am not quite sure whether it is worth it or not.
There doesn't seem to be a lot of info on Didier and le select does not seem to be getting good reviews after JP Challet joined them at their new location.

Anyone been recently? comment?

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
Delete
  1. g
    gtw RE: j6p Jul 9, 2006 01:41 AM

    JP is no longer at Le Select so there may be an improvement (never thought I would say that). I was there shortly before he left and found the food mediocre - I am not sure it was all the fault of the preparation, I do not believe the quality of the raw materials was that good.
    Given this I would suggest Didier.

    1 Reply
    1. re: gtw
      estufarian RE: gtw Jul 10, 2006 03:00 PM

      Didier was awful both times I tried it. Second time was even worse, as the place was almost empty and the service was virtually non-existent (e.g. had to get up and walk over to our wine which was in an ice bucket about 12 feet from our table - and nobody even noticed). Won't be back.

    2. Tara9000 RE: j6p Jul 10, 2006 03:11 PM

      My recent experience at Le Select was mediocre at best. The worst part was the waiter being extremely condescending, and talking down to us like we'd never been to a 'nicer' restaurant before. The bread was almost as hard as a hockey puck, the steak tartar flavorless, and the steak from the steak frites was overcooked, and the frites soggy.

      1 Reply
      1. re: Tara9000
        a
        artificialard RE: Tara9000 Jul 23, 2006 11:33 PM

        Interesting that you mention that because my last experience was dreadful at Le Select. It was a Sunday night.

        We had been to the new location twice before and had excellent experiences there: good food, very nice service, etc. and decided to take relatives from out of town there for dinner thinking it was a safe bet. So very wrong we were. Keep in mind I had made reservations more than 4 days in advance.

        We were seated by the host quickly enough and was greeted by an extremely sweaty and harried waiter who had the bread and water brought over. It took more than 15 minutes for him to come back for the 'drink' order by which time we were ready to order the whole meal. What followed was the oddest and most audacious experience I ever remember:
        -One person in our party orders the steak tartare. The waiter asks "How well would you like it done?" to which she just asks "What?" and he asks again "How WELL would you like it done?" with tone and she says "I'm ordering the tartare..." to which he just says "Oh right." and moves on.
        -There's a boy in our group about 15 who orders the steak and orders it rare. Our waiter sounds like a paranoid health inspector "Are you SURE you want it rare. Most people who order it rare find it's too raw and bloody..." And the boy starts to get all perplexed but the rest of our group pipe up and tell the server want it rare. THe boy's father orders the same and the waiter AGAIN asks if he's "sure" he wants it rare "too".
        The whole ordering experience was ridiculous and terribly condescending to a group that has ordered steak often enough.

        The waiter of course disappears and it is literally in excess of 40 minutes before our food comes. During that time we see him maybe once at the 30 minute mark and simply explains there's a 'large party' out front. There were no particularly large tables that I saw and really I don't see how that's an excuse given I made the reservation. Nothing was offered (not even an apology).

        The food however was excellent, I had the cassoulet which I enjoyed, the steaks were FINE, and the tartare made surprisingly well. All of the bus people were very nice and accomadating to take orders of extra bread and water while our water was AWOL.

        On the whole I have to chalk it up to a horrible waiter and regret not calling to complain the next day. Still I will probably return because my other two visits were very nice and the cuisine was uniformly well done throughout each visit. But ugh.

      2. b
        bogie RE: j6p Jul 10, 2006 09:32 PM

        I would have to go with...NEITHER!

        For better value and true bistro vibe, try Le Paradis or Batifole.

        1 Reply
        1. re: bogie
          Charles Yu RE: bogie Jul 11, 2006 12:44 AM

          For bistro fare, Pastis Express, Sequel and Mirabelle, all along Yonge, should provide you with a much more enjoyable experience. Both food and services for all three establishments are consistently good! 'Didier' - just one remark! Way over-rated!!! Mediocre food from both the Fifth and his current location. For the money, I would go to Splendido instead, any time!!

        2. t
          to_frankie RE: j6p Jul 23, 2006 10:21 PM

          I would choose Le Select over Didier. Especially for the wine list.

          1 Reply
          1. re: to_frankie
            i
            intheweedss RE: to_frankie Oct 20, 2006 04:31 AM

            splendido..for sure..love david lee...and yannick is fantastic in the front of the house..have not gone lately but it was wonderful when we went..

          2. f
            FoodNazi RE: j6p Oct 27, 2006 06:21 AM

            What Bogie said...

            1. midtowngirl RE: j6p Oct 27, 2006 04:41 PM

              I had an experience very similar to the one described by artificialard at Le Select recently. We waited forever for a server to show up and when we finally tracked one down ourserlves the service was atrocious and the waiter made fun of one of our guests for his indecisiveness over the menu choices. We ordered a rather expensive wine from the very extensive wine list, but never saw anyone after the wine was poured into a carafe so we just served ourselves and when the carafe was empty it was whisked away without any inquiries as to whether we would like another bottle. We did not receive proper cutlery for the food we ordered and finally managed to hail a busboy partway through the meal because no one else seemed to be around. Three of the six people at the table barely touched their main courses and no one asked why.

              I followed up with the owner and he said he would make it up to us, but I have not heard from him again. None of us will go back again.

              Show Hidden Posts