Psst... We're working on the next generation of Chowhound! View >
HOME > Chowhound > Cookware >
Jul 5, 2006 08:46 PM

Ice cream makers [Moved from Home Cooking]

I want to buy an ice cream maker. A friend has recommended the Lello Il Gelato 1-quart model, which is a bit pricey (between $160 and $200, depending on the source). Anyone have any other recommendations?

Thanks in advance,

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
  1. I've had a Krups for quite a few years and have been perfectly happy with it, but recently have been reading good things about the one that Cuisinart put on the market this year. I have my eye on that one now and it's well under $100.

    1. It depends how much you want to spend and how much space you have.

      Cuisinart and Deni have $50 machines that you can find anywhere (and get for less if you're patient and scour Amazon and for sales--mine was $25). They're well liked on this board, and I've had my Cuisinart for a few years without problems.

      If you have counter space and want to spend more money, the machines that don't require any pre-freezing and/or can freeze more than 2 qts or multiple batches at a time seem pretty nifty, but I haven't tried any.

      1. Have you seen the Ice Cream Ball ice cream makers? You can get them at REI or Amazon or LL Bean--places like that. Very fun for parties and picnics and camping... There's a canister that sits inside the ball that you fill with the ice cream ingredients, then seal off with the lid. Then, insert the canister and fill the rest of the ball with salt and ice. Toss the ball around for a bit and, presto!, you've got ice cream. Very fun. They run about $30.00 for the pint size. You can also get a double for, I think, $35-$40.

        Not practical for every day use, but certainly fun for those outdoor occasions.


        1. The Lello machine has an excellent pedigree as they were formerly made under the Simac brand. Even though it seems a little expensive, it will give you years of pleasure.

          BTW, it is more expensive because it has it's own compressor and doesn't rely on a bowl that has to be pre-frozen.

          I recommend it over others because of it's quiet operation, ease of cleaning/sanitizing and the soft,creamy ice creams with great mouth-feel that it produces.

          1 Reply
          1. re: bogie

            I also have the Lello which Amazon often highly discounts...and have had NO problems with it...and i really like that I don't have to remember in advance to put a container in the fridge to pre freeze...also frees up freezer space.

          2. Any comments on the ice cream maker for a KitchenAid mixer? It seems like a great add-on, but wouldn't want to buy 'til I heard from users.

            1 Reply
            1. re: sgtyson

              I have one and like it. It will take up to 2 quarts, unlike most ice cream makers which limit you to 1 quart. The motor has plenty of power so I never worry about not being able to churn through the thickening mixture. OTOH it's fairly expensive compared to the smaller units. The manual recommends 15 hours of pre-freezing before you can use it, and it generally does take that long. If you're going a large batch you have to chill the mixture for about 8 hours, so this is not something you make on impulse.

              I also have a Deni with 2 bowls so I can do multiple flavors in small quantities. It was fairly inexpensive so I thought it useful when I'm in the mood to make a lot of ice cream. Pre-freezing is faster (smaller bowl) so is handy when you're in a hurry.